Registry Operator's Proposal
September 29, 2000
Signature : |
I. GENERAL INFORMATION
D1. The first section of the Registry Operator's Proposal (after the signed copy of this page) should be a listing of the following information about the registry operator. Please key your responses to the designators (D1, D2, D3, etc.) below.
Signed copy of the cover page attached.
D2. The full legal name, principal address, telephone and fax numbers, and e-mail address of the registry operator.
Sarnoff Corporation (Sarnoff), in cooperation with AtomicTangerine Inc. (AtomicTangerine), is filing the "Registry Operator’s Proposal". NextDNS is a newly created entity that has been formed with the intention of operating the Registry and executing the business plan as outlined in this proposal. Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine are committed to supporting NextDNS’s operation of the Registry.
Full Legal Name: Principal Address: Main Tel. Number: Fax: email: |
Sarnoff Corporation |
Full Legal Name: Principal Address: Main Tel. Number: Fax: email: |
AtomicTangerine, Inc. |
Full Legal Name: Principal Address: Main Tel. Number: Fax: email: |
NextDNS, Inc. |
D3. The addresses and telephone and fax numbers of all other business locations of the registry operator.
Sarnoff Corporation |
Other Business Locations of AtomicTangerine: |
|
333 Ravenswood Avenue |
1001 Marina Village Parkway |
302 South 9th Street, Suite 201 |
1 Batterymarch Park |
440 9th Avenue - 11th Floor |
1611 North Kent Street |
6666 Gunpark Drive |
Daito Building - Second Floor |
2 Manchester Square |
Principal Address of SRI International: |
333 Ravenswood Ave. |
D4. The registry operator's type of business entity (e.g., corporation, partnership, etc.) and law (e.g., Denmark) under which it is organized.
For NextDNS:
Type of business entity: Delaware Corporation
Law: United States of America.
For Sarnoff:
Type of business entity: New Jersey Corporation
Law: United States of America.
For AtomicTangerine:
Type of business entity: Delaware Corporation
Law: United States of America.
D5. URL of registry operator's principal world wide web site.
www.nextdnsinc.com
www.sarnoff.com
www.atomictangerine.com
D6. Dun & Bradstreet D-U-N-S Number (if any) of registry operator.
NextDNS: Not yet assigned
Sarnoff: 17-552-1103
AtomicTangerine: 12-675-1663
NextDNS: N/A (new entity)
Sarnoff: 800 Full time employees
AtomicTangerine: 250 Full time employees
D8. Registry operator's total revenue (in US dollars) in the last-ended fiscal year.
Sarnoff: US$116,915,000.00
AtomicTangerine: N/A (has not yet completed a full fiscal year)
D9. Full names and positions of (i) all directors, (ii) all officers, (iii) all relevant managers, and (iv) any persons or entities owning five percent or more of registry operator.
Sarnoff Directors: |
|
(Dr.) James E. Carnes |
Alan C. Herzig |
Paul M. Cook |
John A. Rollwagen |
(Dr.) Henry Kressel |
Samuel H. Armacost |
Sarnoff Officers: |
|
Paul M. Cook |
Carmen A. Catanese |
Robert A. Bartolini |
James S. Crofton |
James E. Carnes |
Michael Ettenberg |
Susan T. Gauff |
Anne M. VanLent |
Patrick J. Murphy |
Norman Winarsky |
William J. Burke |
Robert E. Harris |
Other relevant managers from Sarnoff assisting in the creation/launch of NextDNS: |
|
Jim Bergen |
Shailendra Suman |
Rafael Alonso |
AtomicTangerine Directors |
|
Jonathan Fornaci |
Don Robertson |
Jeff Chambers |
Samuel H. Armacost |
Bill Sommers |
Curt Carlson |
AtomicTangerine Officers |
|
Jonathan Fornaci |
Samuel H. Armacost |
Mark Campion |
Alan Weindorf |
Don Robertson |
Patricia Bovan |
Other relevant managers from AtomicTangerine assisting in the creation/launch of NextDNS: |
|
Norm Nielsen |
Steve Whitlock |
Laura Bilodeau |
Sue Mundell |
The principal stakeholders of NextDNS include Sarnoff, AtomicTangerine, and Arnhold and S. Bleichroeder, Inc. Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine are currently engaged in discussions with various parties worldwide to expand the ownership and advisory base of NextDNS to include other global corporations and organizations.
D10. Name, telephone and fax number, and e-mail address of person to contact for additional information regarding this proposal. If there are multiple people, please list all their names, telephone and fax numbers, and e-mail addresses and describe the areas as to which each should be contacted.
Mr. Shailendra Suman
Telephone: (609) 734-3137
Fax: (609) 514-4061
Email : ssuman@sarnoff.com
D11. The full legal name, principal address, telephone and fax numbers, e-mail address, and Dun & Bradstreet D-U-N-S Number (if any) of all subcontractors identified in item D15.3 below.
Full Legal Name: Principal Address: Main Tel. Number: Fax: email: DUNS |
Exodus Communications 2831 Mission College Blvd., Santa Clara, CA 95054 (408) 346-2200 1 (888) 302-8855 inquiry@exodus.net 80-230-4923 |
D12. The second section of the Registry Operator’s Proposal (after the "General Information" section) is a description of the registry operator’s Business Capabilities and Plan. This section must include a comprehensive, professional-quality business plan that provides detailed, verified business and financial information about the registry operator. The topics listed below are representative of the type of subjects that will be covered in the Business Capabilities and Plan section of the Registry Operator’s Proposal.
[INSTRUCTION: ICANN will extensively review and analyze this section of the Registry Operator’s Proposal. The content, clarity, and professionalism of this section will be important factors in ICANN’s evaluation of applications. We strongly recommend securing professional assistance from financial and management consultants to aid in the formulation of your business plan, in securing the necessary sources of financing, and in preparation of this section.]
D13.1. Detailed description of the registry operator's capabilities. This should describe general capabilities and activities. This description also offers the registry operator an opportunity to demonstrate the extent of its business and managerial expertise in activities relevant to the operation of the proposed registry. The following items should, at a bare minimum, be covered:
Note from Applicant: Answers to specific questions for subsections D13.1.1 follow the introduction given below. Sarnoff would welcome the opportunity to meet personally with the ICANN Board, its staff and all interested members of the ICANN community to discuss this proposal and the promise of this new TLD and its associated services and technologies.
INTRODUCTION
Sarnoff Corporation (Sarnoff), in cooperation with AtomicTangerine, Inc. (Atomic Tangerine), is submitting this application on behalf of its new venture, NextDNS, Inc.
Sarnoff, AtomicTangerine, and their parent company, SRI International, have a long, illustrious history of spurring technological innovation. Over the past five decades, their companies and inventions have revolutionized the way the world works, plays, and communicates. This Registry Operator license for a new Top Level Domain (TLD) will enable the creation of pioneering services around the proposed TLD that will offer great enhancements to the way people communicate and how future business, leisure, and personal activities are conducted around the world.
The mission of the Registry is to provide a service provider-invariant Personal Domain Name to individuals that will enable them to configure any or all of their digital communications – whether via e-mail, cell phone, PDA, or pager - to their liking, using services offered by various vendors who will adopt the proposed domain as a platform for value-added services targeted at individuals.
With the convergence of information delivery services and, in particular, the adoption of wireless messaging and location services, there is a need for a central invariant point of contact around which an individual may configure and coordinate his or her access to such services. Our proposed Personal Domain Name will provide an innovative solution to the growing problem of information overload at the individual level, relying on the Internet’s Domain Name System. Unlike the naming conventions used in today’s .com, .edu, and .org domains, the applicant’s proposed domain will be people-centered rather than entity specific, enabling each person in the world to have his or her own Personal Domain Name, thus increasing the usefulness and reach of the DNS.
The proposed TLD will provide numerous benefits to individuals and to societies as a whole. In addition to creating a permanent, private, simpler means of communication, the TLD will also reduce switching barriers for individuals and their information appliances, thereby sparking enhanced competition among Access Service Providers and Telecom companies as well as cell phone, handheld, and paging manufacturers. The expansion of the DNS to serve the personal needs of Internet users and their information appliances is truly the next step in the evolution of the Internet. In bringing these benefits and services to individual Internet users, the proposed Registry will create new business opportunities that were not possible before. With their combined histories of exceptional technological innovation and successful new business creation, Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine are uniquely suited to lead the charge in enabling the next generation applications of the DNS that benefit all Internet users.
Notably, Sarnoff has a legacy as a leading and trusted developer of enabling platform technologies by which third party developers may enter new frontiers. Sarnoff’s neutrality among commercial developers utilizing Sarnoff developments, and commitment to expanding opportunities for competitive commercialization of new technologies are widely known. The objective of this proposal is to open new frontiers in the development and delivery of individualized personal services on a global scale and egalitarian basis. Sarnoff possesses the technical depth and experience in collaborative development of new technologies to make the ideal of "the Internet for everyone" a reality.
Sarnoff Corporation
Sarnoff is a global organization that has created some of the most pervasive technologies of the century. Sarnoff has a world-renowned history as a premier developer of entertainment, consumer, and commercial products that have fundamentally changed the modern world. Many of the products used by consumers today were invented by Sarnoff. In fact, Sarnoff has not only been a leader in industry, it has helped create new industries.
Sarnoff was established in 1942 as RCA Laboratories, the central research organization for the RCA Corporation. In April 1987 it became a subsidiary of SRI International, as part of an agreement with GE.
Sarnoff remains a leading global organization in video, broadcasting, and displays and has a worldwide reputation in the following areas of expertise. With the convergence of the Internet and broadcast media, and the promise of "Internet Everywhere", many of these technologies are becoming ever increasingly important to the Internet space.
Successful New Venture Creation: Sarnoff has a solid track record of successfully nurturing and spinning off new technology ventures regularly during the past 10 years. Sarnoff builds value and other sources of continuing revenue through equity positions in ventures that make use of its technical innovations. These ventures, referred to as Sarnoff Technology Ventures (STVs), reflect the breadth and depth of Sarnoff’s technology and managerial capabilities.
Sarnoff incubates these companies, building the value in each company by developing its technology to a pre-commercial level, and then raising funds for commercialization. Exclusive licenses may be granted to STVs in Sarnoff’s intellectual property in specific fields of use. Sarnoff’s staff acts to fill critical technical and leadership roles in the company until the STV can recruit a full management and technical team and reach critical mass on its own.
The benefit of this model is that Sarnoff lowers the risk of execution and can deliver on its commitments by having a team in place that has delivered on many highly challenging problems and milestones. This established business model has been put into practice to create many new companies over the past 10 years (see Appendix A). The proposed Registry Operator is a Sarnoff venture company. Sarnoff will assist in gaining the appropriate managerial, technological, and financial capital required for the successful operation of the Registry.
Tradition of Technological Innovation and Excellence: Today, Sarnoff is one of the most productive creators of technology in the US. Sarnoff’s partners and clients include multinational corporations, government agencies, research universities and leading high-tech organizations including Motorola, Thomson Multimedia, Toshiba, SmithKline Beecham, and government organizations such as the National Imagery and Mapping Agency (NIMA) and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA).
Sarnoff has been vigorously developing capabilities in database management systems (DBMS) for commercial and government applications. These include Distributed Databases; Mobile Database Systems; Object-Oriented DBMS; Object-relational DBMS; Information System Architecture; Data Caching and Replication; DBMS Query Optimization; Distributed File Systems; Video on Demand; and Multimedia Storage Systems.
Sarnoff has also developed techniques for capturing and tracking information about an analysis process and enabling access to that information through querying and visualization processes. This approach, embodied in an object-oriented database framework, also provides a mechanism for explicit sharing of information among analysts. These techniques have been applied to a wide range of collaborative tasks including mapping (Infobase), open source analysis (NSA/ADE) and distance education (CLASS). For information on additional Sarnoff technologies, please see Section D15.1.
Sarnoff’s broad business base gives it a unique "high ground" perspective on emerging technologies. Sarnoff participates in the invention and development of hundreds of solutions for hundreds of companies. It works with trailblazers, setting industry trends and standards. Because it serves all major technology industries, Sarnoff is a unique resource in the development of products that are at the convergence of these technologies. Furthermore, Sarnoff brings the unique combination of broad commercial experience and broad government experience.
With a 58-year record of significant scientific contributions, achievements, inventions, collaborative development of new technologies, global standards and alliances creation, and successful new business creation, Sarnoff is well positioned to lead the charge in managing the proposed TLD as well as creating and enabling the related next generation of Internet applications.
National and World Record of Achievements: Sarnoff’s groundbreaking contributions to technology have changed the way we live: television, CRTs, CMOS ICs, laser diodes for CDs, LCDs, DVI, solid-state imagers, solid-state amplifiers for satellite transmission, the new HDTV standard, and DirecTV. In high bandwidth communications, Sarnoff’s R&D achievements include the US digital HDTV standard, new multimedia distribution systems (MMDS), and terrestrial and satellite communications developments. Sarnoff has assumed a leadership position in biotechnology with the development of the world’s first all-electronic fluid IC switch technology, with application to genomics and combinatorial chemistry.
Among the awards won by Sarnoff are seven Emmys for technical excellence. In like vein, Sarnoff intends to enable the next generation of pioneering technologies and services based on the Internet’s Domain Name System that will affect important aspects of our lives in beneficial ways. Some of the highlights of Sarnoff’s technology are detailed below (for a complete list, see Section D.15 and Appendix B, a Business Week article on Sarnoff and SRI International).
Sarnoff’s Pioneering Technologies |
||
1964 |
CMOS |
Developed the MOS (metal oxide semiconductor) transistor, the basis of C (complementary) MOS technology, one of the "bedrock" technologies for integrated circuits (ICs) worldwide. |
1968 |
Liquid-Crystal Display Technology |
Liquid-crystal display (LCD) technology was developed by Sarnoff scientists, who formulated both basic theory and the first LCD displays. |
1982 |
Pyramid-Based Image Processing |
Pyramid-based image processing technology developed at Sarnoff has become the basis for computerized vision technology and real-time processing of live video. |
1988 |
Sarnoff Engine Supercomputer |
The Sarnoff Engine is a massively parallel supercomputer developed to process video and imagery in real time. A Sarnoff spin-off company, Diva, is an outgrowth of this technology. |
1991 |
Advanced Digital HDTV |
As part of the competition to establish standards for HDTV, the next generation of television, Sarnoff developed a digital high-definition television (HDTV) system for FCC testing and approval. |
1994 |
Phosphor Tags |
A combination of Sarnoff phosphors are used to uniquely identify currency for security. Users can authenticate documents and parts quickly and reliably. |
1995 |
Grand Alliance HDTV |
In conjunction with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the Grand Alliance consortium was formed to develop and test the new HDTV system; Sarnoff’s contributions included two key elements -- a prioritized packetized data transport structure and a data compression scheme based on MPEG. The FCC adopted the Grand Alliance system for broadcasting HDTV as the US standard in December 1996. |
1999 |
Emmy Award |
Awarded for Sarnoff's Compliance Bitstreams, a comprehensive and easy-to-use set of analysis tools that allows receiver manufacturers, broadcasters, and makers of computer video boards to determine whether receivers will reliably decode complex digital and high definition television (DTV/HDTV) signals. |
Proactive Leadership: Sarnoff is proactive in developing corporate, Government, and academic partnerships and commercializing technologies. This is Sarnoff’s business model. For example, Sarnoff was a major developer of the Advanced Television Research Consortium, and when the HDTV "Grand Alliance" was formed its members (AT&T, Zenith, Thomson, Philips, General Instrument, MIT) selected Sarnoff to be the host and site of HDTV system integration. Sarnoff is leading the team (IBM, HP, Philips) that is developing the next generation digital broadcast equipment. Sarnoff is also the technical lead for the model HDTV station in Washington, DC.
Sarnoff partnerships have significantly influenced a broad range of research areas as diverse as plasma physics, electronic highway and auto controls, ultrasonics in medicine, hyperthermia cancer research, solar energy, and solid state amplifiers for satellite communications. Some examples are:
High Definition Television (HDTV) — Sarnoff was originally a member of a competitive group, the Advanced Television Research Consortium and continues as an active participant in the Grand Alliance Consortium (made up of General Instruments, MIT, AT&T, Zenith, Thomson, and Philips). The Grand Alliance produced the "best of the best" HDTV system, approved by the FCC in December 1996.
Consortium for Educational Process and Technology (CEPT) — CEPT is an alliance of Sarnoff, Educational Testing Service (ETS), and the Williamstown Education Foundation to develop collaborative and long-distance learning techniques.
Phosphor Technology Center of Excellence Consortium — DARPA recognizes that phosphor technology plays a key role in most display systems and funds a Phosphor Technology Center of Excellence (PTCOE). Sarnoff is a member of the group selected to establish this Center. Sarnoff’s partners in the PTCOE include Georgia Institute of Technology, University of Florida, Oregon State University, University of Georgia, Pennsylvania State University, and the American Display Consortium.
NIDL — Since 1990, Sarnoff has hosted the National Information Display Laboratory (NIDL), partnering with the best of American industry and academia to answer the demands and needs of the US Government for rapidly changing technology. Given the NIDL unique mission and the consortium nature of its charter, Sarnoff has been fostered many forms of commercial, academic, and Government partnerships as NIDL’s host.
AtomicTangerine
AtomicTangerine was launched on December 26, 1999 as a spin-off of the consulting practice of SRI International, one of the world’s foremost technology innovation centers and the parent company of Sarnoff. AtomicTangerine is the first e-business venture consulting firm, combining the disciplines of venture capital, technology innovation and strategic consulting, to create category killers and incubate new industries for companies of all sizes and at all stages of evolution. AtomicTangerine’s delivery model facilitates rapid solutions that enable companies to go from concept to reality in 20 weeks or less. This model uses high-level customized approaches that apply revolutionary technology and futuristic thinking to create and sustain competitive advantage.
Within this framework, AtomicTangerine is capable of everything from turning an innovative idea into a successful business to completely revamping an entire e-commerce/e-business platform for a major corporation. Core capabilities include consulting practices in the Internet, telecommunications, supply chain management, and financial services sectors. Top-tier clients include Motorola, Sprint, Vodafone, NTT Data Corporation, Charles Schwab, DuPont, Bank of America, Prudential, Sainsbury Bank, Blakely Sokoloff, Mitsubishi Electric, and Oki-Electric. Internet clients include Amazon.com, Extant, Smile, Dream Train Internet, Hellonetwork.com, Informix, Intermec, Luna, Vitessa, and Worldspan.
Unparalleled expertise in Information Security: AtomicTangerine (and prior to that, SRI Consulting) is world-renowned for its information security practice. The AtomicTangerine Information Security practice is staffed by industry leading security professionals who have conducted more than 500 information security reviews worldwide and 3,500 cases in computer crime for financial services organizations, telecommunications companies, and the U.S. Departments of Justice and Defense. The company hosts the International Information Integrity Institute (I-4®), providing ongoing best practices and information security breakthroughs for a closed-door, invite-only list of FORTUNE 500 companies and government agencies. AtomicTangerine’s Information Security professionals will provide key insights and input as the Registry prepares to run the proposed TLD.
AtomicTangerine’s experienced management team combines skills from the high tech, Internet, e-commerce, management consulting, and research sectors. The company, which operates out of 12 offices, maintains three overseas offices (in London, Tokyo, and Zurich) allowing it to better understand and serve its global customers throughout the world. AtomicTangerine’s employees represent diverse international heritages and are expected to bring their unique cultural perspectives to their consulting work.
AtomicTangerine’s in-depth business expertise will serve as a complement to Sarnoff’s core strengths in technology. As sister companies, Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine share many of the same values, especially the driving passion to use technology to change the world.
D13.1.1. Company information. Date of formation, legal status, primary location, size of staff, formal alliances, references, corporate or other structure, ownership structure.
Sarnoff Corporation |
AtomicTangerine |
|
Date of Formation |
Founded in 1987 as the successor to RCA Laboratories, which was founded in 1942. |
Launched on December 26, 1999 as a spin-off of SRI International. |
Legal Status |
C Corporation under the laws of the state of New Jersey |
C Corporation under the laws of the state of Delaware |
Primary Location |
201 Washington Road Princeton, NJ 08540 Tel: 609-734-2000 Fax: 609-734-2040 |
149 New Montgomery St. San Francisco, California 94105 Tel: 415-901-4840 Fax: 415-901-4885 |
Size of Staff |
800 |
250 |
Formal Alliances |
Various corporations, governments, agencies, and entities worldwide. |
SRI International, Nuance Communications, Oracle, CommerceOne, Blaze Software, Diverse Networks, and Sarnoff |
Client References |
MEMC Motorola Thomson Toshiba SmithKline Beecham Various other corporations, agencies, entities worldwide – names can be provided upon request |
Motorola DuPont Blakely Sokoloff Taylor & Zafman County of San Mateo Extant Sprint Smile Mitsubishi Electric Oki Electric |
Corporate Structure |
Privately-held |
Privately-held |
Ownership Structure |
SRI International (100%) |
SRI International (40%) TA Associates Sienna Holdings LeMans Investment Co. Mitsubishi Electric Information Network Corporation Oki Electric Industry Co. Ltd. Nippon System Development Co. Ltd. Employees |
D13.1.2. Current business operations. Core capabilities, services offered, products offered, duration of provision of services and products.
Sarnoff Corporation |
AtomicTangerine |
|
Core Capabilities |
|
|
Services Offered & Duration |
|
|
D13.1.3. Past business operations/entity history. History, date of formation, legal status/type of entity, initial services, duration of provision of services and products.
RCA Laboratories/ Sarnoff Corporation |
Stanford Research Institute /SRI International/ AtomicTangerine |
|
History |
Founded in 1987 as the successor to RCA Laboratories, which was founded in 1942 |
Spun out of SRI International (which was founded as Stanford Research Institute (SRI) in 1946. |
Date of Formation |
1987 |
1999 |
Legal Status/Type of Entity |
Privately held C Corporation, under the laws of the state of New Jersey |
Privately held C Corporation, under the laws of the state of Delaware |
Initial Services |
|
|
Services Provided & Duration |
|
Consulting (1 year as AtomicTangerine, 15 years as SRI Consulting) |
D13.1.4. Registry/database/Internet related experience and activities. Experience with database operation, Internet service provision.
Registry Experience — The parent of both Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine, SRI International’s precursor – Stanford Research Institute – was one of the original creators of the ARPAnet, including developing and managing HOSTS.TXT (DNS’s predecessor). Later, when HOSTS.TXT encountered difficulties scaling to accommodate the exponential growth in Internet use, SRI International helped to craft a new standard, the Domain Name System (DNS). With 15 years of experience as the first operator of Internet domains, SRI International has a unique and in-depth understanding of how to develop and maintain a successful Registry Operation. SRI International’s collective history and experience will assist the Registry in creating and maintaining an efficient, quality Registry for the proposed TLD.
Database Experience — Sarnoff has been vigorously developing capabilities in database management systems (DBMS) for commercial and government applications. These include: Distributed Databases; Mobile Database Systems; Object-Oriented DBMS; Object-relational DBMS; Information System Architecture; Data Caching and Replication; DBMS Query Optimization; Distributed File Systems; Video on Demand; and Multimedia Storage Systems.
Sarnoff has also developed techniques for capturing and tracking information about an analysis process and enabling access to that information through querying and visualization processes. This approach, embodied in an object-oriented database framework, also provides a mechanism for explicit sharing of information among analysts. These techniques have been applied to a wide range of collaborative tasks including mapping (Infobase), open source analysis (NSA/ADE) and distance education (CLASS).
Internet Experience — AtomicTangerine (and before that, SRI Consulting) has a thriving Internet consulting practice. Highlights include:
Amazon.com: AtomicTangerine is currently architecting and implementing an intelligent data management solution for Amazon.com’s warehouse and data mining applications. AtomicTangerine’s work will enable amazon.com to dramatically improve their access to years of detailed historical data. Once the project is completed, Amazon.com should realize a data management and storage cost reduction of at least 60%, and be able to access terabytes of data that could not be easily accessed previously.
Smile: The first true U.K. Internet bank, offering a full range of accounts at competitive rates. AtomicTangerine was engaged to reengineer Smile’s existing site to new brand guidelines, and to enhance and revitalize the existing customer experience. The AtomicTangerine team is providing assistance with creation of business requirements and functional specifications, recreation of the site structure/information architecture, redesign of the existing site, and creation and assistance with site marketing and PR.
Informix: Well-known for its database products, Informix has engaged AtomicTangerine to evaluate greenfield opportunities in the Internet and mobile market spaces. Informix seeks to recast itself as a solutions provider to address new opportunities presented by the Internet.
eRockefeller: eRockefeller is an early-stage firm seeking to build an online exchange in a specific financial services arena. The founders asked AtomicTangerine to cofound the venture; AtomicTangerine has agreed to cofound the company and to build the site prototype, and will receive 100% of the compensation for this in the form of equity.
In addition to e-business strategy and Internet design and development expertise, AtomicTangerine also has deep knowledge of Internet security issues, having grown a world-renowned information security practice that encompasses all facets of security, including cyber-security. As a major sponsor and the host of the May, 2000 Internet Defense Summit, AtomicTangerine was a key player in crafting the first Internet security "Priority Action Plan" for Global 1000 companies.
D13.1.5. Mission. The registry operator's mission and how it relates to expansion into the registry operation field.
The Registry’s mission is to create a new TLD to provide the underpinnings for the next generation of applications and services that benefit all Internet users. Leveraging Sarnoff’s and AtomicTangerine’s history of creating technologies that change the world, the Registry’s new TLD will enable every user to have a personal domain name that serves as a service provider-invariant point of contact, globally, through which various services and applications can be enabled that are of great benefit. True to the spirit of the Internet, Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine are interested in making the power of the DNS pervasive and available to every Internet user.
Sarnoff has a heritage of independence and of creating and promoting technologies that benefit the widest possible audience. This stands in contrast to a service provider or to a product or software manufacturer who may have an interest in building in high switching costs so as to lock-in the customer. Sarnoff is committed to supporting the proposed Registry’s goal of enabling the services and applications around the proposed Personal Domain Name system in a fair and open standards manner. Development of services and applications on top of the enabling platform will be open to everyone, including participation by ISPs, telecom and wireless providers, application and software system developers, etc.
The Registry will bring together global Internet communities to develop the next generation of services and applications based on the proposed TLD. Schematic of the proposed vision appears above.
Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine together provide unique strengths that are essential for this important mission to enable the next generation applications of the DNS in order to bring the benefits of the DNS to all Internet users:
Sarnoff has played a pioneering role in the creation, sustenance, and growth of some of the most pervasive consumer technologies. Sarnoff, together with AtomicTangerine, is the ideal team to assume the leading role in enabling the use of the DNS for individual Internet users.
D13.1.6. Management. Qualifications and experience of financial and business officers and other relevant employees. Please address/include past experience, resumes, references, biographies.
Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine both attribute their success to their greatest asset: their people. Both sister firms have created a culture of proactive leadership at every level of the organization.
At Sarnoff, "champions" are any members of the staff who have agreed to take responsibility for the success of a program; who are passionate and articulate about their vision; who have the breadth of knowledge and experience to succeed; and who are leaders, and have teams who believe in them and will follow them. In addition, Sarnoff’s management, scientists, and engineers are leaders in scientific, engineering, and professional societies and technology conferences, both national and international. As technology leaders they present and publish papers on state of the art technical results and program developments. Often they are active in the leadership and management of those societies and conferences.
At AtomicTangerine, the venture consulting model has infused the firm with an emphasis on entrepreneurial skills and a strong culture of entrepreneurship. Employees share their clients’ mission to create breakthrough services that provide sustainable competitive advantage, and often receive an equity stake in the client. In doing so they become true partners with the client, and hence many AtomicTangerine employees have borne the weighty responsibility of launching new businesses that depend on their management, technology, and strategy expertise. The following list of new ventures provides a solid example of AtomicTangerine’s ability to build teams and companies internally as well as externally, as well as to find them funding:
Security Portal: An in-house team had developed an information-security vulnerability benchmarking methodology using extensive network attack data. Based on those data, AtomicTangerine created a spin-off company and built it into a portal for online information security content and consulting. As a result of this work, AtomicTangerine obtained US $5.5 M of funding on a US $20 M valuation.
AtRisk: Based on the same benchmarking data, AtomicTangerine partnered with Lloyd's of London to create an insurance company that insures against losses due to security breaches. AtomicTangerine is now building the prototype, and has obtained term sheets for US $2-3 M of funding.
Motorola: Motorola approached AtomicTangerine with a new technology for which they had built a small initial prototype. AtomicTangerine developed the complete spec for the commercial prototype by bringing together experts from SRI, Composite Optics Inc., Motorola, and in-house experts at AtomicTangerine. Based on that spec, the venture is now obtaining A-round funding (term sheet is currently being finalized) and AtomicTangerine will go forward with them to implement the new technology.
eRockefeller: This pre-seed start-up seeks to create an online exchange for high net worth individuals and disintermediate the traditional brokerages in the process. They approached AtomicTangerine to cofound the firm with them and to assist with the full Web site buildout, strategy, and branding. AtomicTangerine worked with them to refine their business plan to create a better pitch for funding and participated in presentations to angel investors. The first group that was visited decided to invest the full US $500K requested. AtomicTangerine is now moving forward to design and implement the full Web site for eRockefeller and to create its identity and branding.
On the business side, the proposed Registry Operator is being assisted by a variety of key individuals from Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine, including several program directors. Please see D15.1 for biographical information for technical managers, and see Appendix C for full resumes.
Dr. James E. Carnes, President and CEO of Sarnoff Corporation
Dr. James E. Carnes is President and CEO of the Sarnoff Corporation. A recognized authority in the field of charge-coupled devices, he has played a major role in the development of High Definition Television (HDTV) in the U.S. since 1987. He joined RCA Laboratories in 1969 as a Member of the Technical Staff and worked in the area of MOS device structures, particularly CCD technology and applications. Since 1977 he has served in a variety of management positions in the company’s Consumer Electronics Division, culminating in his appointment as Vice President, Consumer Electronics and Information Sciences Research in 1987, when Sarnoff became a subsidiary of SRI International. Dr. Carnes has been issued nine U.S. patents and is the author of more than 100 papers and presentations. In 1981 he was a recipient of the David Sarnoff Award for Outstanding Technical Achievement "for the development and implementation of a CCD comb filter integrated circuit in color television receivers." He received a B.S. degree in Engineering Science from The Pennsylvania State University in 1961 and a Ph.D. degree in Electrical Engineering from Princeton University in 1970. Dr. Carnes is a Fellow of the IEEE and a member of the National Academy of Engineering. He currently sits on the Board of Directors of the Sarnoff Corporation, SRI International, Sensar Inc (a Sarnoff Technology Venture), and Sarif, Inc.
Dr. Norman D. Winarsky, Vice President, Sarnoff Corporation
Norman D. Winarsky is Corporate Vice President of Sarnoff Corporation, responsible for Internet and Multimedia Technologies. Business units within Sarnoff reporting to Dr. Winarsky include the National Information Display Laboratory (NIDL), Vision Technologies, and Computational Science. Dr. Winarsky is a founder of the National Information Display Laboratory - a center of excellence for the government in information processing and display technologies. A recipient of Sarnoff's highest honor, the David Sarnoff Award for Outstanding Technical Achievement., he was also founder of five of Sarnoff’s sixteen spinoffs. Dr. Winarsky received the BS, MS, and Ph.D. degrees in Mathematics from the University of Chicago, graduating Summa Cum Laude and Phi Beta Kappa. He has written over 50 papers and given hundreds of invited talks, lectures, and presentations throughout the world. His primary responsibility is to advance and execute the Sarnoff Internet Strategy.
Glenn A. Reitmeier, Vice President, Sarnoff Corporation
Glenn Reitmeier is Vice President of Internet Technology Strategy and Development at Sarnoff Corporation. His career has pioneered the development of digital television, digital media and digital convergence. He has created and led world-leading developments in Digital Cinema, object coding and wavelet image compression in MPEG-4, MPEG-2 compressed bitstream processing and integrated circuits for digital television receivers. His efforts have contributed to the formation of six new startup companies and resulted in three technical Emmy awards. Mr. Reitmeier was one of the leading contributors to establishing the ATSC Digital Television standard that was approved by the FCC in 1996. In the Digital HDTV Grand Alliance, he performed in both technical and strategic capacities, and was the leader of Grand Alliance computer interoperability efforts. He has also led projects related to developing new technologies for consumer information services, including computer and network architectures, Digital Signal Processing modems and natural language software. Earlier, Mr. Reitmeier was a contributor to the establishment of the world’s first digital television standards (the ITU 601 sampling standard and the D1 tape standard) that are now in widespread use in the broadcast industry. He holds over 40 patents in digital television technology. He received the B.E.E. degree summa cum laude in 1977 and an M.S.E. degree in Systems Engineering from the University of Pennsylvania in 1979.
Shailendra K. Suman, Executive Director, Sarnoff Corporation
Shailendra K. Suman is responsible for the business and strategy development, market analysis, and strategic alliances for nVention and its ventures. Prior to joining Sarnoff, Mr. Suman served in various management capacities for several energy-related companies, including responsibilities for strategy as well as new venture development. Mr. Suman received his BS in Mechanical Engineering from B.I.T. Sindri, India, an MS in Control Systems from University of Alabama, and an MBA in Finance and Strategy from University of Minnesota in 1986, 1989, and 1995 respectively. He completed all the coursework towards a Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering at Columbia University, NY in 1989. Mr. Suman is a member of the Conference Board’s International Council of Innovation & Technology Management and the Institute of Electronics and Electrical Engineers.
Anne VanLent, Vice President, Ventures and Licensing, Sarnoff Corporation
Anne M. VanLent serves as Sarnoff’s Vice President, Ventures and Licensing. Her responsibilities include identifying technologies that can serve as the foundation of new commercial businesses, and helping to assemble the technical, managerial, and financial resources to create those businesses. She also manages and oversees all of the patent and licensing activities of Sarnoff. Ms. VanLent has extensive experience in founding and building technology-based companies. In addition, she is experienced with emerging growth companies and has a broad background in science, finance, and business development. Before joining the Sarnoff Corporation in July of 1997, Ms. VanLent was the founder of AMV Associates, a life-sciences consulting firm; co-founder of Trophix Pharmaceuticals Inc., a venture-backed neuroscience company; and Senior Vice President and CFO of The Liposome Company, Inc. Her undergraduate degree in physics, conferred with honors and great distinction, was received from Mount Holyoke College. She conducted graduate studies at the Universite de Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France. Anne currently serves as a director of two public companies and several private emerging growth technology companies.
Nova Spivack, Founder, Lucid Ventures
Nova Spivack is Founder, President and CEO of Lucid Ventures Inc. and Co-Founder and CEO of Lucid Associates, LLC. Mr Spivack has been an Internet venture strategy advisor to Sarnoff Corporation for the past year and a prime mover in its decision to create nVention. From 1994, Mr Spivack was a Co-Founder, Executive Vice President, and Director of EarthWeb Inc., an industry-leading Internet venture. He co-led the company from startup through an historic IPO (the first business-to-business IPO and one of the all-time best first-day gainers) and a secondary public offering, serving as executive vice-president for product development and strategy. Mr. Spivack, a published author and frequent keynote speaker, is currently developing several new proprietary patents in the areas of GPS technology, Internet television, wireless consumer electronics, Internet radio, artificial intelligence and augmented reality, and is the principle inventor of multiple fundamental patents related to simulcasting Internet content with television broadcasts for use in entertainment, education, sports, news and information services. Mr Spivack is among the top-rated featured "Internet Business Experts" on Expert-central.com, part of the About.com network and has been interviewed by many prominent publications.
Anil Rungta, Program Director
Anil Rungta worked in Investment Banking at JP Morgan for 5 years. Mr. Rungta played a variety of roles in his career at JP Morgan, including technology banking, capital markets, syndicate and derivatives. Most recently Mr. Rungta was a member of the West Coast senior banking team at JP Morgan continuing the effort to build out JP Morgan’s technology/ Internet franchise. Mr. Rungta was primarily responsible for business development with Internet/ High Tech companies to provide financing and strategic advisory services, as well as to manage client relationships. Mr. Rungta was a key member of the core equity team that grew JP Morgan’s equity business from #18 in the league tables in 1995 to #6 in 1999, with annual revenues approaching $800MM. As part of the Convertibles marketing team, Mr. Rungta helped create a proprietary dividend exchange product that was heavily marketed to and utilized by several RBOCs and Utilities to preserve cash in order to invest in higher growth opportunities. Some of the clients that Mr. Rungta was involved with in his work at JP Morgan include Swisscom, EarthWeb, CyberSource, Network Commerce, Network Solutions, ActivCard, Sycamore Networks, Pharmacia & Upjohn, Telefonica de Espana, Telecom Italia, Ford, Gillette, ENI, Cable and Wireless, STET Hellas, Telstra, MATAV, MGM, China Telecom, Unibanco, Bayerische Vereinsbank, etc. Mr. Rungta is a graduate of Williams College and the London School of Economics. While at Williams, Mr. Rungta was the Founder and President of a collegiate direct marketing company called Impact Marketing. Mr. Rungta has two patents pending.
Dileep Agrawal, Technical Director
Dileep Agrawal founded and established Nepal’s first ISP. His company, WorldLink Communications was one of the first Internet companies in the Indian Subcontinent, has grown to be not only the largest ISP in Nepal, but one of the largest IT services companies employing more than 100 people. At WorldLink Communications, Dileep implemented all necessary technology, including setting up Unix-based servers with ISP applications, configuring entry-level Cisco routers, and establishing international data connectivity to upstream Internet provider. Mr. Agrawal was in-charge of overall corporate management, product development, and system administration. WorldLink has registered tremendous sustained growth and provides services ranging from Internet connectivity and related services to VSAT networking and software development. Mr. Agrawal has received various honors and awards, which include: a) member of National IT Infrastructure Development Committee - invited by His Majesty’s Government of Nepal to advise the National IT Infrastructure Development Committee on behalf of the private sector in the country; b) expert Speaker at National Y2K Conference (January 29, 1999) - invited to make an expert presentation at the National Y2K Conference in Katmandu organized by His Majesty’s Government of Nepal. Amongst other things, Mr. Agrawal’s technical experience includes setting up Nepal’s first nation-wide TCP/IP network and designing and supervising the installation of Katmandu’s first broadband wireless network based on wireless Ethernet technology. Mr. Agrawal is a graduate of Bates College.
Dr. William J. Burke, Vice President, Intellectual Property and Licensing, Sarnoff
William J. Burke has been Sarnoff’s Vice President for Intellectual Property and Licensing since 1997. Joining RCA Laboratories in 1967, in 1978 Dr. Burke transferred to the RCA Patent Operations in 1978 and was named a Managing Patent Attorney in 1983. In 1987 when the David Sarnoff Research Center was transferred to SRI International by General Electric, he was named Director of Law and Patent Operations as well as Assistant Secretary for the new company, becoming Acting General Counsel in 1995. In 1997 Dr. Burke was named Vice President, Intellectual Property and Licensing. He received his JD from New York Law School and has been admitted to the New York Bar, New Jersey Bar, Court of Appeals of the Federal Circuit and Court of Federal Claims and is registered to practice before the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. His undergraduate degree in Physics is from Boston College and his PhD degree is from Tufts University. Dr. Burke was a National Science Foundation Postdoctoral Fellow at University of Illinois, Urbana.
Jonathan C. Fornaci, President and Chief Executive Officer, AtomicTangerine
Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Fornaci served as chief operating officer of Luna Information Systems, an e-business software company. In previous work, he served as chief executive officer at IBIS Consulting, Inc., chief information and technology officer of a GE Capital Services Company, and vice president and chief information and technology officer of several other international companies. A sought-after speaker, Mr. Fornaci has spoken at the IT Metrics Summit (sponsored by the World Research Group), International HR (sponsored by the National Foreign Trade Council), Intranet ’98 (sponsored by Business Intelligence), HR Internet ’97 (World Research Group), the Zonerthon Internet Conference, the Software 500 Executive Forum, the 16th Annual Software Forum, Software Marketing Perspectives, the IDG Global Summit, Corporate Intranet (sponsored by Business Intelligence), SIMS, IDG, and the Morgan Stanley Investment Conference. Mr. Fornaci holds a B.A. in physics from the University of California at Berkeley.
Dr. Yadunath Zambre, Chief Technology Officer, AtomicTangerine
AtomicTangerine’s chief technology officer, specializes in speech recognition and computer networking technologies, and is currently working with the Nuance speech recognition system. He periodically teaches graduate classes on digital multimedia technology at Stanford University, where his students have done projects ranging from Java-based Internet shopping applications to voice control for networked virtual environments. Dr. Zambre has also been an invited speaker on Internet technology and its applications at international scientific conferences and at artists’ guild workshops in Hollywood. He has applied and integrated new and old technologies in a wide variety of settings. He has experience programming Sun, VAX, Xerox, IBM, and PC systems with C/C++, Java, Fortran, and assembler. Before joining AtomicTangerine and, previously, SRI International, Dr. Zambre cofounded a company that wrote software for diagnosing and analyzing errors in particle accelerators. The software was sold to international and U.S. laboratories and, on average, has reduced accelerator downtime by a factor of five. In many cases, the resulting cost reduction per incident exceeds US $200,000. Dr. Zambre holds a B.S. (cum laude) and M.S. (awarded simultaneously with the B.S.) in engineering from Yale University, and a Ph.D. in applied physics from Stanford University.
Sterling Stoudenmire, Vice President, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Sterling Stoudenmire has more than 11 years of experience in strategy and information technology consulting, and has worked with numerous "dot-com" clients in the formation, capitalization and emergent stages. He has a unique combination of business acumen across a variety of industries and expertise in emerging technologies, frequently acting as overall architect for new business opportunities. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Stoudenmire served as director, e-business strategy, for Arthur Andersen LLP. He is a frequent public speaker on e-business, information rules, and "innovation through information technology" for organizational change and competitive advantage. Past audiences include the World Economic Forum, AA’s E-Business Video Series, and the Florida Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Mr. Stoudenmire holds a B.S. in finance from Florida State University.
Donald Holden (CISSP), Business Leader, Information Security, AtomicTangerine
Don Holden has more than 20 years of experience in information systems, security, encryption, business continuity and disaster recovery planning. He has written numerous white papers and given presentations on information security management and technology issues such as intrusion detection, firewalls, biometric authentication and digital watermarking. Mr. Holden is currently the chairman of the IEEE Computer Society working group on recommended best practices for Internet security. He is also participating in the development of security standards for the financial industry. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Holden was a senior consultant for SRI Consulting, where he was a project leader for an Internet startup assignment to plan a revolutionary secure electronic commerce portal-based business. He previously served as program manager for Compaq’s Security Program Office and as the director of operations research at a major Boston bank. Mr. Holden holds an MBA from Wharton and a B.S. in business and accounting from Georgetown University. He is a Certified Information System Security Professional (CISSP) and a member of the IEEE Computer Society, the Computer Security Institute, and the Information Systems Security Association.
Laura A. Bilodeau, Business Leader, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Laura Bilodeau specializes in market strategy, business modeling, and business case development for entrepreneurial ventures as well as Fortune 500 companies. In particular, she focuses on the use of quantitative techniques and market assessment to validate the business plans for new e-commerce ventures. Ms. Bilodeau has worked closely with service providers to build market sizing and revenue forecasting models, with a focus on broadband Internet access and the e-commerce capabilities they make possible. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Ms. Bilodeau was a consultant in the telecommunications practice at A. T. Kearney. Previously she worked at D. E. Shaw & Company, a proprietary trading firm in New York, where she was responsible for conducting financial analysis and due diligence for potential new ventures. Ms. Bilodeau holds a B.A. in astrophysics from Princeton University and an MBA from the Wharton School of Business.
Sue Mundell, Business Consultant, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Sue Mundell’s background is at the juncture between Internet consulting and venture capital. Before joining AtomicTangerine Ms. Mundell worked at Axxon Capital, a Massachusetts venture capital firm, where she assessed and selected venture start-ups applying for funding. She has also helped numerous Internet companies improve their business models, write their business plans, and fine-tune their pitches for the venture capital community. Previously she launched and led a project at The Library of Congress to digitize fifty volumes of a bibliographic reference work for conversion to CD-ROM and Web formats. Ms. Mundell holds a MS/BS in political science from MIT and an MBA, magna cum laude, from Babson College, the top-ranked entrepreneurship program in the US.
D13.1.7. Staff/employees. Current staff size, demonstrated ability to expand employee base, hiring policy, employee training, space for additional staff.
Current Staff and Future Employee Expansion: Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine (formerly SRI Consulting) have a history of attracting the best people and staffing their operations and incubated ventures with the most talented teams available. Currently, Sarnoff has 800 employees and AtomicTangerine has 250. AtomicTangerine’s employee headcount has grown extremely rapidly, from a mere 80 employees when AtomicTangerine spun off from SRI in January 2000 to 250 employees in September 2000. AtomicTangerine’s compelling venture consulting model and strong reputation among clients have enabled it to attract and recruit top talent at high speed. AtomicTangerine’s Vice President of People and other human resources managers stand ready to advise the Registry as it grows its employee base.
Hiring and Employment Policies: As one of the Sarnoff Technology Venture companies, the Registry will adopt the employment standards, policies, and procedures in place at Sarnoff, including adherence to the Equal Employment Opportunity law. Given its primary responsibility to safeguard Registry information, the Registry will require all employees who have access to secured information to undergo a thorough background security check. For similar reasons, the Registry will maintain a Drug-Free Workplace, implementing Sarnoff’s policies in this regard. Excerpts from Sarnoff’s "Standards of Business Conduct" are briefly described below.
Sarnoff intends to comply strictly in all respects with all laws, domestic and foreign, affecting its business, and to conduct its business in accordance with the highest ethical and moral standards. There are no exceptions to this position and it may not be compromised or qualified by anyone acting for the Company.
All employees are expected to serve the Company with judgment, discretion, and integrity in the performance of their duties. Relationships of a compromising nature or even the appearance of such shall be scrupulously avoided.
Employees are expected to devote their full time and ability to the performance of their duties as employees during regular business hours and such additional time as may be required of them by their supervisors. Employees are prohibited from maintaining, directly or indirectly, any outside business or financial interest and from engaging in any outside business or financial activity or having any other interest in or relationship with any outside organization or individual having business dealings with the Company, which conflicts with the interests of the Company or that might interfere with the employee's ability fully to discharge his or her corporate duties.
Employees who violate this procedure are subject to dismissal or other appropriate disciplinary action.
Training: The Registry will develop training programs and extensive reference manuals in support of them. All employees and consultants will be required to undergo rigorous training and will be expected to have a thorough familiarity with the material in the reference manuals. New hires will attend a company boot camp modeled on that of AtomicTangerine to get acquainted with colleagues, learn company culture and values, and foster cross-functional teamwork among employees.
Physical Expansion: The Registry will be housed in new facilities in New Jersey that will accommodate rapid expansion to a large staff size of up to 200 people.
D13.1.8. Commercial general liability insurance. Address/include amount of insurance policy, provider of policy, plans for obtaining additional insurance.
Sarnoff has obtained commercial general liability insurance from Marsh Risk & Insurance services of Three Embarcadero Center, 3rd Floor, San Francisco, CA 94111. As one of the Sarnoff portfolio companies, the Registry will obtain and/or extend this coverage as necessary to cover all reasonable risks involved. AtomicTangerine is also covered by Marsh Risk & Insurance Services.
The insurance documents are confidential, but can be provided upon request.
D13.2. Business plan for the proposed registry operations. This section should present a comprehensive business plan for the proposed registry operations. In addition to providing basic information concerning the viability of the proposed operations, this section offers the registry operator an opportunity to demonstrate that it has carefully analyzed the financial and operational aspects of the proposal. At a minimum, factors that should be addressed are:
D13.2.1. Services to be provided. A full description of the registry services to be provided.
Domain Name Registration Services for Individuals and Internet-Enabled Devices, via ICANN Accredited Registrars
The proposed TLD will allow individuals to register a service-provider-independent point of contact for configuring Internet-enabled applications and create an addressing mechanism for an individual’s Internet-enabled devices. Our services can be broadly grouped into three subcategories: (a) conducting registration services for the proposed TLD; (b) enabling the next generation of middleware, applications, services and technologies around the DNS in an open and competitive manner; and (c) creating a global base for the Registry.
A. Registration Services for the Proposed TLD
As a Registry, we will provide equivalent registration services to all current and future ICANN Accredited Registrars and will implement fair and equitable conflict resolution mechanisms in connection with these obligations. We will maintain the master directory of all second and third level domain names in the proposed TLD for those domain names entered in the Registry (see Naming Conventions, Section E3). We will also provide and maintain the shared registration system that will allow all registrars to enter new second and third level domain names into the master directory and to submit modifications, transfers, re-registrations and deletions for existing second and third level domain names. We will offer variable registration terms, up to 10 years, and for longer periods of time to be implemented later, including lifetime and perpetual registrations.
The Registry will maintain the integrity of the domain name records in its databases and ensure full uptime. Continuous availability of nameservers at all times to resolve the proposed TLD will be the top priority of the Registry. The central database will be available for access by accredited registrars on a 24/ 7 basis. In addition, the Registry will cooperate in resolution of domain name disputes based on TLD Policies, as outlined in Section E6. The Registry will also provide "pre-emption" and "pre-registration" services to fully protect intellectual property and registered trademarks, as outlined in the TLD policies document. Whois service will be provided as outlined in the TLD policies document, Sections E5.6 and E7.
Name Space for Everyone and Every Device: The Registry’s proposed naming scheme (see Section E3) lays out a plan to ensure that everyone has cheap and equitable access to a Personal Domain Name registration. This naming scheme covers all the individuals of the world, as well as Internet enabled devices. The naming scheme is descriptive with respect to the individual, yet generic in that all individuals are covered.
In accordance with its mission of aiding the proliferation of the DNS to serve the needs of individuals and their Internet enabled devices globally, the Registry will provide a certain type of domain name, in certain quantities, over certain time frames (discussed in more detail in the TLD policies document) completely free of charge. Rather than compete with the registrars in the provision of these free domain names to the end user, the Registry will provide them for free to the registrars, with the hope that they be provided to the end user for free.
Customer Support/Technical Assistance Services: High quality customer support and technical assistance will be vital to the satisfaction of our customers, the registrars. Prior to going into a production environment, we will develop an operation test and evaluation environment for the registrars to test their systems. Furthermore, we will be assigning one point of contact to each registrar to help resolve issues. In addition, a trained team of engineers will be on standby to address any operational issues that adversely impact the registrars.
The Registry will also develop and implement standards, policies, and functions designed to enhance the ease, speed, and security of the registration process by adding new capabilities to facilitate the registration process and by providing quality customer service and support to registrars, as well as to retail customers when needed.
As the Registry for individual domain names, we will engage as many Registrars as possible in a geographically dispersed manner to provide global reach and support. As a critical infrastructure for mapping the global Personal Domain Name system, we will provide secure, reliable, and globally accessible registration facilities.
Personalization and Privacy Protection: The Registry Operator will abide by the strictest standards of privacy protection in order to protect registrants’ information, while protecting the rights and addressing the concerns of Intellectual Property and trademark holders as well as aggrieved parties. A Whois directory will be maintained, by which the registrant's contact information can be obtained in response to a manual query identifying any Particular Domain Name (please see the TLD policies document for more detail on the Whois policy). However, complete registration information for an individual in the proposed TLD will be made available only upon presentation of a legitimate inquiry indicating the name, address, and bar registration number (or international equivalent) of an attorney making the request and identifying the trademark sought to be enforced. This will prevent this data from being obtained by would-be stalkers, thieves, etc. (See Section E5.6 for further information on the Whois policy.)
Because one of the possible services to be added to the proposed TLD involves personalization, protecting the privacy of personal data is of paramount importance. The Registry Operator will ensure, to the greatest extent possible technologically and under the law, that any personal information used at the registry level is maintained according to the user’s established preferences and in a secure and verifiable manner.
B. Enabling the Next Generation of Middleware, Applications, Services and Technologies Around the DNS in an Open and Competitive Manner
It is appropriate and fitting that the DNS evolve to accommodate the needs of individuals and their information appliances. The underpinnings of the next generation of applications and services on the Internet are rooted in the DNS. The Registry’s mission is to make the power of the DNS pervasive and available to every Internet user. Key to the notion of creating the proposed TLD is the availability of a unique ID for every individual and device on our planet in a cheap, fair and equitable manner.
Some of the potential middleware, applications, and services that can be developed are outlined below. This is just an indicative list of some of the potential technologies that will benefit and open new opportunities for both consumers and businesses. The proposed Registry has already received verbal interest from companies interested in forming alliances with it to bring such middleware and services to market (see Appendix D for a letter of intent from Compaq, the first of many such expected letters).
B.1 Aliasing and Messaging Applications
Aliasing: Individuals may utilize a service whereby they will use different aliases for different purposes, such as segmenting and managing different aspects of their lives that are conducted in Internet space. The specific use of aliases facilitates redirection and remediation of communications as life events dictate, with minimal disruption to sender and receiver of messages. When used in conjunction with possible messaging capabilities described below, this could become an even more powerful tool to simplify life.
Message Management Services: The proposed TLD enables the creation of new services associated with managing the flow of multi-format messages to an individual with multiple receiving devices. The range of services that can be provided is extremely broad, and includes such services as message routing, message transcoding, message binning/blocking, and message status services for the sender. Consider the following categories of services, which -- when combined into an integrated service offering -- will be revolutionary in their impact upon personal communications:
Taken together, these services provide a powerful new paradigm for managing the flow of messages among people.
B.2 Superior Authentication & Certification Routines
With the United States’ electronic signature act taking effect October 1, 2000, a more secure and pervasive solution to Internet security is called for.
The most secure solution right now is based on public/private key encryption. One "signs" a document by adding the "private key" encrypted text to the original document, after which the recipient can decrypt the "signature" with the public key of the signer. If the encrypted text equals that of the original document, the signature is authentic. The Registry could play a future role by serving as the trusted source for an individual’s public key, thus enhancing security in the proposed TLD. To enhance security further, the Registry could form partnerships with cell phone operators and PC and PDA manufacturers to imbed the public key of the Registry Operator in the hardware. Although this authentication technology is currently in use, to date it has been used to link to a device rather than to a person. Expanding it to identify people using the Personal Domain Name system would be a natural extension.
B.3 Convergence and the Introduction of the Internet to Other Mediums
The Internet is going to shift from the computer desktop as the primary access device to other mediums and channels, such as TV, handheld devices, automobiles, smart mobile devices, etc. Sarnoff has great knowledge and understanding of these various mediums and is recognized as the premier consumer/commercial research and innovating organization in the world. As such, Sarnoff is very well positioned to lead the charge into the next- generation application of the DNS and to bring digital identifiers not just to people, but to Internet-enabled devices, home and residential gateways, information appliances, and personal networking environments.
Home Appliance Applications: Controlling home appliances and monitoring home security will be greatly simplified when home appliances are manufactured with the capability of assigning each appliance a digital ID sub-domain under the homeowner’s Personal Domain Name. Using a firewall at the edge of the home network for security purposes, all appliances could be monitored and controlled remotely. Content could be sent directly to appliances such as TVs, videos, and ovens under the Personal Domain Name, using the sub-domain name representing the digital ID of that appliance. From this perspective, the DNS applies not only to corporations, organizations, and individuals, but also to devices. Given Sarnoff’s history and expertise in developing innovative consumer technologies, the Registry will be well positioned to proliferate the DNS and surrounding technologies throughout the home in order to simplify consumers’ lives.
Security and Theft Detection Services: The geographic locations of devices with assigned domain-name based digital ID’s (e.g., cars, laptops, cell phones) will be easy to detect whenever these devices are logged onto the Internet. If a device is stolen, a signal could be sent to activate a specific audible alarm in the device to alert those nearby that the use of this device is not permitted or that the device may have been stolen.
B.4 Digital Legacy
The proposed TLD will enable individuals to create a personal multimedia legacy of their lives for future generations. Family histories and genealogy will have an increasing online component, as the life memories of stories, images, and sounds are preserved for future generations. We envision new services dedicated to the creation, management (e.g., creating new links as families grow and change), and "perpetual care" of these personal archives. Once created, an individual Personal Domain Name could be maintained by friends and/or family as a memorial to that individual after his/her passing. Alternatively, the Personal Domain Name holder could pay to have his/her domain name registered for the highest period permitted by law or the life of the Registry. The Registry expects to enable lifetime and perpetual registrations in due time.
B.5 Social Benefits
The creation of the proposed TLD will greatly facilitate the use of network-based computing and user-interface environments that can roam the world with users, independent of an association with a physical device, providing a focal point for the true convergence of platforms and devices. With the Personal Domain Name system, Internet-enabled telephony, file sharing, remote workgroup coordination, personal communications, and wireless devices such as personal digital assistants could be configured via a unitary interface to each individual’s specifications.
This will be important to travelers and mobile professionals who may have readily available Internet access, but not necessarily through their own PC. The personalization gained from user preferences, cookies, etc., can become network-based if the proposed TLD domain is used to associate a personal environment with a user (while keeping all personal information private and secure, as discussed above). The same approach will facilitate the growth of casual use in Internet cafes and other public and semi-public venues, serving to expand more and more consumer behavior on Web-based applications. Even those who cannot afford their own device will benefit, via individualized access to Internet service through PCs or other devices that are shared among multiple families or that are publicly available at libraries or schools.
Other uses of the Personal Domain Name system are also of great social benefit, including:
Missing Children Service: Every year, several million children are reported missing. With proper teaching and training, children could be taught to remember and use a Personal Domain Name based digital ID to communicate with their parents or relatives. A simple wireless web device worn by a child would be sufficient in locating the position of the child. An alert signal could be sent to the device with which to get the child’s attention so that he/she can find a device to communicate. Similar devices could be used in locating missing pets.
Humanitarian Uses: The availability of free numeric domain names has humanitarian applications as well. Eventually organizations such as the Red Cross and the UNHCR will be able to use the Personal Domain Name system to serve people in crisis around the world. For instance, when refugees flee their homelands, they often must leave everything behind, including their home, bank accounts, passports and even driver’s licenses. They have no papers and no identity. Missing family members and individuals are sometimes difficult to locate because there is no way to communicate with them. Once the Personal Domain Name system is widely implemented, refugees or victims of natural disasters could be reached anywhere by any device logged into the Internet, anytime. This would solve one of the serious problems posed by war, invasion, or natural disasters.
B.6. Technology Vision and Standards Development
The Registry seeks to enable the next generation of middleware, services and technologies around the DNS in an open and competitive manner. We also seek to create and lead alliances such that industry standards can be developed to enable the development of applications based on the DNS that benefit everyone. Further, we intend to fully participate in efforts by the IETF (Internet Engineering Task Force), MINC (Multilingual Internet Names Consortium), and other Internet standards organizations to further develop DNS processes, procedures, protocols, and other solutions to expand the capabilities of the DNS systems.
Sarnoff has many years’ experience working with industry organizations to develop new standards for various industries, including very recently the Grand Alliance to develop the HDTV system standard. The Registry will leverage that expertise to create an unofficial policymaking organization to develop consensus standards of a global nature around the Personal Domain Name system. As a result, Internet application standards and protocols, mutually agreed upon by industry leaders, various relevant constituencies, and consumer advocates, can be developed. Because the Registry is not an access service provider, application service provider, nor device manufacturer, it will have better credibility to lead such a standards-setting initiative.
C. Creating a Global Base
International advisors, sponsorships, and marketing will be critical areas of focus for the Registry. Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine are currently in active discussion with a variety of international organizations to form partnerships. A global advisory group will be established to help the Registry consider the needs of all constituents, regardless of nationality. Alliances will be sought with foreign and multinational companies on a continuous basis to enable the development of middleware and innovative services that appeal to various communities around the world. Likewise, a global base of corporate sponsors will be sought to further communicate the Registry’s international message. Initial marketing efforts will target those areas of the world where individuals are most ready to embrace applications and services based on the Personal Domain Name system, i.e., Europe and Asia, where the growth rate of wireless web-enabled devices is the highest.
D13.2.2. Revenue model. A full description of the revenue model, including rates to be charged for various services.
As described in the mission statement, the Registry seeks to enable all individuals to obtain a Personal Domain Name while still maintaining a financially sound business. The proposed pricing and tiers are as follows.
The proposed service will offer three price tiers of names:
These tiers and the reasoning behind them are explained in greater detail below. Please note the naming convention is discussed in greater detail in the TLD Policies document, E3.
Free Personal Numeric Domain Names: Domain names of the form tendigits.twoletters.TLD (as described in D13.2.1 above) will be provided free of charge in order to provide equitable access to a Personal Domain Name irrespective of an individual’s ability to pay. Our projections predict that in Year 1 around 20% of registrations in the proposed TLD will be requests for free numeric domain names, a figure predicted to grow to 40% by the end of Year 4. (See Section D13.2.5, Estimated Demand for Registry Services, for further information.) Revenues from fee-based registrations will be used in part to subsidize the free domain name program.
Standard Format Third-Level Domain Names: Domain names of the format firstname-middleinitial-lastname.fourdigits.TLD represent the Registry’s standard offering. At the low price of US $2 wholesale, these names give users the opportunity to have a personalized name at an extremely economical price. The four digits enable creation of multiple domain names of the same firstname-middleinitial-lastname combination.
Customized Domain Names: For individuals who want a customized domain name, they will have the opportunity to request a third- or second-level domain name of their choosing. During the Startup period, requests for domain names will be handled by lottery. At the conclusion of the lottery, a registrant will be selected at random from the pool of parties indicating an interest. The base registration fee charged the winning registrant may be determined by the number of participants in the lottery in order to recover overhead costs based on the volume of entry requests. The annual renewal fee for a domain name bought by lottery will be the price charged for the initial registration of the domain name.
After the startup period, all customized domain names will be sold on a first come, first served basis. Customized domain names registered after the Startup period will be priced at US $4 wholesale, and an annual renewal fee of US $4 wholesale per name will be required to maintain them.
Projected Revenues: Using these values for the variables in our revenue model(base case or 50% confidence level), we calculate resulting fee revenues at roughly US $6.6 M, US $31.7 M, US $66.1 M, and US $134.1 M for the first 4 years, respectively.
Note: Anticipated services to enable the next generation of middleware, applications, services, and technologies around the DNS described in Section D13.2.1 above are not included in the current revenue model. The intent is to enable and develop technologies in an open, international standards based environment. The Registry will provide for involvement of public policy and R&D organizations to insure robust, secure development and scaling of the infrastructures and application innovation. The widespread adoption of the Personal Domain Name System will benefit not just Internet users, but create and motivate new development communities and businesses to innovate and build on top of it, following the dynamic of the World Wide Web and other core Internet platforms.
D13.2.3. Market. Market definition, size, demand, accessibility.
The general market for the proposed personalized domain is Internet users who want to use the Internet for centralizing and/or routing communications (e-mail, instant messaging, VoIP, etc.), managing and conducting financial transactions, shopping online, storing and managing personal information electronically, mobile computing, maintaining a Web presence, etc. Any individual who stands to benefit from portability and a service provider invariant point of contact and communication is a target for the proposed TLD registration and services surrounding it. Ultimately, the Registry is proposing a revolutionary new service offering that will bring new, innovative technology, applications, and services to Internet users.
Market research indicates that Personal Domain Names and the portability and simplicity they bring are of great interest to several target markets, including: (1) business travelers who are already "wired" to their home office while traveling – either through a cell phone, pager, laptop, and/or PDA with Internet capability; and (2) general consumers seeking to simplify their lives. In both cases, Personal Domain Name owners will be able to reduce the amount of time they spend checking multiple e-mail and voice-mail systems for messages, and will feel secure that the messages they want to receive are being sent according to their preferences as to when, where, and how they wish to receive them. Even more compellingly, owners of a Personal Domain Name will no longer risk losing important e-mail from colleagues and friends each time they switch jobs, schools, or Internet service providers, since their Personal Domain Name is portable across employers, colleges, and service providers. Given the increasingly transient nature of the world’s workforce, this is a particularly attractive feature and will provide us with easy access to our target market.
Our modest pricing policies (free for a numeric domain name and US $2-4 per year for most domain names) will assist in sparking demand quickly in a market that is already in severe need of an organized name space. Although we intend to roll out a formal marketing campaign, we expect that we will also benefit from word of mouth, e-mail campaigns, and positive press coverage of our creative solution to a very tangible problem.
Market Size and Demand
To quantify the size of the market, we first consider the total base of Internet users:
Internet users: estimated to be about 700-800 million in the next 3 years.
Internet-enabled devices: estimated to be more than one billion in the next 3 years.
Additional trends suggest the increasing need for e-mail consolidation and simplification:
Within the starting base of Internet users, a moderate percentage will shift towards the more sophisticated services enabled by our proposed TLD. This adoption, however, will stagger across different groups at different rates. We expect two particular segments to surface as early adopters:
Youth (Teenagers and College Students)
One group of likely early adopters will be youth ages 13 to 23. These individuals are very mobile, early adopters of new services and technologies and spend a lot of time on the Internet. An exceptionally mobile and sociable group, Generation Y college students will seize the opportunity to obtain a globally accessible service provider invariant identifier that can serve their needs and simplify their lives.
According to the US Census Bureau, there are currently 42 million people in the age group 13-23 in the US alone. Globally, the number is much higher. We estimate that by 2001, 1-1.5% or approximately 500,000 youth, in the US alone, will have purchased their own Personal Domain Name, while by 2004, nearly 12-15% or approximately 5 million youth in the US alone will have done so. Adding in the rest of the world’s teenagers and college students could easily double these figures or more, depending on adoption rates overseas.
"Wired" Business Travelers
For this segment, one can find promising indicators in a wide variety of sources. According to the Travel Industry of America, 63% of the 43.9 million US business travelers in 1999 were "wired" to their home office while traveling, through either a cell phone, pager, laptop, and/or PDA. One can also assume that the number of e-mails and voice mails received by business travelers far exceeds the number of messages for the average US user cited above.
Further validation of expected demand for our proposed service is offered from another outside source: a 1998 Yankee Group survey found that many wireless users were either very or somewhat interested in a single number service that would integrate home, wireless, and pager numbers. This trend was particularly prevalent among those on the road more than 6 days a month (61%), those who use wireless primarily for business (61%), and those whose cell phone bills were more than US $50 per month (67%). These describe the profile of the typical wired business traveler.
Clearly one can conclude that for the wired business traveler who handles a large volume of e-mails, pages, cell phone calls, and other transactions each day, a communications routing solution based on Personal Domain Names is particularly attractive. Therefore, we expect high demand among this target segment.
From both 1996 to 1997 and 1997 to 1998, the number of US business travelers increased 2% each year. Using this historical growth rate, we project that the number of wired US business travelers will increase from 28.2 million in 2000 to 30.5 million in 2004. Assuming an initially low but fast-growing adoption rate for the proposed Personal Domain Name service within this segment, we project the US component of these early adopters at 1 million in 2001, increasing to 9 million individuals by 2004. For projections purpose, we assume that there are at least an equal number of business travelers outside the US, and that therefore the totals for the following years will be double the US figure. This gives us a global early adopter market of 1 million in 2001 and 18 million in 2004.
The above groups represent only a portion of the total market appeal of the Personal Domain Name. The broader market is comprised of all individuals who can use a Personal Domain Name as a service provider-invariant point of contact for configuring Internet-enabled applications and create an addressing mechanism for themselves as well their information appliances.
General Consumers
According to a March 2000 Lehman Brothers report, the number of worldwide users expected to connect to the Internet via wireless devices and PDAs is expected to reach 50 million by the end of 2000, with projections of 1.2 billion users by 2005. Of these users, a substantial portion will want to avail themselves of the Personal Domain Name service to better manage, screen, and route their communications from multiple channels to their preferred device at any given point in time.
Source: Lehman Brothers, March 2000
Within this enormous consumer market, it is difficult to predict the adoption rate of our TLD by leisure users. However, the findings of the Yankee Group’s Sept. 1999 US Mobile User Survey provide some clues:
While we expect that general consumers will be outnumbered by the early adopters in 2001, for 2002 onward we assume that general consumers will equal or outpace specific subcategories. Taking the 60-40 ratio of personal to business-related e-mails and applying that same ratio to the number of users, we expect roughly 500,000 consumer users in 2001, increasing to about 27 million in 2004.
D13.2.4. Marketing plan. Advertising, publicity, promotion strategy, advertisement development strategy, relationship with advertising firm. Use of registrars and other marketing channels.
To target the individual and Internet enabled devices market for the proposed TLD, the Registry will use the appropriate combination of marketing, sales channels and pricing. Given our low prices and the widespread use of simple communications tools such as e-mail, the above target markets for the DNS-based Digital IDs (Personal Domain Names) are easily accessed. The channels to be utilized include Registrars, applications developers, different types of service providers (e.g., communications, telecom, finance), etc. In a way, the proposed TLD will require little marketing because there is a tremendous pent up demand for the type of name space proposed here. No TLD exists today to serve this need. The proposed TLD will have the right branding as well as the right purpose to attract registrants. To enhance this awareness and branding, the Registry will undertake a comprehensive marketing campaign to inform and familiarize individuals globally of the new TLD and the purpose and market it serves.
The Registry will work closely with a top-flight public relation firms interested in representing the marketing efforts of the proposed TLD. Please see attached letter of interest from Ruder Finn.
Ruder Finn, known for its tradition of excellence in public relations for more than 50 years, is among the largest public relations agencies. The hallmark of the company is blending innovative, strategic thinking and creative communications practices to enhance the success of clients in the realms of business, culture, science, government and education. Ruder Finn’s overall mission is to guide its clients in responding to the communications challenges of a fast-changing and dynamic world.
The more than 50 professionals in Ruder Finn’s Technology Division focus on both large multinational and entrepreneurial start-up companies in the information technologies, telecommunications and new media industries. The division’s clients include semiconductor manufacturers, computer hardware and software firms, computer-aided design and data services, business and consumer electronics, artificial intelligence, imaging, HDTV, networking suppliers, broadcast television production, online services and entertainment technology.
Marketing Plan Highlights
Our top priorities in the marketplace are to undertake a comprehensive global awareness campaign aimed at the end user. In addition, we are seeking to provide significant and reliable applications, services and support to the technology and middleware development circles. Co-promotions with distribution channels and expansion of the distribution channels to include traditional service providers (such as Telcos, ISPs, etc.) will be a focus as well.
In general marketing campaigns directed at end users as well as the distribution channels, the purpose and value proposition of the Proposed TLD will be strongly emphasized. Security, utility, efficiency, trust, and privacy protection are some of the other key themes.
The Registry will work closely with the selected Public Relations and Marketing firm to effect a strategically sequenced market entry and technology advocacy program for the Registry to gain early traction and technical recognition among its target customer base of individuals seeking unique digital identities on the Internet. The PR firm will also closely assist in a) enabling industry analysts and editors to better evaluate, understand and report on the Registry products and services through effective strategic messaging and technology communications; b) establish the Registry as a credible authority leader in interpreting customer needs and requirements in the evolving domain name market; and c) gain optimum news coverage and analyst validation of the Registry’s strategic marketing agenda, technology development efforts and category positioning.
Marketing Mix
The marketing initiatives of year one would include:
Preliminary Marketing Plan Calendar: Q4 2000
Messaging and positioning – establish a vocabulary and terminologies suitable for consumers, businesses, and government/public interest audiences
Handle the public announcement in coordination with ICANN
Educate media about new domain names, on and offline
Educate industry analysts
Explore relationships/partnerships with other organizations focused on online security and consumer trust
Identify government and or public policy organizations whose actions could affect the Registry; create a plan for constructive engagement
Identify trade shows and conferences for 2001 participation
Consumer research on early I-adopters
Preliminary Marketing Plan Calendar: Q1 2001
Educational microsite gets posted on the web
Preliminary Marketing Plan Calendar: Q2 2001
On and offline media relations focused on consumers
Second round contacts with technology analyst firms
Planning and logistics of grassroots promotions
Initial contacts with financial analysts
HTML newsletter continues
Preliminary Marketing Plan Calendar: Q3 2001
Ongoing media relations
Implementation of grassroots marketing / promotion / communications in several key areas
Full consumer advertising launch, TV, radio, print
HTML newsletter continues
Affiliate marketing continues
Update technology analysts on rate of registrations
D13.2.5. Estimated demand for registry services in the new TLD. Projected total demand for registry services in the TLD, effect of projected registration fees, competition. Please provide estimates for at least 10%, 50%, and 90% confidence levels.
We estimate that the number of requests for Personal Domain Names by 2004 could be as high as 6% of all Internet users, or around 70 million at the 10% confidence level. At a bare minimum, within a 90% confidence level, we believe that 1.2% of worldwide Internet users will request a Personal Domain Name by that year, translating into about 15 million registrations. However, a more likely scenario is that about 3.8% of the world’s Internet population, or around 46 million users, will purchase a Personal Domain Name by the end of 2004, which corresponds to a 50% confidence level.
Estimated Demand for Personal Domain Names (Cumulative Paying Subscribers, MM) |
||||
Year |
2001 |
2002 |
2003 |
2004 |
Total Internet Users (MM) |
427 |
596 |
862 |
1220 |
Users w/ Personal Domain |
||||
10% confidence level |
2.0 |
15 |
40 |
70 |
50% confidence level |
1.5 |
10 |
22 |
46 |
90% confidence level |
0.8 |
5 |
9 |
15 |
% Penetration (50% level) |
0.4% |
1.7% |
2.6% |
3.8% |
Research shows that most early adopters will be more willing to pay a registration fee to get a non-numerical Personal Domain Name. Because of this, we estimate that in the first year only 20% of our projected 1.5 million users are likely to take advantage of the Registry’s free numeric domain name offering.
However, as the years pass and the Personal Domain Names system and its surrounding technology become more mainstream, we expect to see a growing demand for the free numerical Personal Domain Names. By Year 3, for instance, we expect that 35% of registered users within the proposed TLD will be using the free numerical Personal Domain Name. This growth in the free service will take place primarily at the expense of the paid names registrations (see the table below). However, we propose to cap our free numeric domain name offering at about equal to the number of paying subscribers, pending further evaluation once operational. The Registry is very committed to providing a low-price and equitable service to all individuals who demand it. These free names will pose additional costs to the Registry, so the Registry will continue to evaluate the feasibility of this plan once operating.
A rough proxy was used to estimate the percentage of users who would be likely to choose paid registration over a free numeric Personal Domain Name by comparing paid and free subscriptions to Internet access companies (i.e., AOL vs. Juno). We found that there is a roughly a 3-1 split, with more people subscribing to the paid services. Of the major players: AOL and Earthlink have 28 million subscribers, while Juno and NetZero together have 11 million. From this, we altered this ratio downward to account for the fact that the price of the proposed personal domain is an order of magnitude smaller than most paid Internet access subscriptions available today. Offsetting this slightly is the fact that among the Internet providers, the paid services usually offer more capabilities for that money, while for our proposed Registry the free proposition provides the exact same services as the paid names, giving people a slightly greater incentive to settle for a free name. Therefore we will assume that among the early adopters, only 20% will want a free name. As the service spreads globally, we predict that the percentage of free numeric domain names will increase to 40% by Year 4.
In addition to the 20% who receive free numeric domain names, we estimate that another 20% of registrants will be motivated to pay a slightly higher fee during the startup period, with the remaining 60% of registrants split evenly between those who seek a standard-format third-level domain name and those who prefer a customized domain name.
Year |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
Year 3 |
Year 4 |
Fees (US $ /name) |
||||
Free Numeric |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
Standard Format |
$ 2.00 |
$ 2.00 |
$ 2.00 |
$ 2.00 |
Customized |
$ 4.00 |
$ 4.00 |
$ 4.00 |
$ 4.00 |
Customized – Startup Period |
$ 10.00 |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
Users (millions) – base case |
1.87 |
14.3 |
34.7 |
76 |
% Free Numeric |
20% |
30% |
36% |
40% |
% Standard Format |
30% |
35% |
32% |
30% |
% Customized |
30% |
35% |
32% |
30% |
% Customized - Startup |
20% |
0% |
0% |
0% |
Total |
100% |
100% |
100% |
100% |
Total revenues ($millions) |
||||
Free Numeric Names |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
Standard Format @ US $ 2/name |
$ 1.5 |
$ 9.9 |
$ 21.4 |
$ 44.4 |
Customized @ US $ 4/name |
$ 3.0 |
$ 19.8 |
$ 42.9 |
$ 88.7 |
Customized Startup @ US $10/name |
$ 3.0 |
$ 3.0 |
$ 3.0 |
$ 3.0 |
Total (in US $) |
$ 7.5 |
$ 32.7 |
$ 67.3 |
$ 136.1 |
These estimates for fee-based vs. free Personal Domain Name registrations are based in part on the abovementioned research, which indicates more than half of Internet users would pay to consolidate their e-mails and over 61% of mobile users would pay to have a single number service. Because our customer value proposition incorporates notions of both voice and e-mail consolidation and improved communications routing capability, together with cross-platform and cross-service provider portability, we believe the Personal Domain Name will experience quick adoption rates, especially given our commitment to provide low-cost, accessible registration fees. By guaranteeing one free Personal Domain Name to anyone who wants one (within budgeted limits) and reasonable wholesale annual registration fees of US $2-4 for most names within the TLD, the end price to the user is expected to be competitive. This will have the effect of boosting Personal Domain Name adoption rates even further; we expect Personal Domain Names to become ubiquitous among the Internet population.
Competition
The Registry, working with Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine, will enable the next generation of applications for the DNS and enable unprecedented services and functionalities that are truly beneficial to the Internet users of the world. This process will also create opportunities for businesses and service providers to create new applications and tap into new markets. The commitment of the Registry to further these interests is also demonstrated by the proposed pricing structure, whereby the Registry is offering a free numeric domain name to all Internet users (within budgeted limits). It is our belief that all Internet users have the right to a permanent, portable, domain name.
The end result will be better services, more competition and user freedom. Our Registry will be the first mover in creating the market described in this document. A TLD that caters to Internet users and their information appliances, and that is targeted towards creating the next generation of applications and services based on the DNS does not exist today.
Because the proposed TLD will be open for registration services offered by any ICANN-Accredited Registrar, competition for registration services will be maintained. Additionally, there will be competition among the providers of Internet-enabled applications and devices that will utilize the individual addressing mechanism provided by the proposed TLD. It is in this area – freeing the individual from restrictions or service limitations imposed by the individual’s service providers – where competition will be enhanced and further benefits realized.
D13.2.6. Resources required to meet demand. Provide a detailed estimate of all resources (financial, technical, staff, physical plant, customer service, etc.) required to meet the estimated demands, using at least the 10%, 50%, and 90% confidence levels.
Human Resources
The key functional areas include technology, finance, legal, marketing, human resources, and customer service staff. As the number of registrations rapidly increases over the first year, the size of the company will expand by almost 50% by Year 2. The staffing requirements are detailed in the chart below.
Payroll Base
Year |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
Year 3 |
Year 4 |
Management |
4 |
6 |
6 |
6 |
Corporate functions (e.g. marketing, accounting) |
8 |
12 |
16 |
20 |
Staff |
12 |
18 |
22 |
28 |
Customer support tech |
12 |
18 |
24 |
30 |
Sr. System administrators |
4 |
4 |
4 |
4 |
Jr. System administrators |
3 |
4 |
6 |
8 |
System developers |
2 |
4 |
6 |
8 |
Support engineers |
12 |
18 |
24 |
24 |
Total |
57 |
84 |
108 |
128 |
Note that customer service is a key component of staffing. The customer support operations will be 24 x 7 and will be continually monitored to ensure proper staffing levels are maintained.
Technology Assets
The technical requirements encompass a mix of hardware, software, and services necessary to architect, build, maintain, and monitor the Registry. The infrastructure is being designed for the 50% confidence level, with potential adjustments for significantly higher or lower levels of demand.
The hardware is comprised of networking equipment and servers. The servers will be from Sun while Cisco will provide the networking equipment. We estimate that the following equipment is required per facility to run at the 50% confidence level:
Bind and Whois are freely distributed under the GNU public license. OpenSRS will be developed based upon an industry standard tool set. The database will be Oracle. Backup software will be Veritas NetBackup.
Several systems will be used for the necessary office software and hardware for business operations as discussed below:
In addition, a state of the art MIS system will be implemented to enable delivery of necessary information to each individual within the company. (Please see Appendix E for letter of interest from Cap Gemini Ernst & Young US LLC.) All the software systems mentioned above adopt open architectures and industry standards. The MIS system will tap into the existent systems and present the information via a browser. On the hardware side, the following equipment is budgeted:
Cisco will provide the networking infrastructure equipment, Dell will provide the servers necessary to support the software above, and Lucent will provide the telephony solution. CardKey will provide the electronic card key access system.
Financial Resources
The financial resources necessary to meet demand will vary according to usage. The hardware and software projected costs will not be significantly impacted by these exercises. This is based upon using the 50% projections for architecture design and evaluating the difference in total cost of ownership for upside and downside scenarios. Another architecture consideration was maintaining high quality of service even under estimated peak loads. The marketing and advertising numbers are expected to remain the same at each confidence level unless marketing analysis illustrates that a change in dollars will be beneficial. The financial resource most impacted will be in personnel expenses such as salary, benefits, rent, travel and administrative costs. The three charts below illustrate the different financial resource requirements at each confidence level.
Annual Projections at 90%
EXPENSES |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
Year 3 |
Year 4 |
Registry infrastructure |
|
|
|
|
Hardware/Software/ |
5,880 |
4,143 |
4,143 |
4,143 |
Data lines |
180 |
180 |
180 |
180 |
Maintenance fee |
203 |
211 |
211 |
211 |
Business office infrastructure |
|
|
|
|
Computer equip, services & maintenance |
1,059 |
345 |
345 |
345 |
Rent & Utilities |
2,583 |
3,402 |
4,347 |
4,725 |
Human Resources |
|
|
|
|
Management |
576 |
576 |
576 |
576 |
Corporate functions |
240 |
300 |
420 |
480 |
Staff |
360 |
420 |
480 |
540 |
Customer support Technicians |
360 |
480 |
600 |
600 |
Sr.System Administrators |
480 |
480 |
480 |
528 |
Jr. System Administrators |
216 |
288 |
432 |
576 |
Employee Benefits |
558 |
636 |
747 |
813 |
|
|
|
|
|
Marketing & Advertising |
5,000 |
5,000 |
5,000 |
5,000 |
Professional fees |
360 |
396 |
455 |
524 |
Travel |
360 |
405 |
495 |
540 |
Administrative expenses |
455 |
390 |
444 |
417 |
|
|
|
|
|
Total expenses |
19,061 |
18,086 |
20,039 |
21,127 |
Annual Projections at 50%
EXPENSES |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
Year 3 |
Year 4 |
Registry infrastructure |
|
|
|
|
Hardware/Software/ |
5,880 |
4,143 |
4,143 |
4,143 |
T1 lines |
180 |
180 |
180 |
180 |
Maintenance fee |
203 |
211 |
211 |
211 |
Business office infrastructure |
|
|
|
|
Computer equip, services & maintenance |
1,059 |
345 |
345 |
345 |
Rent & Utilities |
3,591 |
5,292 |
6,804 |
8,064 |
Personnel |
|
|
|
|
Management |
576 |
864 |
864 |
864 |
Middle management |
480 |
720 |
960 |
1,200 |
Staff |
720 |
1,080 |
1,320 |
1,680 |
Customer support Technicians |
720 |
1,080 |
1,440 |
1,140 |
Sr.System Administrators |
480 |
480 |
480 |
528 |
Jr. System Administrators |
216 |
288 |
432 |
576 |
Employee Benefits |
798 |
1,128 |
1,374 |
1,650 |
|
|
|
|
|
Marketing & Advertising |
5,000 |
5,000 |
5,000 |
5,000 |
Professional fees |
720 |
792 |
911 |
1,047 |
Travel |
360 |
540 |
660 |
780 |
Administrative expenses |
523 |
461 |
504 |
504 |
|
|
|
|
|
Total expenses |
21,721 |
23,322 |
27,034 |
31,305 |
Annual Projections at 10%
EXPENSES |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
Year 3 |
Year 4 |
Registry infrastructure |
|
|
|
|
Hardware/Software/ |
5,880 |
4,143 |
4,143 |
4,143 |
T1 lines |
180 |
180 |
180 |
180 |
Maintenance fee |
203 |
211 |
211 |
211 |
Business office infrastructure |
|
|
|
|
Computer equip, services & maintenance |
1,059 |
345 |
345 |
345 |
Rent & Utilities |
3,591 |
5,292 |
6,804 |
8,064 |
Personnel |
|
|
|
|
Management |
576 |
864 |
864 |
864 |
Middle management |
480 |
720 |
960 |
1,200 |
Staff |
720 |
1,080 |
1,320 |
1,680 |
Customer support Technicians |
720 |
1,080 |
1,440 |
1,140 |
Sr.System Administrators |
480 |
480 |
480 |
528 |
Jr. System Administrators |
216 |
288 |
432 |
576 |
Employee Benefits |
798 |
1,128 |
1,374 |
1,650 |
|
|
|
|
|
Marketing & Advertising |
5,000 |
5,000 |
5,000 |
5,000 |
Professional fees |
720 |
792 |
911 |
1,047 |
Travel |
360 |
540 |
660 |
780 |
Administrative expenses |
523 |
461 |
504 |
504 |
|
|
|
|
|
Total expenses |
21,769 |
23,638 |
28,114 |
32,690 |
D13.2.7. Plans for acquiring necessary systems and facilities. Describe plans for acquiring all necessary systems and facilities for providing the proposed services at each estimated demand level. Provide details as to the scope, cost, and vendor for any significant planned outsourcing.
Electronic Registry
The life-cycle of the electronic registry components are architecture, construction, monitoring and maintenance. Cisco is a dominant player in networking equipment and is supplying all the necessary networking equipment (e.g., firewall, routers and switches) for the electronic registry. Sun is the vendor for servers. Sun servers are scalable and robust. EMC is a proven industry leader in reliable mass storage. Alliant Technologies is an IT professional services firm experienced in architecture design and build. Alliant Technologies will provide the services necessary for architecting the electronic registry. Exodus is a leader in hosting and maintenance services of the Internet. Exodus will provide for the hosting, monitoring and maintenance of the electronic registry. Additionally Exodus will perform the actual site build.
Outsourced costs:
Business Office Infrastructure
Several systems provide the necessary business tools for business operations. GreatPlains/Siebel have formed a partnership providing for web enabled financial management, human resources, customer service and customer relationship management. Microsoft back office and desktop solutions provide for a collaborative work environment common in the workforce today. Kana will be used to manage the e-mail customer support system. Services will be provided by Alliant Technologies to implement GreatPlains/Siebel. An MIS system will be developed to deliver the necessary information to each individual within the company. All the software systems mentioned above adopt open architectures and industry standards. The MIS system will tap into the existing systems and present the information via a browser. Stringent security will be enforced.
Outsourced costs: Alliant Technologies (one-time fees)
Office Space
Office space will be located in New Jersey. The facility will be extremely secure and in an accessible environment. The Registry will have security at the primary entrance. To secure the various entrances as well as internal entrances to secure areas, such as the data center, a card key system will be installed. In addition, video surveillance of the entrances will be monitored.
D13.2.8. Staff size/expansion capability. Plans for obtaining the necessary staff resources, capacity for expansion, hiring policy, employee training, space for additional staff, staffing levels needed for provision of expanded technical, support, escrow, and registry services.
Recruiting: The Registry will recruit and hire a full-time Human Resources Manager to lead the recruiting of staff resources, and will be assisted by AtomicTangerine and Alliant Technologies to screen competencies of potential technical candidates. Internal recruiting will be supplemented by fee-based, external professional recruiting services. The Human Resource Manager will assure that job descriptions have been developed for all positions, which would include salary ranges. One of the benefits of being located in New Jersey, and in particular in the Princeton area, is the relatively fertile market for skilled technology personnel. The Registry will appeal to new recruits with its challenging and open work environment, and the added prestige of being a venture company of the Sarnoff Corporation.
Capacity for Expansion: As the Registry operations grow from 25 to 100 employees over a 3-year period, the Registry will recruit additional professional managers to help implement more formal lines of responsibility. Primary growth areas in staffing are projected to be in sales, customer support, and operations support.
Employee Training: One of the Registry’s main responsibilities will be to enhance the abilities of the employees and support them in the development of new skills. Technology companies need to provide their employees with a sense of challenge, so that they are motivated to continually improve and deepen their skills to meet the changes in the marketplace. This environment creates incentive among employees to pursue new methodologies and chart new territory. Alliant Technologies will provide Registry technical personnel with technical training, in addition to mentoring and knowledge transfer.
Hiring: The company’s hiring policy will involve selecting candidates with diverse backgrounds academically, professionally, and culturally.
Space for Additional Staff: Office space will initially be leased to accommodate approximately 60 employees, with opportunities to scale up quickly to 200 employees or more. The Registry will seek short-term leasing arrangements to provide flexibility to acquire additional space or move to larger facilities. In that respect, New Jersey and the Princeton area are very conducive to finding world class office space that is available with ease. Alliant Technologies is assisting with identifying the proper facility.
Additional Considerations: With Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine championing this new venture, there is especially strong capability to expand staff as needed to handle increasing demand and transaction volume. Both firms have the ability to provide the quantity and quality of individuals who are suited to scale the Registry organization under subcontract as needed. In addition, Alliant Technologies will be on standby to provide for any short-term increased staffing levels needed for provision of expanded technical, support, escrow, and registry services.
AtomicTangerine, as a 250-person venture consulting firm, has many staff who have worked at startups and who have extremely strong technical backgrounds. The majority of employees have built Internet exchanges, implemented security, or designed and implemented systems using cutting-edge technology. Moreover, AtomicTangerine’s venture launch services include individuals knowledgeable in corporate functions such as finance, legal, and branding and marketing. All of these capabilities are available to assist the Registry.
In addition, it is important to note that AtomicTangerine’s genesis was as SRI Consulting, the technology and strategy consulting arm of SRI International. SRI International continues to be a significant shareholder in AtomicTangerine and the two firms continue to partner on projects. SRI International, which was the first operator of Internet domains for 15 years, is similarly staffed with individuals who possess some of the world’s most cutting-edge technology innovation skills, and continues to give AtomicTangerine access to those staff.
D13.2.9. Availability of additional management personnel. How will management needs be filled?
AtomicTangerine, as a venture consulting firm, often inserts its own top executives into startups to enhance the budding management team. The firm has several particularly strong candidates with experience very relevant to this Registry operation, including:
Yadunath Zambre, Chief Technology Officer, AtomicTangerine
AtomicTangerine’s chief technology officer, specializes in speech recognition and computer networking technologies, and is currently working with the Nuance speech recognition system. He periodically teaches graduate classes on digital multimedia technology at Stanford University, where his students have done projects ranging from Java-based Internet shopping applications to voice control for networked virtual environments. Dr. Zambre has also been an invited speaker on Internet technology and its applications at international scientific conferences and at artists’ guild workshops in Hollywood. He has applied and integrated new and old technologies in a wide variety of settings. He has experience programming Sun, VAX, Xerox, IBM, and PC systems with C/C++, Java, Fortran, and assembler. Before joining AtomicTangerine and, previously, SRI International, Dr. Zambre cofounded a company that wrote software for diagnosing and analyzing errors in particle accelerators. The software was sold to international and U.S. laboratories and, on average, has reduced accelerator downtime by a factor of five. In many cases, the resulting cost reduction per incident exceeds US $200,000. Dr. Zambre holds a B.S. (cum laude) and M.S. (awarded simultaneously with the B.S.) in engineering from Yale University, and a Ph.D. in applied physics from Stanford University.
Sterling Stoudenmire, Vice President, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Sterling Stoudenmire has more than 11 years of experience in strategy and information technology consulting, and has worked with numerous "dot-com" clients in the formation, capitalization and emergent stages. He has a unique combination of business acumen across a variety of industries and expertise in emerging technologies, frequently acting as overall architect for new business opportunities. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Stoudenmire served as director, e-business strategy, for Arthur Andersen LLP. He is a frequent public speaker on e-business, information rules, and "innovation through information technology" for organizational change and competitive advantage. Past audiences include the World Economic Forum, AA’s E-Business Video Series, and the Florida Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Mr. Stoudenmire holds a B.S. in finance from Florida State University.
Norm Nielsen, Technology Director, AtomicTangerine
Norm Nielsen has worked extensively with major corporations on four continents to assess and deploy information technology to achieve strategic business objectives and improve profitability. Dr. Nielsen specializes in computer systems design and architecture evaluation, information technology assessment and strategy, networked and distributed systems, data- and knowledge-based systems (e.g., data warehousing and data mining, intelligent scheduling), and information security and risk assessments. He has led numerous projects that assisted companies in using information technology to strategic advantage. Before joining AtomicTangerine and, previously, SRI International, Dr. Nielsen served as a faculty member at Stanford University. He is listed in Who’s Who in America and Who’s Who in Science and Engineering and is a member of Phi Beta Kappa and other national honor societies. In addition to serving as treasurer of AAAI, he is a member of AAAS, the ACM, the Computer Society of the IEEE, and INFORMS. He has written more than 75 articles and papers on information technology topics, as well as 2 books relating to the practical application of artificial intelligence technology. Dr. Nielsen holds a B.A. in mathematics (summa cum laude) from Pomona College, an MBA in management science and a Ph.D. in operations and systems analysis from Stanford University
Sanjay Deo, Technology Director, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Sanjay Deo has more than 10 years of experience in software development—custom as well as product—and has provided management consulting services to startups, spin-offs, and brick-and-mortar clients in the information services, telecommunications, entertainment, health care and high-tech industry sectors. His specific expertise lies in building B2B digital marketplaces and Internet security. He is also experienced in IT strategy, technology assessment, systems design and integration, and process innovation. Recent work includes a project involving the first MRO Latin American digital marketplace. Mr. Deo formulated business strategy, created internal business processes and procedures, integrated buyers and sellers, selected and implemented platform and infrastructure and a customer relationship management system, and provided overall internationalization, customization and integration of the digital marketplace engine. In another project for one of the largest U.S. retailers, Mr. Deo identified the software and hardware required to handle 60,000 orders per hour, scaling up to 240,000 orders per hour in the next 5 years Before joining AtomicTangerine, he was director of the Advanced Technology Group in Arthur Andersen’s Business Consulting practice. In previous work, Mr. Deo was with CyberGuard Corporation, where he focused on design and implementation of high-assurance operating systems, and architected three firewalls for three operating systems. He holds a B.E. in computer engineering from the University of Bombay and an M.S. in computer science from Texas A&M, College Station, Texas.
Donald Holden (CISSP), Business Leader, Information Security, AtomicTangerine
Don Holden has more than 20 years of experience in information systems, security, encryption, business continuity and disaster recovery planning. He has written numerous white papers and given presentations on information security management and technology issues such as intrusion detection, firewalls, biometric authentication and digital watermarking. Mr. Holden is currently the chairman of the IEEE Computer Society working group on recommended best practices for Internet security. He is also participating in the development of security standards for the financial industry. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Holden was a senior consultant for SRI Consulting, where he was a project leader for an Internet startup assignment to plan a revolutionary secure electronic commerce portal-based business. He previously served as program manager for Compaq’s Security Program Office and as the director of operations research at a major Boston bank. Mr. Holden holds an MBA from Wharton and a B.S. in business and accounting from Georgetown University. He is a Certified Information System Security Professional (CISSP) and a member of the IEEE Computer Society, the Computer Security Institute, and the Information Systems Security Association.
Stephen Whitlock, Technology Leader, AtomicTangerine
Stephen Whitlock specializes in cryptography, UNIX and network security. Mr. Whitlock is an internationally recognized expert in the field of information security. His background includes the development of tools for testing system security as well as publications and presentations on cryptography, UNIX and network security. For many years, he functioned as an internal corporate consultant on cryptographic and security issues. Among other work, Mr. Whitlock developed an encryption strategy for large, multi-platform enterprise environments, which was presented to the U.S. Office of Science and Technology Policy, the National Security Council and the FBI. The results directly affected the Clinton Administration’s U.S. Encryption Policy. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Stephen was an advanced computing technologist in the mathematics and computing technology division of Boeing’s Phantom Works. He has been an active participant in the security activities of the Electronic Messaging Association, Internet Engineering Task Force, Key Recovery Alliance, Object Management Group and the Open Group. He is currently the chair of the Open Group’s Security and Electronic Commerce Program Group and as such has been involved in the development of several standards, including the Architecture for a Public Key Infrastructure, Common Data Security Architecture and Advanced Authorization API. Mr. Whitlock holds a B.S. in electronic engineering technology from the Weber State University and an M.S. in software engineering from Seattle University.
Likewise, Sarnoff and its incubator nVention also have much experience in new technology venture creation. nVention will assist the Registry with incubation and growth phase needs. Experience available at nVention includes:
Glenn A. Reitmeier, Vice President, Sarnoff Corporation
Glenn Reitmeier is Vice President of Internet Technology Strategy and Development at Sarnoff Corporation. His career has pioneered the development of digital television, digital media and digital convergence. He has created and led world-leading developments in Digital Cinema, object coding and wavelet image compression in MPEG-4, MPEG-2 compressed bitstream processing and integrated circuits for digital television receivers. His efforts have contributed to the formation of six new startup companies and resulted in three technical Emmy awards. Mr. Reitmeier was one of the leading contributors to establishing the ATSC Digital Television standard that was approved by the FCC in 1996. In the Digital HDTV Grand Alliance, he performed in both technical and strategic capacities, and was the leader of Grand Alliance computer interoperability efforts. He has also led projects related to developing new technologies for consumer information services, including computer and network architectures, Digital Signal Processing modems and natural language software. Earlier, Mr. Reitmeier was a contributor to the establishment of the world’s first digital television standards (the ITU 601 sampling standard and the D1 tape standard) that are now in widespread use in the broadcast industry. He holds over 40 patents in digital television technology. He received the B.E.E. degree summa cum laude in 1977 and an M.S.E. degree in Systems Engineering from the University of Pennsylvania in 1979.
Shailendra K. Suman, Executive Director, Sarnoff
Shailendra K. Suman is Executive Director of Sarnoff Corporation and General Partner of nVention. He is responsible for the business and strategy development, market analysis and strategic alliances for nVention and its ventures. Prior to joining Sarnoff, Mr. Suman served in various management capacities for several energy-related companies, including responsibilities for strategy as well as new venture development. Mr. Suman received his BS in Mechanical Engineering from B.I.T. Sindri, India, an MS in Control Systems from University of Alabama, and an MBA in Finance and Strategy from University of Minnesota in 1986, 1989, and 1995 respectively. He completed all the coursework towards a Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering at Columbia University, NY in 1989. Mr. Suman is a member of the Conference Board’s International Council of Innovation & Technology Management and the Institute of Electronics and Electrical Engineers.
Nova Spivack, Founder, Lucid Ventures; Entrepreneur in Residence, nVention
Nova Spivack is Founder, President and CEO of Lucid Ventures Inc. and Co-Founder and CEO of Lucid Associates, LLC. Mr Spivack has been an Internet venture strategy advisor to Sarnoff Corporation for the past year and a prime mover in its decision to create nVention. Mr Spivack was a Co-Founder, Executive Vice President , and Director of EarthWeb Inc., an industry-leading Internet venture, since 1994. He co-led the company from startup through an historic IPO (the first business-to-business IPO and one of the all-time best first-day gainers) and a secondary public offering, serving as executive vice-president for product development and strategy. Mr. Spivack, a published author and frequent keynote speaker, is currently developing several new proprietary patents in the areas of GPS technology, Internet television, wireless consumer electronics, Internet radio, artificial intelligence and augmented reality, and is the principal inventor of multiple fundamental patents related to simulcasting Internet content with television broadcasts for use in entertainment, education, sports, news and information services. Mr Spivack is among the top-rated featured "Internet Business Experts" on Expert-central.com, part of the About.com network and has been interviewed by many prominent publications.
Rafael Alonso, Head, Computing Systems Research Group, Information Sciences Laboratory, Sarnoff Corporation
Rafael Alonso obtained a Ph.D. in Computer Science from U.C. Berkeley in 1986 where he held an IBM Fellowship. He was a faculty member at Princeton University from 1984 to 1992 where he graduated three doctoral students, obtained several government and industrial grants, and developed two new courses. In 1991 he co-founded the Matsushita Information Technology Laboratory to develop leading edge information and video systems for Panasonic. Dr. Alonso obtained two U.S. patents for his work, and his research team contributed software to a number of products, as well as developed a non-linear editing system prototype shown at the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) Conference. Dr. Alonso is presently Head of Computing Systems Research at Sarnoff Corporation where he oversees research projects in a number of areas including Web-based collaboration tools, online learning, video databases, and development of MPEG encoding algorithms. He is also currently coordinating two product development efforts. Dr. Alonso's current research interests include organizational memory, multimedia database systems, video servers, mobile information systems, and heterogeneous database systems. Dr. Alonso has published over 40 refereed papers, been a member of more than 20 Program Committees, and is currently on the editorial board of several technical journals.
James R. Bergen, Head, Information Technologies Initiatives, Sarnoff Corporation
James R. Bergen is an expert in the technologies of image processing, computer vision, visual psychophysics, and visual perception, with special competence in motion and visual texture (from perceptual and algorithmic standpoints), adaptive video signal processing, computer vision, and image analysis systems. A three-time recipient of the David Sarnoff Technical Achievement Award (1983, 1987, 1991), Dr. Bergen has authored or co-authored forty (40) technical publications and book chapters. He holds a BA in Mathematics and Psychology (1975) from the University of California at Berkeley and a PhD in Biophysics and Theoretical Biology (1981) from the University of Chicago. Dr. Bergen was a postdoctoral member of the technical staff at Bell Laboratories in Murray Hill, NJ.
D13.2.10. Term of registry agreement. State assumptions regarding the term of any registry agreement with ICANN or the sponsoring organization. Note that the .com/.net/.org registry agreement has a basic term of four years.
An initial Registry term of 10 years is proposed. The proposed TLD is targeting a new market need that has not been served so far. In addition, the creation of an open standards platform for applications and services development that will serve the interest of all constituents will play out over a number of years. Enough time has to be allotted for the full evolution of the applications and services detailed in this document, as well as the realization of the overall vision for the DNS to provide a name space for and enhance individual’s lifestyles.
D13.2.11. Expected costs associated with the operation of the proposed registry. Please break down the total estimated operational costs by the sources of the costs for each estimated demand level. Be sure to consider the TLD's share of ICANN's cost recovery needs. (See <http://www.icann.org/financials/budget-fy00-01-06jun00.htm#IIIB>.)
Operating Costs
The costs associated with the Registry are categorized in the following manner.
1. Personnel
Personnel will grow with the increasing demands of the Registry. The major functional areas of personnel are Customer Service, Finance, HR, IT, and Marketing. For budgetary purposes we will view the personnel costs in the following structure: Management, Corporate Functions, Staff, Customer Support, Sr. Systems Administrators, Jr. Systems Administrator, System Engineers and Support Engineers. the financial plan (see D.13.3) are Personnel salaries and benefits per quarter for the first 4 years are detailed within the financial projections (see D.13.3).
2. Electronic Registry Infrastructure
The entire electronic registry infrastructure comprises hardware, software and services. Best of breed partners such as Alliant Technologies, Cisco, EMC, Exodus, Oracle, and Sun provide the hardware, software and services necessary to create, maintain and monitor the electronic registry.
Within the attached financial plan these items are categorized as hardware & software purchase costs, Registry monitoring and architecture maintenance fees, communication links, and hardware & software on-going maintenance.
3. Registry Office Infrastructure
A mix of vendors has been chosen for the tools necessary for office automation and business operations. The vendors for the infrastructure are Cisco, Dell, Microsoft, and Sun. The software providers are GreatPlains/Siebel, Kana, and Microsoft.
The Registry will be located within New Jersey for its favorable business environment and excellent access to resources.
The infrastructure line items within the financial projections (see Section D.13.3) are for equipment, software, services and maintenance, and rent and utilities.
4. Registry Office Professional Services Costs
The professional services line item consists of legal, auditing and accounting. In addition, the Registry will rely on the services of a professional marketing and advertising firm with a proven history and an understanding of the online space.
5. Registry Office Expendables
Administrative expenses within the financial plan are the day-to-day operating costs of the Registry, which are comprised of desktop hardware and software, office supplies, corporate insurance, postage, messenger, telephone costs and travel.
6. ICANN Cost Recovery
The Registry will reimburse ICANN its share of the cost-recovery needs. Currently that figure is estimated to be in the range of US $500,000-US $600,000.
NOTE: For detailed cost breakdowns at the 10%, 50%, and 90% confidence levels, please see Section D13.2.6 above.
D13.2.12. Expected revenue for the proposed registry
The key revenue stream for the proposed Registry derives from the fees from the Startup period and the ongoing wholesale fees for standard and customized Personal Domain Names (see Section D13.2.5 for a discussion of the estimated demand for each). The calculation is a straightforward linear equation:
# users x
[ (% Startup x avg. startup fee)
+ (% standard format x standard wholesale fee)
+ (% customized x customized wholesale fee) ]
We have employed the following assumptions in our calculations:
Using these values for the variables in our revenue model, we calculate resulting fee revenues at roughly US $6.6 M, US $31.7 M, US $66.1 M, and US $134.8 M for the first 4 years, respectively.
Year |
Year 1 |
Year 2 |
Year 3 |
Year 4 |
Fees(US $/name) |
||||
Free Numeric |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
Standard Format |
$ 2.00 |
$ 2.00 |
$ 2.00 |
$ 2.00 |
Customized |
$ 4.00 |
$ 4.00 |
$ 4.00 |
$ 4.00 |
Customized – Startup Period |
$ 10.00 |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
Total Users (millions) – base case |
1.87 |
14.3 |
34.7 |
76 |
% Free Numeric |
20% |
30% |
36% |
40% |
% Standard Format |
30% |
35% |
32% |
30% |
% Customized |
30% |
35% |
32% |
30% |
% Customized - Startup |
20% |
0% |
0% |
0% |
Total |
100% |
100% |
100% |
100% |
Total revenues ($millions) |
||||
Free Numeric Names |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
$ - |
Standard Format @ US $ 2/name |
$ 1.5 |
$ 9.9 |
$ 21.4 |
$ 44.4 |
Customized @ US $ 4/name |
$ 3.0 |
$ 19.8 |
$ 42.9 |
$ 88.7 |
Customized Startup @ US $10/name |
$ 3.0 |
$ 3.0 |
$ 3.0 |
$ 3.0 |
Total (in US $) |
$ 7.5 |
$ 32.7 |
$ 67.3 |
$ 136.1 |
D13.2.13. Capital requirements. Quantify capital requirements in amount and timing and describe how the capital will be obtained. Specify in detail all sources of capital and the cost of that capital (interest, etc.). Evidence of firm commitment of projected capital needs will substantially increase the credibility of the registry operator's proposal.
Since 1987 Sarnoff revenues have grown from US $75 million to over US $120 million. During that same period the company’s value, including holding in new ventures, has increased from US $75 million to over US $250 million. Sarnoff has created and assisted in private equity financing from leading VC firms totaling more than $200 million for its over 19 new ventures. Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine will assist the proposed Registry in gaining required capital through its network of leading venture capital firms. Funding for the Registry has been additionally committed from Arnhold and S. Belishroeder, Inc. as discussed in the attached letter (see "Proof of Capital", Section D.13.4.4).
D13.2.14. Business risks and opportunities. Describe upside and downside contingencies you have considered and discuss your plans for addressing them.
The novel services proposed in this application, specifically in section D13.2.1, represent numerous opportunities that could be pursued. In addition, there are other opportunities that may present themselves due to positive occurrences outside our control.
De facto adoption: The new TLD’s mission is to provide a name space and an enabling platform for applications and services to individuals, and as such we intend to market it to individuals. However, organizations such as companies, universities, or even whole countries may choose to adopt the TLD personal domain name as the de facto address for their employees, students, or citizens, respectively. This would obviously speed adoption tremendously, as these organizations would encourage their members to obtain a personal domain name.
Cashless society: Many trends in society today suggest that more and more cash transactions are being replaced by electronic equivalents. In the event that tangible cash usage continues to wane or disappears entirely, this would provide whole new reasons to use the personal domain name as a funnel for an individual’s e-commerce transactions.
Enhancement to privacy/security: We have already witnessed growing concern about the privacy of individuals’ communications. Notable topics in the news include employer access to employees’ email, "spam" and Internet marketing in general; and Doubleclick’s mission to match Internet addresses with demographic information. All of these have stirred the public concern over individual privacy. If these concerns are compounded by a newsworthy catastrophic event or series of events that affects a large group of individuals, the public outcry will lead to a call for more secure personal communications. We believe that the services proposed for the TLD could solve many of the issues that haunt consumers today, because it gives them so much greater control over how, when, and with whom they communicate. Therefore, a backlash against security threats could lead to increased demand for personal domain names. The Registry is committed to building a highly secure solution, with the help of AtomicTangerine’s renowned expertise in information security.
The business described in this application will face challenges as well. New players in any emerging field face three possible categories of business risk: market risk, management risk, and financial risk.
Market Risk
Market risk is that individuals may not request a Personal Domain Name as quickly as we have predicted or they may decide to request the free numeric domain name instead of a paid one. They may also elect not to buy many of the value-added services. There is the risk that demand among users will not match the supply presented by competing providers. However, there are several trends suggesting that this risk is minimal:
Management Risk
Management risk at start-ups falls along two key dimensions: industry and entrepreneurial. The first refers to the executives’ lack of direct experience in the business’s industry area; the second refers to the lack of previous start-up experience among the founding team. The combination of Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine mitigates both forms of risk.
Financial Risk
Financial risk stems from the need to subsidize the free identifiers with the fees collected from paid registration and value-added services. We believe, given the low market risk described above, we have a compelling model by which the collected revenues will be sufficient to run a successful Registry operation on an ongoing basis.
13.2.15. Registry failure provisions. Please describe in detail your plans for dealing with the possibility of registry failure.
The Registry will take every step necessary to ensure that its customers and the users who rely on it are never without service. The first line in handling failure will be to ensure, to the greatest extent possible, that it never occurs. From a technical point of view, this means maintaining stable, robust equipment that is fully redundant, with all data backed-up and stored at off-site locations. The details of the Registry’s technical proposal, including the provisions for redundant equipment and back-up services, are set forth below in Section D.15.
In the unlikely event that the Registry fails as a business, it will make every effort to ensure that a transition to a new registry provider is seamless and invisible to its users and customers.
To this end, the Registry will work to set aside sufficient working capital to guarantee that it can continue to provide stable registry operations for a period of time sufficient to allow a smooth transition to a new registry even in the absence of revenue to the Registry.
To guarantee that any successor registry is able to take over the Registry’s operations in the event of a failure, the Registry will deliver all registry data and software to agreed escrow agent on any reasonable schedule specified by ICANN. The Registry will provide any ICANN-designated successor registry with a royalty-free, perpetual, worldwide license to any registry-related software, data or other work in which the Registry maintains a copyright.
In short, supporting its users and customers and maintaining the stability of the Internet are of paramount importance to the Registry, and it will take whatever steps necessary to ensure that the company's failure, however unlikely, does not impact the interests of others or the Internet as a whole.
D.13.3 Pro-forma financial projections: Please provide detailed pro-forma financial projections, consistent with your business plan, for the demand scenarios that you estimate under item D13.2.5. The pro-formas should show revenue and expense estimates broken down by detailed categories and should be broken down into periods no longer than quarterly.
Please see the following spreadsheets for Pro-forma financial projections.
Notes to financial projections:
B4. Renewals are calculated at 5% attrition year to year. This projection is based on historic facts and our proposed low cost of domain names.
C2. Hardware/Software – Registry Infrastructure consists of the following hardware/software components:
One-time Hardware & Software cost $1,737,523
Cisco equipment incl. Premium maintenance $814,225
Oracle parallel server software $299,754
Installation and setup (Exodus) $254,044
Help desk software $ 69,500
Software to generate zone file $ 50,000
SRS software development $ 150,000
Software-billing and collection $ 100,000
Monthly Recurring Charges $345,213
Exodus Services incl. Sun server rental $325,213
Monthly lease on EMC Symmetrix 8430-18 $ 20,000
Infrastructure cost has been calculated based on a one time expense for hardware and software, plus monthly expenses for a state-of-the-art, highly secure, hosting environment. The monthly figures are kept flat for the projected 4 years taking into account Moore’s law and the resulting reduction in cost of computing expenses that occur over time. Since the incremental cost savings are negligible, the infrastructure cost has been projected at the same rate at all confidence levels.
C3. Data lines: T1 data lines will be used to connect the Registry data facility to the corporate headquarters for remote monitoring and maintenance. All together, there are six T1 lines planned.
C4. Maintenance fee: This projected cost will meet the requirement to upgrade or service the technical infrastructure.
C6. Computer equipment, services and maintenance: Includes cost of providing state-of-the-art MIS, and other related inter-office technical infrastructure.
C8. Details of employees in each category are provided in section D.13.2.6.
C10. Corporate functions will account for Legal Counsel, Managers for Accounting, Marketing, Administration, etc.
C15. Employee benefits are calculated at 25% of the total payroll.
C17. Marketing and advertising. Marketing and advertising expenses have been projected at a flat rate for the four years at all three confidence levels. This expense represent overall global information dissemination, branding, product positioning, product introduction, advisory/alliance creation expenses, etc. These expenditures will be adjusted as needed across categories as well as in terms of gross total as per the proposed operating metrics once launched.
C18. Professional fees to cover professional accounting and auditing functions, any additional legal fees, etc.
C.19. Administrative expenses to cover the cost of maintaining office, office equipment, insurance, and other miscellaneous expenses. Y1 Q1 projection includes one- time expenses for office equipment purchases.
C21. ICANN Cost Recovery is projected based on the yearly estimate of $250,000 published by ICANN at their website.
Also please note that for the 90% confidence level, Business Office infrastructure, HR, administrative and travel costs have been scaled down from the 50% confidence level due to expected lower operational overheads . The expense and infrastructure projections for the 50% confidence level will be adequate to meet the operational overhead.
D13.4. Supporting documentation. The following documentation should be provided in support of the Business Capabilities and Plan section:
D13.4.1. Registry operator's organizational documents. Documents of incorporation (or similar documents).
D13.4.2. References. A list of significant trade and credit references.
Sarnoff’s Industrial Credit References: |
|
BOC Gases |
MEMC |
Griffith Electrical Supply Company |
The Workstation |
Hoya Corporation USA |
Client and corporate references can be provided on request. |
AtomicTangerine’s Client References: |
|
Motorola |
Extant |
Kurt Estes, |
Sprint |
DuPont |
Smile |
Hoya Corporation USA |
Mitsubishi Electric |
Blakely Sokoloff Taylor & Zafman |
Oki Electric |
County of San Mateo |
AtomicTangerine’s Client References
Motorola
"AtomicTangerine has provided significant value to Motorola through its Venture Consulting model. AtomicTangerine’s entrepreneurial, technological and strategic expertise has allowed Motorola to create an entirely new company from previously under-utilized assets."
- Kurt Estes, Manager, Strategic Intellectual Assets, Motorola
DuPont
"AtomicTangerine has improved DuPont’s information security systems along with creating key educational methodologies for DuPont’s Information Securities Organization. AtomicTangerine’s informational securities expertise and experience in education make the organization highly valuable to DuPont. The AtomicTangerine consultants I’ve dealt with have been world class and the execution of AtomicTangerine’s services at DuPont have been excellent."
- Michael Leach, VP, DuPont’s Information Security Organization
Blakely Sokoloff Taylor & Zafman
"AtomicTangerine’s technical expertise has been extremely valuable to our I.P. law firm. The company has greatly enhanced the functionality and overall capability of our Web site along with creating a first rate content management solution and data repository. We are quite impressed with the professionalism and level of energy that AtomicTangerine brings to the engagement. Over the next five to ten years, BST&Z looks forward to AtomicTangerine assisting us as we continue to grow and expand."
- Tarek Fahmi, Partner, BST&Z
County of San Mateo
"AtomicTangerine is providing a detailed blueprint for the implementation of a countywide intranet that will significantly enhance and revolutionize communication among police departments in San Mateo County. Of the fifteen bidders considered for this project, only AtomicTangerine possessed the scientific background to address our needs. The implementation and carrying out of AtomicTangerine’s services has been impeccable and I would rate the company’s level of professionalism first rate. "
- Jim Granucci, Chief of Police of San Carlos
Extant
"AtomicTangerine has provided first rate business strategies as well as valuable internal process reviews to Extant. AtomicTangerine’s strategic personnel are highly professional, in fact, world class. The execution of AtomicTangerine’s services at Extant have been outstanding and I would certainly recommend AtomicTangerine in the future."
- Dan Donahue, VP Strategy, Extant
D13.4.3. Annual report. The registry operator's most recent annual financial report (or similar document). Audited financials are preferred.
Sarnoff Corporation and Subsidiaries’ Consolidated Financial Statements and Schedules for December 31, 1999 and December 31, 1998.
D13.4.4. Proof of capital. Provide evidence of existing capital or firm commitments of capital. Demonstrated access to necessary capital will be carefully scrutinized.
D13.4.5. Proof of insurance. Please provide proof of the insurance described in item D13.1.8.
Insurance documents are confidential but can be provided upon request.
III. TECHNICAL CAPABILITIES AND PLAN
D15.1 Detailed description of the registry operator's technical capabilities
The Registry Operator will capitalize on the Sarnoff Corporation and AtomicTangerine’s superior technical knowledge. Specifically, the proposed Registry Operator will have access to:
SRI’s Registry Experience
The parent of both Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine, SRI International’s precursor -- Stanford Research Institute – created the ARPAnet, including developing and managing HOSTS.TXT (DNS’s predecessor). Later, when HOSTS.TXT encountered difficulties scaling to accommodate the exponential growth in Internet use, SRI International helped to craft a new standard, the Domain Name System (DNS). With 15 years of experience as the first operator of Internet domains, SRI International has a unique and in-depth understanding of how to develop and maintain a successful Registry Operation. Thus, SRI International’s collective memory will assist the proposed Registry Operator in creating and maintaining an efficient, quality Registry for the proposed TLD.
AtomicTangerine
In addition to contributing its new venture creation expertise (see Section D13.1.6), AtomicTangerine managers will play a key technical role in building and maintaining the Registry and in ensuring that proper levels of security are consistently maintained. AtomicTangerine’s computer and Internet consultants are skilled in analyzing business requirements and creating functional specifications, as well as in designing site structure and information architecture, and its managers will be instrumental in ensuring the Registry’s success.
In addition, AtomicTangerine (and prior to that, SRI Consulting) is world-renowned for its information security practice. AtomicTangerine’s information security professionals will provide key insights and input as the joint venture with Sarnoff prepares to become the Registry Operator for the proposed TLD. The AtomicTangerine Information Security practice is staffed by industry leading security professionals who have conducted more than 500 information security reviews worldwide and 3,500 cases in computer crime for financial services organizations, telecommunications companies, and the U.S. Departments of Justice and Defense. The company hosts the International Information Integrity Institute (I-4®), providing ongoing best practices and information security breakthroughs for a closed-door, invite-only list of FORTUNE 500 companies and government agencies. For instance, recently an AtomicTangerine team developed an information-security vulnerability benchmarking methodology using extensive network attack data. Based on those data, AtomicTangerine created a spin-off company and built it into a portal for online information security content and consulting. As a result of this work, AtomicTangerine obtained US $5.5 M of funding on a US $20 M valuation.
Sarnoff Corporation
As a global organization that has created some of the most pervasive technologies of the century, Sarnoff has a world-renowned history as a premier developer of entertainment, consumer, and commercial products that have fundamentally changed the modern world. Many of the products used by consumers today were invented by Sarnoff.
Successful Venture Creation
In fact, Sarnoff has not only been a leader in industry, it has helped create new industries, successfully nurturing and spinning off new ventures regularly during the past several decades. Sarnoff builds value and other sources of continuing revenue through equity positions in ventures that make use of its technical innovations. These ventures, referred to as Sarnoff Technology Ventures (STVs), reflect the breadth and depth of Sarnoff’s technology and managerial capabilities.
Sarnoff incubates these companies, building the value in each company by developing its technology to a pre-commercial level, and then raising funds for commercialization. Exclusive licenses may be granted to STVs in Sarnoff’s intellectual property in specific fields of use. Sarnoff’s staff acts to fill critical technical and leadership roles in the company until the STV can recruit a full management and technical team and reach critical mass on its own.
The benefit of this model is that Sarnoff lowers the risk of execution and can deliver on its commitments by having a team in place that has delivered on many highly challenging problems and milestones. This established business model has been put into practice to create many new companies over the past 10 years (See Appendix A). Among them are (partial list):
E-Vue, Inc. – An MPEG-4 multimedia technology service company that is developing streaming multimedia products for the Internet.
Princeton Lightwave – Designs and manufactures high-performance optical components for advanced network applications.
Pyramid Vision Technologies (PVT) – The world’s highest performance computer vision systems for video production stabilization.
Secure Products – Develops anti-counterfeiting and anti-diversion systems through unique marking and recognition technology and is the only company with a phosphor-tag security system in US currency.
Sensar, Inc. – This company has introduced an iris recognition biometric system for financial services applications.
VideoBrush™ Corporation – VideoBrush and its technology (PC-based software that creates high-resolution or panoramic images from video and digital photographic input) were recently acquired by PictureWorks Technology, Inc.
Technology Expertise
Sarnoff remains a leading US organization in video, broadcasting, and displays and has a worldwide reputation in the following areas of expertise. With the convergence of the Internet and broadcast media, many of these technologies are becoming increasingly relevant to those who would operate in the Internet space.
Today, Sarnoff files an average of two patents every week, making it one of the most productive generators of new technology in the US. Sarnoff’s partners and clients include multinational corporations, government agencies, research universities and leading high-tech organizations including Motorola, Thomson, Toshiba, SmithKline Beecham, and government organizations such as the National Imagery and Mapping Agency (NIMA) and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA).
Sarnoff's technological achievements have changed the way information is stored, retrieved and shared. A sample of past developments is presented below, including a brief description of each technology.
Databases — Sarnoff has been vigorously developing capabilities in database management systems (DBMS) for commercial and Government applications. These include: Distributed Databases; Mobile Database Systems; Object-Oriented DBMS; Object-relational DBMS; Information System Architecture; Data Caching and Replication; DBMS Query Optimization; Distributed File Systems; Video on Demand; and Multimedia Storage Systems.
Infobase — Sarnoff has developed techniques for capturing and tracking information about an analysis process and enabling access to that information through querying and visualization processes. This approach, embodied in an object-oriented database framework, also provides a mechanism for explicit sharing of information among analysts. These techniques have been applied to a wide range of collaborative tasks including mapping (Infobase), open source analysis (NSA/ADE) and distance education (CLASS).
Video Indexing — Sarnoff developed new algorithms to find scenes in videos by color, texture content, and other attributes. A web-based client-server demonstration system has been created that shows how non-linear content-based access of videos at the clip level can be accomplished efficiently. This system combines spatial indexing through video mosaic based indexing with appearance based indexing to allow a user to sift through and access a large collection of videos at the clip level.
Video Storage — Sarnoff is pioneering the use of MPEG compression technology in the television broadcast studio environment, inventing novel ways to perform switching, editing, and processing on compressed data. While this was once widely believed to be impossible, Sarnoff technology allows video to be efficiently stored and manipulated in the broadcast studio environment, reducing storage capacity and costs by at least a factor of 4.
MPEG-7 — This is a recent effort to standardize the multimedia content description interface, so that efficient and interoperable content-based search and retrieval methods can be achieved. Potential applications are in multimedia content creation, re-use of multimedia data and its distribution, digital library, etc. Sarnoff actively participates in this standardization effort through relevant technical contributions.
Multiresolution Pyramid Databases — Sarnoff has pioneered Image Pyramids, which allow images to be represented and processed at multiple spatial resolutions. Pyramid representations decompose the imagery into their fundamental components at different spatial scales. Pyramids also support fast processing, information-based selection of focus of attention, and enable real-time processing of video sequences. Images and video stored in databases can be organized using pyramid representations. These representations support highly efficient image and video compression, progressive transmission, rapid indexing based on multiresolution image content, and efficient manipulation of image and video information.
Specialized Web Servers — Sarnoff has developed a unique Distance Learning server with novel functionality, such as student activity monitoring, student-driven information tagging, and support for teacher-student collaboration.
With a 58-year record of significant scientific contributions, inventions, successful spinoffs, and achievements, including seven Emmys for technical excellence, Sarnoff is well positioned to lead the charge in creating and enabling the next TLD as well as the related next generation of Internet applications. For a complete list of Sarnoff’s pioneering contributions over the last 58 years, see Section D15.1.4.
D15.1.1 Key technical personnel (qualifications and experience).
Note: Please see Appendix C for complete resumes.
Yadunath Zambre, Chief Technology Officer, AtomicTangerine
Yadunath Zambre specializes in speech recognition and computer networking technologies, and is currently working with the Nuance speech recognition system. He periodically teaches graduate classes on digital multimedia technology at Stanford University, where his students have done projects ranging from Java-based Internet shopping applications to voice control for networked virtual environments. Dr. Zambre has also been an invited speaker on Internet technology and its applications at international scientific conferences and at artists’ guild workshops in Hollywood. He has applied and integrated new and old technologies in a wide variety of settings. He has experience programming Sun, VAX, Xerox, IBM, and PC systems with C/C++, Java, Fortran, and assembler. Before joining AtomicTangerine and, previously, SRI International, Dr. Zambre cofounded a company that wrote software for diagnosing and analyzing errors in particle accelerators. The software was sold to international and U.S. laboratories and, on average, has reduced accelerator downtime by a factor of five. In many cases, the resulting cost reduction per incident exceeds US $200,000. Dr. Zambre holds a B.S. (cum laude) and M.S. (awarded simultaneously with the B.S.) in engineering from Yale University, and a Ph.D. in applied physics from Stanford University.
Sterling Stoudenmire, Vice President, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Sterling Stoudenmire has more than 11 years of experience in strategy and information technology consulting, and has worked with numerous "dot-com" clients in the formation, capitalization and emergent stages. He has a unique combination of business acumen across a variety of industries and expertise in emerging technologies, frequently acting as overall architect for new business opportunities. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Stoudenmire served as director, e-business strategy, for Arthur Andersen LLP. He is a frequent public speaker on e-business, information rules, and "innovation through information technology" for organizational change and competitive advantage. Past audiences include the World Economic Forum, AA’s E-Business Video Series, and the Florida Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Mr. Stoudenmire holds a B.S. in finance from Florida State University.
Norm Nielsen, Technology Director, AtomicTangerine
Norm Nielsen has worked extensively with major corporations on four continents to assess and deploy information technology to achieve strategic business objectives and improve profitability. Dr. Nielsen specializes in computer systems design and architecture evaluation, information technology assessment and strategy, networked and distributed systems, data- and knowledge-based systems (e.g., data warehousing and data mining, intelligent scheduling), and information security and risk assessments. He has led numerous projects that assisted companies in using information technology to strategic advantage. Before joining AtomicTangerine and, previously, SRI International, Dr. Nielsen served as a faculty member at Stanford University. He is listed in Who’s Who in America and Who’s Who in Science and Engineering and is a member of Phi Beta Kappa and other national honor societies. In addition to serving as treasurer of AAAI, he is a member of AAAS, the ACM, the Computer Society of the IEEE, and INFORMS. He has written more than 75 articles and papers on information technology topics, as well as 2 books relating to the practical application of artificial intelligence technology. Dr. Nielsen holds a B.A. in mathematics (summa cum laude) from Pomona College, an MBA in management science and a Ph.D. in operations and systems analysis from Stanford University
Sanjay Deo, Technology Director, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Sanjay Deo has more than 10 years of experience in software development—custom as well as product—and has provided management consulting services to startups, spin-offs, and brick-and-mortar clients in the information services, telecommunications, entertainment, health care and high-tech industry sectors. His specific expertise lies in building B2B digital marketplaces and Internet security. He is also experienced in IT strategy, technology assessment, systems design and integration, and process innovation. Recent work includes a project involving the first MRO Latin American digital marketplace. Mr. Deo formulated business strategy, created internal business processes and procedures, integrated buyers and sellers, selected and implemented platform and infrastructure and a customer relationship management system, and provided overall internationalization, customization and integration of the digital marketplace engine. In another project for one of the largest U.S. retailers, Mr. Deo identified the software and hardware required to handle 60,000 orders per hour, scaling up to 240,000 orders per hour in the next 5 years Before joining AtomicTangerine, he was director of the Advanced Technology Group in Arthur Andersen’s Business Consulting practice. In previous work, Mr. Deo was with CyberGuard Corporation, where he focused on design and implementation of high-assurance operating systems, and architected three firewalls for three operating systems. He holds a B.E. in computer engineering from the University of Bombay and an M.S. in computer science from Texas A&M, College Station, Texas.
Donald Holden (CISSP), Business Leader, Information Security, AtomicTangerine
Don Holden has more than 20 years of experience in information systems, security, encryption, business continuity and disaster recovery planning. He has written numerous white papers and given presentations on information security management and technology issues such as intrusion detection, firewalls, biometric authentication and digital watermarking. Mr. Holden is currently the chairman of the IEEE Computer Society working group on recommended best practices for Internet security. He is also participating in the development of security standards for the financial industry. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Holden was a senior consultant for SRI Consulting, where he was a project leader for an Internet startup assignment to plan a revolutionary secure electronic commerce portal-based business. He previously served as program manager for Compaq’s Security Program Office and as the director of operations research at a major Boston bank. Mr. Holden holds an MBA from Wharton and a B.S. in business and accounting from Georgetown University. He is a Certified Information System Security Professional (CISSP) and a member of the IEEE Computer Society, the Computer Security Institute, and the Information Systems Security Association.
Stephen Whitlock, Technology Leader, AtomicTangerine
Stephen Whitlock specializes in cryptography, UNIX and network security. Stephen is an internationally recognized expert in the field of information security. His background includes the development of tools for testing system security as well as publications and presentations on cryptography, UNIX and network security. For many years, he functioned as an internal corporate consultant on cryptographic and security issues. Among other work, Stephen developed an encryption strategy for large, multi-platform enterprise environments, which was presented to the U.S. Office of Science and Technology Policy, the National Security Council and the FBI. The results directly affected the Clinton Administration’s U.S. Encryption Policy. Before joining AtomicTangerine, Stephen was an advanced computing technologist in the mathematics and computing technology division of Boeing’s Phantom Works. He has been an active participant in the security activities of the Electronic Messaging Association, Internet Engineering Task Force, Key Recovery Alliance, Object Management Group and the Open Group. He is currently the chair of the Open Group’s Security and Electronic Commerce Program Group and as such has been involved in the development of several standards, including the Architecture for a Public Key Infrastructure, Common Data Security Architecture and Advanced Authorization API. Stephen holds a B.S. in electronic engineering technology from the Weber State University and an M.S. in software engineering from Seattle University.
Glenn A. Reitmeier, Vice President, Sarnoff Corporation
Glenn Reitmeier is Vice President of Internet Technology Strategy and Development at Sarnoff Corporation. His career has pioneered the development of digital television, digital media and digital convergence. He has created and led world-leading developments in Digital Cinema, object coding and wavelet image compression in MPEG-4, MPEG-2 compressed bitstream processing and integrated circuits for digital television receivers. His efforts have contributed to the formation of six new startup companies and resulted in three technical Emmy awards. Mr. Reitmeier was one of the leading contributors to establishing the ATSC Digital Television standard that was approved by the FCC in 1996. In the Digital HDTV Grand Alliance, he performed in both technical and strategic capacities, and was the leader of Grand Alliance computer interoperability efforts. He has also led projects related to developing new technologies for consumer information services, including computer and network architectures, Digital Signal Processing modems and natural language software. Earlier, Mr. Reitmeier was a contributor to the establishment of the world’s first digital television standards (the ITU 601 sampling standard and the D1 tape standard) that are now in widespread use in the broadcast industry. He holds over 40 patents in digital television technology. He received the B.E.E. degree summa cum laude in 1977 and an M.S.E. degree in Systems Engineering from the University of Pennsylvania in 1979.
Shailendra K. Suman, Executive Director, Sarnoff Corporation
Shailendra K. Suman is Executive Director of Sarnoff Corporation and General Partner of nVention. He is responsible for the business and strategy development, market analysis and strategic alliances for nVention and its ventures. Prior to joining Sarnoff, Mr. Suman served in various management capacities for several energy-related companies, including responsibilities for strategy as well as new venture development. Mr. Suman received his BS in Mechanical Engineering from B.I.T. Sindri, India, an MS in Control Systems from University of Alabama, and an MBA in Finance and Strategy from University of Minnesota in 1986, 1989, and 1995 respectively. He completed all the coursework towards a Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering at Columbia University, NY in 1989. Mr. Suman is a member of the Conference Board’s International Council of Innovation & Technology Management and the Institute of Electronics and Electrical Engineers.
Nova Spivack, Founder, Lucid Ventures; Entrepreneur in Residence, nVention
Nova Spivack is Founder, President and CEO of Lucid Ventures Inc. and Co-Founder and CEO of Lucid Associates, LLC. Mr Spivack has been an Internet venture strategy advisor to Sarnoff Corporation for the past year and a prime mover in its decision to create nVention. Mr Spivack was a Co-Founder, Executive Vice President , and Director of EarthWeb Inc., an industry-leading Internet venture, since 1994. He co-led the company from startup through an historic IPO (the first business-to-business IPO and one of the all-time best first-day gainers) and a secondary public offering, serving as executive vice-president for product development and strategy. Mr. Spivack, a published author and frequent keynote speaker, is currently developing several new proprietary patents in the areas of GPS technology, Internet television, wireless consumer electronics, Internet radio, artificial intelligence and augmented reality, and is the principal inventor of multiple fundamental patents related to simulcasting Internet content with television broadcasts for use in entertainment, education, sports, news and information services. Mr Spivack is among the top-rated featured "Internet Business Experts" on Expert-central.com, part of the About.com network and has been interviewed by many prominent publications.
Rafael Alonso, Head, Computing Systems Research Group, Information Sciences Laboratory, Sarnoff Corporation
Rafael Alonso obtained a Ph.D. in Computer Science from U.C. Berkeley in 1986 where he held an IBM Fellowship. He was a faculty member at Princeton University from 1984 to 1992 where he graduated three doctoral students, obtained several government and industrial grants, and developed two new courses. In 1991 he co-founded the Matsushita Information Technology Laboratory to develop leading edge information and video systems for Panasonic. Dr. Alonso obtained two U.S. patents for his work, and his research team contributed software to a number of products, as well as developed a non-linear editing system prototype shown at the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) Conference. Dr. Alonso is presently Head of Computing Systems Research at Sarnoff Corporation where he oversees research projects in a number of areas including Web-based collaboration tools, online learning, video databases, and development of MPEG encoding algorithms. He is also currently coordinating two product development efforts. Dr. Alonso's current research interests include organizational memory, multimedia database systems, video servers, mobile information systems, and heterogeneous database systems. Dr. Alonso has published over 40 refereed papers, been a member of more than 20 Program Committees, and is currently on the editorial board of several technical journals.
James R. Bergen, Head, Information Technologies Initiatives, Sarnoff Corporation
James R. Bergen is an expert in the technologies of image processing, computer vision, visual psychophysics, and visual perception, with special competence in motion and visual texture (from perceptual and algorithmic standpoints), adaptive video signal processing, computer vision, and image analysis systems. A three-time recipient of the David Sarnoff Technical Achievement Award (1983, 1987, 1991), Dr. Bergen has authored or co-authored forty technical publications and book chapters. He holds a BA in Mathematics and Psychology (1975) from the University of California at Berkeley and a PhD in Biophysics and Theoretical Biology (1981) from the University of Chicago. Dr. Bergen was a postdoctoral member of the technical staff at Bell Laboratories in Murray Hill, NJ.
D15.1.2 Size of technical workforce
Combined, Sarnoff and Atomic Tangerine have a technical workforce that is in the several hundreds. Each will be assisting the proposed Registry with technical personnel and relevant experience. In addition, Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine will help shape the structure and staffing of the Registry.
D15.1.3 Access to systems development tools
Through Sarnoff and Atomic Tangerine, the proposed Registry will be able to access almost every popular systems development tool. However, for the purposes of its operations, very little systems development will be required. Nearly all software to be used will be packaged solutions with one exception, the SRS server, which will be developed using a published toolkit. The development environment will be Sun Workshop –Forte for development. It is a Sun package and will enable a finely tuned application to be developed. Merant’s PVCS will be used for version control. PVCS is a moderate package for version control adequate for the needs of development of the SRS server software.
D15.1.4 Significant past achievements
Among the awards won by Sarnoff are seven Emmys for technical excellence. In like vein, Sarnoff intends to enable the next generation of pioneering technologies and services based on the Internet’s Domain Name System that will affect important aspects of our lives. Highlights of Sarnoff’s pioneering technical achievements are given below (see also Appendix B, a Business Week article on Sarnoff and SRI International).
Sarnoff’s Pioneering Technologies |
||
1946 |
Color Television |
An all-electronic, compatible with black/white, color television system was developed at Sarnoff. It is the basis of the NTSC system adopted by the FCC in 1953 as the standard for color TV and is still in use today. |
1953 |
Video Tape Recording |
Sarnoff developed magnetic recording tape for black-and-white and color television for broadcast use. |
1955 |
Emmy Award |
Academy of Arts and Sciences 1955, Best Engineering Technical Achievement, Tricolor Picture Tube. |
1964 |
CMOS |
Developed the MOS (metal oxide semiconductor) transistor, the basis of C (complementary) MOS technology, one of the "bedrock" technologies for integrated circuits (ICs) worldwide. |
1966 |
Liquid-Phase Epitaxial Growth of GaAs Lasers |
LPE laser growth, invented at Sarnoff, made possible the production of reproducible GaAs material for low-cost lasers and LEDs. LPE is the worldwide standard today for laser production for CDs. |
1968 |
Liquid-Crystal Display Technology |
Liquid-crystal display (LCD) technology was developed by Sarnoff scientists, who formulated both basic theory and the first LCD displays. |
1974 |
CCD Image Sensor |
The Charge-Coupled Device (CCD) was developed for commercial use at Sarnoff as part of visible and infrared (IR) sensor technology; it became the basis of the CCD IR camera and the CCD broadcast camera. |
1976 |
All-Electronic TV Tuning |
This fundamental approach of frequency synthesis (all-electronic) TV tuning is now used in substantially all television sets worldwide. |
1976 |
Just Noticeable Difference |
Sarnoff developed computerized measurement techniques that accurately model the human visual system. |
1977 |
Silicon-on-Sapphire ICs |
Sarnoff pioneered the technique for depositing Si on sapphire (SOS) for ICs. |
1977 |
Amorphous Silicon Solar Cells |
A basic patent was issued to Sarnoff scientists who achieved a remarkable 10% efficiency in converting sunlight to electricity. |
1982 |
GaAs FET Microwave Amplifiers: SSPAs |
These GaAs microwave devices were the first solid-state power amplifiers (SSPAs) to be used in communications satellites in space. |
1982 |
Pyramid-Based Image Processing |
Pyramid-based image processing technology developed at Sarnoff has become the basis for computerized vision technology and real-time processing of live video. |
1984 |
CCD Broadcast Camera |
Television broadcast camera using a solid-state CCD to pick up images, was developed at Sarnoff. |
1984 |
Emmy Award |
The National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences awarded an Emmy to Vladimir K. Zworykin, a Sarnoff scientist, for more than a half century of pioneering conception and invention including the first practical tube for picture transmission. |
1986 |
Emmy Award |
Awarded for Outstanding Achievement in Engineering Development for work in developing and implementing Multi-Channel Stereo Sound for Broadcast Television. |
1986 |
Stereo Broadcast Television |
Sarnoff developed and implemented multi-channel stereo sound for broadcast television. |
1988 |
Sarnoff Engine Supercomputer |
The Sarnoff Engine is a massively parallel supercomputer developed to process video and imagery in real time. A Sarnoff spin-off company, Diva Systems, is an outgrowth of this technology. |
1989 |
Polysilicon AMLCD |
Sarnoff's work in polysilicon active-matrix, liquid-crystal displays (AMLCDs) led to the formation of SARIF, a spin-off company to manufacture advanced displays. |
1989 |
GEM: Generalized Emulation of Microcircuits |
With SRI, Sarnoff successfully pioneered the GEM technology using current Bi-CMOS techniques for form, fit, and function replacements of no-longer-available ICs in DoD electronic systems without having to redesign the entire systems. |
1990 |
Solid-State Spectrometer Sensor |
The world’s first combination of CMOS and spectroscopic CCD process technologies to produce a unique sensor for an innovative spectrometer design, which markedly increased system performance and throughput. |
1991 |
Advanced Digital HDTV |
As part of the competition to establish standards for HDTV, the next generation of television, Sarnoff developed a digital high-definition television (HDTV) system for FCC testing and approval. |
1991 |
Micro-mirror Projection Displays |
Produced the first projection display based on MEM’s technology; developed jointly with Texas Instruments. |
1992 |
DirecTV Satellite Broadcasting |
Together with Thomson Consumer Electronics, Sarnoff developed the Direct Satellite System (DSS) standard and built the prototype for DirecTV, a new way of sending video and data directly to homes from satellites. DSS is the fastest growing new consumer electronics product in history. |
1992 |
Ultra-Low- Power A/D Converter |
The application of Sarnoff’s unique ADC architecture and its exploitation of deep submicron CMOS technology resulted in a hundredfold decrease in power consumption, important for commercial applications. |
1992 |
Remote RF Tag |
Sarnoff invented a technique to transmit and receive information via a passive tag, the size of a credit card, by high-frequency radio waves at distances up to 20 feet. Potential applications include the remote collection of automobile tolls, inventory control, and personal access control. |
1993 |
High-Resolution Infrared Camera: 640 x 480 Pixels |
Sarnoff developed the highest resolution and most sensitive 640 x 480-pixel platinum /silicon (PtSi) imager, operating under computer control and capable of providing full video resolution and sub-frame imaging. |
1993 |
Phosphor Center of Excellence |
Established to promote phosphor research in the US, the Center has its headquarters at the Georgia Institute of Technology. Sarnoff, a key member, is a leader in the development of phosphor technology. |
1993 |
Sensar, Sarnoff’s First Start-Up |
Sensar, Sarnoff's first spin-off company, is working in the field of human iris tracking and recognition for automatic teller machines. |
1993 |
28-GHz TV System |
Sarnoff developed a wireless local multipoint distribution system (LMDS) for broadcasting numerous studio-quality video channels with stereo sound to multiple subscribers over a distance of nine miles. |
1993 |
TV Imager: 1000 x 1000 Pixels |
The world’s first high performance, low noise, back illuminated sensor operating at high frame rates. |
1993 |
Blue EL Phosphor |
The blue EL electroluminescent (EL) phosphor developed at Sarnoff is the last color element needed to make a full-color EL display. |
1993 |
Real Time Video Insertion |
The world’s first demonstration of real-time insertion of images into frames of a live video stream. |
1994 |
High Performance CRT: 2500 x 2000 Pixels |
The world’s first 5-Mega-Pixel monochrome display with 200 fL brightness for high performance medical and surveillance applications. |
1994 |
MicroLab Diagnostic |
Sarnoff’s unique micro-laboratory concept for a completely automated instrument of miniaturized devices based on MEMs technology that will analyze micro-volume samples of blood for a broad range of diseases. |
1994 |
0.3-mm ESD Protection |
Sarnoff's work in electrostatic discharge (ESD) protection is key to consumer appliances made with ICs, where ESD protection guards against voltage "spikes." |
1994 |
Ceramic-on-Metal MCM |
The world’s first low cost, low expansion, and high thermal conductivity metal-ceramic laminate material for direct mounting of high power Si and GaAs bare die for multichip modules (MCMs). |
1994 |
DFB Laser |
The world’s first visible distributed feedback diode laser. |
1994 |
Integrated Drive aSi LCD |
The world’s first integration of drive circuitry on an LCD display using amorphous-Si transistors. |
1994 |
Phosphor Tags |
A combination of Sarnoff phosphors are used to uniquely identify currency for security. Users can authenticate documents and parts quickly and reliably. |
1995 |
SEQ DNA Sequencing |
An approach for ultra high speed DNA sequencing using SEQ’s single model detection technology to sequence and store personal Genome information on a CD-ROM for diagnosis and Genomic therapy. |
1995 |
Grand Alliance HDTV |
In conjunction with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the Grand Alliance consortium was formed to develop and test the new HDTV system; Sarnoff’s contributions included two key elements -- a prioritized packetized data transport structure and a data compression scheme based on MPEG. The FCC adopted the Grand Alliance system for broadcasting HDTV as the US standard in December 1996. |
1995 |
Dry Drug Delivery |
Delsys, a Sarnoff spin-off company, is working with a pharmaceutical company to develop very accurate delivery of drugs through inhalers or transdermal patches. |
1995 |
MicroLab |
MicroLab's work in developing a microelectronic device for disease detection led to SmithKline Beecham and Sarnoff establishing Orchid Biocomputer, a joint venture. Orchid is developing a miniaturized laboratory that will be able to screen up to ten thousand chemicals simultaneously for drug discovery. |
1995 |
Active Matrix EL Display |
The world’s first Active Matrix Electroluminescent display on a Si chip demonstrating 800 fL peak brightness and over 2000 pixels per inch resolution. |
1996 |
LCD Projector: 1280 x 1024 Pixels |
Sarnoff spin-off company, SARIF, is pursuing the electronic projector market using Sarnoff’s high-resolution, active-matrix LCD technology. |
1996 |
Iris Recognition System |
Sensar is developing a personal identification system that uses the unique patterns of the iris in the human eye based on Sarnoff’s pyramid-processing technology for Automatic Teller Machines. |
1997 |
High Power 1.5µm Laser |
The world’s highest average output power 1.5µm diode laser. |
1997 |
VideoMosaic |
Sarnoff developed a commercial product to produce panoramic video mosaic images from live video based on our real-time video processing technology. This technology led to the formation of Video Brush, a Sarnoff technology Venture company. Video Brush and its technology were acquired by PictureWorks Technology, which in turn was acquired by IPIX. |
1999 |
Emmy Award |
Awarded for Sarnoff's Compliance Bitstreams, a comprehensive and easy-to-use set of analysis tools that allows receiver manufacturers, broadcasters, and makers of computer video boards to determine whether receivers will reliably decode complex digital and high definition television (DTV/HDTV) signals. |
D15.2 Technical plan for the proposed registry operations
The proposed Registry Operator aims to establish a robust and reliable registry with domain nameservers that are available at all times to resolve domain names under the TLD. In order to ensure smooth registry operation, the most robust and reliable technical infrastructure will be implemented. Only products and services from industry leaders like Cisco, EMC, Exodus, Oracle and Sun will be used to ensure interoperability, maximum availability and overall system dependability and resilience.
In order to ensure the Registry is functional at all times, a superior network architecture has been designed and resources will be heavily invested in technical infrastructure. The infrastructure design ensures there is no single point of failure by building in redundancy. The Registry will have the reliable, redundant and high-performance infrastructure demanded by such a critical application. Please see Figure 1: Diagram of Technical Infrastructure.
The front-end of the infrastructure will be available for serving DNS and Whois requests. Registrars will maintain registry records using the back-end portion of the infrastructure. They will have the ability to add, delete and modify domain name records in the Oracle database, which is hosted in the back-end and is the authoritative source of DNS records. This database populates the DNS and Whois servers as well as internal systems used for billing and reporting.
Each layer of the infrastructure will have redundancy. This redundancy will ensure that there is no single point of failure within the infrastructure. Load balancing is utilized to provide for a high level of quality of service to the user base. Load balancing ensures response in the event of device failure. DNS servers are load balanced by software design.
In the beginning there will be two identical set-ups of equipment, one in New York, NY and the other in Santa Clara, California. The back-ends of the two facilities will be networked to the proposed Registry’s corporate headquarters using Cisco 2610 routers and multiple T1 digital circuits (see Figure 2). The front end at both facilities will be active to provide DNS service. The backend at the New York location will remain active, but the backend at Santa Clara will remain dormant. However, the EMC Symmetrix storage in Santa Clara will be kept in sync with the EMC Symmetrix storage in New York over two T1 links using the Symmetrix Remote Data Facility (SRDF). In the highly unlikely event of catastrophic failure of the entire New York hosting facility, the Santa Clara backend will be activated to provide service.
Every hardware component will be from a world-class vendor. These vendors provide best of breed support and service. All vendors are global in scope to ensure that future global growth will be enabled. This will provide for a highly scalable growth path with minimal emphasis on re-creating the infrastructure at each location or region of the world. Teaming with industry leaders will also provide a continued growth path and help avoid the technological dead-ends that all too often are the fate of non-top-tier vendors. Leading vendors also provide a variety of equipment so that the most appropriate equipment is used for each function while minimizing the technical diversity. This will help simplify maintenance, training, and support.
D15.2.1 General description of proposed facilities and system
D15.2.1.1.1 Buildings
The technical facilities associated with the Registry will be collocated at Exodus Data Centers in New York, NY and Santa Clara, CA. As and when required, additional nameservers will be collocated at Exodus Data Centers in Tokyo, Japan and London, UK.
At each of the data centers, Exodus will provide a virtual data center (VDC), which is a secured private area within the Exodus Communications Data Center for hosting the Registry infrastructure. The VDC is designed with steel mesh walls and a key lock sliding access door. Below are the specifications for the VDC, as per the sub-proposal from Exodus Communications (see Appendix F).
Product Description |
Equipment |
Power |
Usable Dimensions |
Virtual Data Center |
Secure Area |
4 dedicated 20 Amp Circuits |
7’ W x 8’ D |
EXO-VDC |
4 Racks |
D15.2.1.1.2 Hardware
The hardware used will be a combination of servers, networking equipment and storage equipment from prestigious companies like Sun, Cisco and EMC. These companies are recognized as leaders in their respective industries and their products are unsurpassed in terms of features, quality, scalability and reliability.
Network Equipment
Two Cisco 7206VXR with NPE-300 and I/O Controller with fast Ethernet will serve as the border routers at each site. The routers will run the IP feature set of the Cisco Internetworking Operating System (IOS). Each router is connected to a different Internet service provider and BGP is used to load-balance the out-bound traffic.
Two Cisco 3524 switches will bring the traffic from the border routers to the Cisco Pix 520 firewalls. The switches provide for redundancy in the event of failure of one of the switches. They also protect against firewall failure. The back-end network also employs two Cisco 3524 switches.
The core network switch is the Cisco Catalyst 6509. This switch has 48 10/100 ports, which will be sufficient for future expansion within a hosting facility. Each data center will have two Catalyst 6509 switches for redundancy.
Cisco LocalDirector load balancers will provide for load balancing requests across available equipment. They automatically route data only to responsive equipment. The end results are rapid response due to load distribution as well as guaranteed results from re-routing traffic from failed equipment to operational equipment. There are two sets of two Local Directors, one in the front-end and the other in the back-end. The set in the front-end is used to load-balance incoming traffic to the Whois servers. It is also used to route incoming traffic to the backup "phantom" primary nameserver in case the first one fails. The set in the back-end is used to load-balance the SRS servers. Each set contains two Local Directors for redundancy.
Firewalls
Cisco Pix 520 firewalls will provide for full featured firewall protection. These firewalls will disable all but necessary traffic from the Internet. For security purposes one firewall will remain active while the other is in a live waitful state in the event of failure of the first device.
Servers
All servers are from Sun Microsystems. The servers include primary nameservers, secondary nameservers, Whois servers, Oracle database servers, SRS servers and a zone file generation server. Each type of server will be the appropriate model for its specific purpose. The Oracle databases will run on Sun Enterprise 6500 with 4 processors and 4 gigabytes of random access memory (RAM). All other servers, including, the nameservers, are Sun Enterprise 450 with 1 processor and 1 gigabyte of RAM.
There are a total of three database servers. The first is used for read/write operations to make changes to the database and can handle as many as 150 writes per second. The second is optimized for read-only operations and can handle as many as 500 transactions per second. The third database is a fully configured database that will serve as a hot spare for either of the other two.
Data Storage
The Oracle servers will use an EMC Symmetrix 8430-18 for data storage. This is the optimum solution for reliable data storage. It also allows two Oracle servers to share the same logical drive. EMC has been the dominant player in high performance storage media for several years.
D15.2.1.1.3 Software systems
Operating system: All devices will run the manufacturer’s operating system. The latest well-tested production version of each operating system will be used. These will provide for the greatest functionality and security. All Sun servers will run Solaris 2.x. Cisco hardware will run the Internetworking Operating System (IOS).
Domain Nameservers: A combination BIND 8.0 and BIND 9.0 will run on the nameservers to serve DNS queries. BIND is the industry standard for nameserver software and is distributed under the GNU public license (GPL).
Database: Oracle 8i (Enterprise edition) with Oracle Parallel Server (OPS) will be the database software running on the database servers. 8i is Oracle’s latest version that expands upon Oracle’s long-standing technology leadership in the areas of data management, transaction processing, and data warehousing. The OPS enables multiple Oracle instances running on separate servers to share the same database, thereby enhancing the database throughput. Oracle Reports will be used to generate reports.
Security: Cisco Pix will run the standard Cisco Pix software and operating system. This offering from Cisco provides for stateful service of session inspection, user authentication and authorization as well as automatic stateful fail-over should a path in the network fail. High availability in conjunction with the fastest performance of any firewall on the market makes this the right choice. All Sun servers will run tripwire, a file system integrity-checking program for UNIX operating systems.
Backup: As part of its DataVault Service, Exodus Communications will be using the Veritas NetBackup solution for backup and restore.
Zone File Generation: SQL*Plus will be used to generate the zone files from domain name records stored in the Oracle database. Encrypted SQL*Net will be used for secure data transport between the Oracle server and the zone file generation server.
SRS Software: Based on the Registry-Registrar Protocol (RRP), the SRS system allows accredited registrars to add, delete and modify domain name records in the Oracle database. It has two components: the SRS server software at the Registry and the SRS client software at the registrar. SSL encryption is used to protect the data in transit between the SRS server software and the SRS client software.
ACE Server: This is the server software from industry leading RSA. The RSA ACE SecurID Server will be used for authentication and access control for maintenance as well as registrars.
Whois Server: This server will run Whois software that has been tested and used by other registries and registrars. It will serve domain name Whois information from a text file. Once the number of domain names registered under the proposed TLD approaches 1 million, the server will use the Veritas File System to store the text files.
D15.2.1.1.4 Environmental equipment
Each Exodus facility is built on raised floors and has high-volume, zoned temperature control systems. Exodus has multiple air conditioning units to ensure proper heat dissipation. In the event one system fails, the other units are able to assume the full load of cooling the collocated equipment.
D15.2.1.1.5 Internet connectivity
At each data center, Exodus will provide a 100 mbps connection to the Internet as part of its bandwidth services. This connectivity utilizes Exodus’s extensive network and peering arrangements. More information on the network is available in the Exodus proposal (see Appendix F).
In addition to this connectivity, each data center will have additional connectivity through the AT&T IP global network. This service is delivered through AT&T and the bandwidth is 100 mbps.
15.2.1.1.6 Power
Exodus will be providing four 20 Amp circuits at each virtual data center. These circuits provide in-line UPS and diesel generator backup in the event of grid power failure.
15.2.1.1.7 Networking
The primary networking scheme will be 100 mbps switched Ethernet. There will be one network in the front-end that is selectively accessible via the Internet. This network contains the nameservers and the Whois servers. The back-end has a separate physical network and contains the Oracle servers and the SRS servers.
A separate physical network connects all servers that need to be backed up to a Sun 11000 storage array through a Cisco switch. The backup service is provided by Exodus Communications. This overlay network is used solely for backup and is not accessible via the Internet.
A third network consists of asynchronous serial links from each device at the facility to two Cisco 2610 terminal servers. This allows for highly secure and reliable device monitoring and management as well as for backing up configurations of servers and network equipment.
D15.2.2 Registry-registrar model and protocol
The present registry-registrar model and protocol used by Verisign Global Registry Services (formerly Network Solutions) is time-tested and known to work. It has also been widely implemented by registrars. Rather than develop a new system, the proposed Registry intends to adopt Verisign’s model and protocol. Not only is this a stable system, its adoption will accelerate the process of bringing registrars online with the new Registry.
The proposed Registry will use the Registry Registrar Protocol (RRP), which allows registrars to register, modify and delete domain names from the Registry’s central database. Shared Registry System (SRS) software based on the RRP will be developed using the software development kit made available by Verisign and the RRP specifications in RFC2832. The existing client-side SRS software at the registrar-end can be easily modified to interoperate with the server-side SRS software. Development assistance, training, and support will be provided to interested ICANN-Accredited Registrars to make the modification and come on-line with the proposed Registry.
Under the registry-registrar model, a registrant is required to go through an accredited registrar in order to register a new domain name or modify an existing one. The Registry will not accept registrations directly from the registrant. Similarly, the registrar is responsible for all interactions with the registrant, which includes customer support as well as billing and collection. The registrar is also responsible for enforcing the Registry policies on the registrants.
D15.2.3 Database capabilities
D15.2.3.1 Database size
Business projections are for 140 million domain names (best case scenario) in the proposed TLD by the end of the fourth year, which translates into a projected database size of 70 gigabytes assuming a high estimate of 0.5 kilobytes per record.
D15.2.3.2 Throughput
The Oracle server optimized for read-only transactions can handle up to 500 reads per second. The other Oracle server that will perform both read and write operations can handle up to 150 transactions per second. These figures are based on tests conducted jointly by Sun and Oracle.
D15.2.3.3 Scalability
Oracle is one of the most scalable databases in the market today. The scalability of the database is dependent upon a number of factors, such as the server architecture, size of RAM, CPU power, number of CPUs, and disk access speeds. The Sun servers used for the database support multiple processors. Additionally, the services of read-only and read/write will operate on separate servers, thereby allowing scalability and growth paths based on the type of traffic. The machines at Day One support hundreds of simultaneous connections with scalability to thousands while maintaining industry-leading performance figures. The Sun Enterprise 6500 can address over 30 terabytes of storage. It can handle 6500 concurrent users and still deliver over 3000 transactions per minute, where a transaction is a database read, a CPU process and a database write. Initial configuration of the databases will be 4 CPUs with 4 gigabytes of memory. The Sun Enterprise 6500 is scalable to 32 CPUs with 60 gigabytes of memory. Sun also has other servers of considerably more capacity. Though not top-of-the-line, the Sun Enterprise 10000 can perform 102,000 i/o’s per second.
The maximum projected database size at the end of the fourth year is 70 gigabytes, which can easily be handled by Oracle. It would be safe to assume that the database can scale far beyond the purposes of the proposed Registry.
D15.2.3.4 Procedures for object creation, editing, and deletion
Before explaining the procedures, it is necessary to provide some definitions.
Registrar Whois server (RAWS): This is the Whois server maintained by the registrar. It contains all contact information about the domain holder as per ICANN requirements.
Registry Whois server (RYWS): This is the Whois server maintained by the Registry. It is publicly accessible via the Internet. When queried with a domain name, it returns the nameservers serving the domain name, and the URL and the Whois server of the registrar through which the domain was registered.
SRS Client Server (SCS): This server runs the SRS client software at the registrar-end and talks directly to the Registry SRS server. It serves as the gateway though which the public communicates with the Registry.
SRS Server (Registry SRS) Server (SSS): This server runs the SRS server software at the Registry and interfaces with the registrar SRS client server (SCS) and the Oracle database server containing the domain name records.
Database Server (DBS): This is the master database server at the Registry that contains a record for each domain name resolved by the Registry. It communicates directly with the SRS Server (SSS) to handle the creation of a new domain name or changes to existing ones.
Create Domain: The registrant, through a web interface at the registrar’s web site, enters the domain name to be registered, causing the SCS to send a SRS CREATE DOMAIN message to the SSS. The SSS runs through an algorithm that checks for syntax errors and performs other checks. It then queries the DBS to check availability of the domain name. If there is an error or the domain name is unavailable, the SSS informs the SCS, which in turn informs the registrant. If there are no problems, the SSS writes the domain record to the DBS and the registrant is informed via the SCS.
Edit Domain: The only changes to a domain name record occur when one or more associated nameservers need to be added, changed or removed, or when the domain needs to be renewed (registrar transfer is discussed in Section D15.2.3.6). For each of these changes, the SCS sends the SSS the appropriate SRS command. Upon receiving the command, the SSS makes the appropriate change to the domain name record in the DBS and writes a record to a history table on the same database. This history table can be used to generate a report of all past modifications to a domain name.
Delete Domain: In order to delete a domain name, the SCS sends a command to the SSS, which deletes the pointer to the registrar field of the domain name record in the database so that any Whois lookup shows the domain exists, but is in an inoperative "hold" condition. The domain name is not included in subsequent zone files either. It will be maintained this way for a random period of time exceeding 3 months, after which the record associated with the domain name is completely removed from the database and a record is written to the history table. The domain is free to be registered again, by anybody.
Only the registrar associated with the domain name will be allowed to edit or delete the domain.
D15.2.3.5 Change notifications
All changes to a domain name record in the database will be recorded in a history table, which can be used to generate a report of all past modifications to the domain name. Such a report would be necessary to resolve a domain name dispute, especially over unauthorized or incorrect modifications.
Whois information with the contact details of the domain name holder is stored on the registrar’s Whois server, not the Registry’s. The Registry does not store the registrant’s e-mail address, and therefore, cannot e-mail the registrant if any modifications are made to his/her domain name. The registrars will be required to send change notifications to the registrants. The Registry will e-mail change notifications to the registrars as well as to a standard e-mail address associated with the domain name, e.g. registration@domain-name.TLD. Registrants willing to receive these change notifications will be instructed to allow receipt of these e-mails by making arrangements with their e-mail service provider.
D15.2.3.6 Registrar transfer procedures
These procedures are similar to what the Verisign Global Registry Services follows. The registrant initiates a registrar transfer at the new registrar. The new registrar’s SCS sends the transfer command to the SSS. The SSS notifies the old registrar and waits for positive acknowledgement. If a positive acknowledgement is received or none is received within 48 hours, the SSS completes the transfer by instructing the DBS to modify the appropriate field of the domain name record in the database. If the old registrar provides a negative acknowledgement ("no, don't transfer it") the domain will not be transferred. The registrant can override the negative acknowledgment by sending a notarized letter directly to the Registry requesting the transfer.
D15.2.3.7 Grace period implementation
All domain names in the registry database have a fiscal-time-to-live field provided by the SRS Client Server (SCS) during the domain name creation. This is based on the number of years the registrant requests the registration and pays for it. If the domain name is not renewed prior to the end of this fiscal-time-to-live period, a 6-week grace period will be granted, during which the domain name is operative and can be renewed. Past the grace period, the domain name will be deleted and placed in an inoperative "hold" condition for a random period of time exceeding 3 months, as per the Registry’s policies regarding deletion of domain names.
Technically, the grace period will be implemented using a server-side script that runs once a day on the Oracle server and checks for expired domain names. If expired, it checks if the domain name is within the 6-week grace period. If it isn’t, the domain name is deleted from the database, as described in Section D15.2.3.4.
D15.2.3.8 Reporting capabilities
Oracle Reports will be used to create customized technical, financial and operational reports based on information stored in the Oracle database. For financial reporting and invoicing, data will also be imported into the billing and collection system described in Section D15.2.6.
Technical reports will cover database activity and performance. Operational reports will cover metrics such as the number of new domain names registered via a user-defined registrar within a user-defined period. These reports will enable close monitoring of the Registry operations and keep a close watch on the database performance. They will detect unusual activity that could be caused by a malfunction or system hack. For example, if the number of new registrations suddenly increases, it could be indicative of a compromised SRS client at a registrar.
D15.2.4 Zone file generation
D15.2.4.1 Procedures for changes, editing by registrars, updates
All updates and changes by registrars will be made to the associated records in the Oracle database. These changes will be reflected in the newly generated zone files. The zone files are not changed or edited by registrars.
D15.2.4.2 Frequency
Twice a day, at 3 pm and 3 am, the zones files will be generated. These times are fixed, but may be rescheduled to avoid peak hours once the Registry is operational and peak hours are determined.
D15.2.4.3 Security
All technical and physical security measures described in Section D15.2.9 will also protect the zone file generation. The zone file generation server is protected by multiple layers of security and has all unnecessary ports and services blocked. It has an IP address in the 192.168.0.0 network, which is not routable on the Internet.
D15.2.4.4 Process
SQL*Plus scripts will be used to generate the zone files from domain name records stored in the Oracle database. Encrypted SQL*Net will be used for secure data transport between the Oracle server and the zone file generation server. The script will read domain name records in the Oracle database and generate properly formatted zone files containing the domain names and their associated nameservers. It will exclude expired domain names and those in the process of being deleted. The new zone files will be compared to the old ones and differences will be noted. Each difference must have a corresponding entry in the history table (which has a record of each change made to the domain name records in the database). Conversely, all new records in the history table must be accounted for in the new zone files. This process audits all changes and ensures that the zone files were generated properly and completely without any tampering.
D15.2.4.5 Interface
Since users will not edit the zone files directly, no interface is required.
D15.2.4.5 User authentication
User authentication will not be required, as registrars will not make changes to the zone files.
D15.2.4.6 Logging
All activity associated with zone file generation will be logged locally and to a remote logging server at the corporate offices. These logs will be inspected after the zone files are generated to ensure that the process was error-free.
D15.2.4.7 Data back-up.
Data backup procedures described in Section D15.2.7 will be used to backup the zone files, which will be stored on tape and overwritten after 2 weeks.
D15.2.5 Zone file distribution and publication
D15.2.5.1 Locations of nameservers
The proposed Registry will start operations in two Exodus data centers, one in New York, NY and the other in Santa Clara, CA. The two facilities will split the 13 nameservers. Over time, Exodus data centers in other locations, starting with London and Tokyo, will be used to migrate secondary nameservers to other continents. The possibility of co-locating nameservers with reputable regional ISPs will also be explored.
D15.2.5.2 Procedures for and means of distributing zone files
At each location, there are two primary nameservers, one active and the other a hot spare. A Cisco LocalDirector monitors the active server and directs traffic to the hot spare if the active server stops functioning. These "phantom" primary nameservers are not published as one of the 13 nameservers for the TLD, and are therefore not used for resolving DNS requests. Their purpose is to make the zone files available to the secondary nameservers.
The zone file generation server will run SQL*Plus scripts that generate zone files from the database at predetermined times twice daily. Next, it will open a secure FTP session to each of the primary nameservers using SSH. This connection will be monitored by the Cisco Pix firewall, which will allow only SSH connections to the primary nameservers from the zone file generation server.
Once the zone files are completely downloaded to the active "phantom" primary, the old zone files on the server are archived and replaced with the new ones. The name daemon on the server is restarted and the 13 secondaries (which are published on the Internet as the sole 13 nameservers for the TLD) automatically fetch the new zone files and restart the name daemon.
D15.2.6 Billing and collection systems
The billing and collection system for the Registry is very simple, as it deals with a limited number of registrars that is unlikely to exceed 200. An integrated management system will be utilized for accounts receivable, invoicing, human resources, registrar support and customer relationship management. The chosen system is the GreatPlains/Siebel system. The system will access registration information on the Oracle database directly through the read-only instance. Invoices will be generated automatically and e-mailed to registrars at the end of each month. The invoice amount will be entered into the accounts receivable and the account managers will follow-up with the registrars for collection.
D15.2.6.1 Technical characteristics
GreatPlains/Siebel will have its own separate database and data. This system will be housed not at the Exodus collocation facility, but at the corporate office. It has a web-enabled interface and an API for integrating other applications that may be utilized at a later date. This allows the users of the system to have a single view into the information of the Registry, and minimizes training.
D15.2.6.2 System security and Accessibility
GreatPlains/Siebel has token authentication and encrypted tunneling creating an authenticated and encrypted VPN within the organization. This is in addition to username/password authentication. The system will not be accessible over the public Internet, but only at the private intranet at the corporate office. It will be further secured by using a Cisco Pix 520 firewall. All internal machines with access to this system will have machine passwords to prohibit unauthorized access.
D15.2.7 Data escrow and backup
Data backup and escrow are indispensable components of technical operations. The data backup and restore service will be provided by Exodus Communications as part of its DataVault service. Data escrow service will be provided by Iron Mountain in conjunction with the DataVault service from Exodus.
D15.2.7.1 Frequency and procedures for backup of data
Once a week, data will be completely backed up to tape. Six times a week, the data will be incrementally backed up. After each 2-week period, tapes will be overwritten.
The file system supporting the Oracle database will be configured using a RAID 0+1 architecture. EMC’s Timefinder utility will utilize this architecture to generate a spare live data volume, known as a Business Continuance Volume (BCV), which will act as the source for data backup. This alleviates the production data volume from these responsibilities. The entire process is handled by Veritas NetBackup for EMC, which backs up the Oracle database over a separate LAN connection to the central backup server at Exodus. NetBackup for EMC solves the problem of affecting system availability and performance during backup for Oracle sites using EMC Symmetrix disk arrays. It utilizes EMC's TimeFinder capabilities for managing Symmetrix devices resulting in nearly zero-impact backups.
The software and configuration on all Sun servers will be backed up using Veritas NetBackup. This will provide a backup of configured software for use in disaster recovery. The configuration of all networking equipment will be backed up over the asynchronous serial link.
As part of the Change Management process, every modification to any device in the form of a change to configuration files, software, or network equipment settings will be backed up to ensure that the most recent settings are available during disaster recovery. These backups will be used to update any warm spares on premises. Copies of the backup will be stored locally and off-site.
D15.2.7.2 Hardware and systems used
Exodus uses Veritas NetBackup and DLT tape storage technology. Backup storage is provided on a Sun 11000 storage array connected to the servers to be backed up by a dedicated overlay storage network. Exodus will provide a Cisco Catalyst switch connected to the backup network. The EMC Symmetrix storage will be connected directly to this switch through a 100 mbps Ethernet port and a patch cable.
D15.2.7.3 Data format
The data formats for the Oracle database will be native database files. The software products in use will be stored in both source code, where available, as well as run modules. ASCII text will be the data format for configuration files and settings of network equipment.
D15.2.7.4 Identity of escrow agents
Exodus will provide offsite tape storage in coordination with Arcus Data Security, an Iron Mountain Company.
Arcus Data Security is regarded as the leader in offsite data vaulting. For over 30 years, they have provided secure, offsite vaulting for disaster recovery and archival data. More than 25,000 companies in over 50 locations have relied on Arcus to ensure they have the information they need to recover from a computing disaster.
D15.2.7.5 Procedures for retrieval of data/rebuild of database
As per Exodus’s DataVault service, the database in backup can be restored within 15 minutes. The retrieval process is automated using Veritas NetBackup software. In the event a hardware or media error causes database corruption, a third fully configured database stands in readiness to accept the responsibilities while the hardware or media is attended to.
D15.2.8 Publicly accessible look up/Whois service
There are two Whois subsystems of relevance: the Registry Whois and the registrar Whois. Since the proposed Registry will adhere to the Verisign "thin registry" model, the Registry Whois is comparatively simple and the only information made public is the domain name, registrar, URL of Whois server, URL of registrar website, published nameservers and last zone file update date.
D15.2.8.1 Software and hardware
The Whois servers are Sun Enterprise 450s with 450 MHz processor and 1 gigabyte of RAM. They run Whois software that has been tested and used by other registries and registrars. It will serve domain name Whois information from a text file. Once the number of domain names registered under the proposed TLD increases, traditional UNIX file systems are incapable of maintaining fast performance in storing and serving the Whois text files. Therefore, Veritas File System will be used once the number of domains approaches 1 million. Veritas File System provides scalable performance and capacity that would meet the projected increase in registrations.
Each data center has two Whois servers for redundancy. They are load balanced by a Cisco LocalDirector. The Whois servers in Santa Clara are in a non-functional, dormant state, available to come online instantly if the entire New York data center fails.
D15.2.8.2 Connection speed
As mentioned earlier, each data center has two 100 mbps connections to the Internet. The Whois servers will enjoy this connection speed.
D15.2.8.3 Search capabilities
Wildcard Whois searches will not be allowed. The registrar Whois will display the contact information for the domain registrant subject to the limitations outlines in the Whois policies (see sections E5.6 and E7). Given the non-commercial charter of the domain and taking into consideration privacy concerns, no wildcard searching of registrar databases will be allowed.
D15.2.8.4 Coordination with other Whois systems
It is fairly standard now for Whois client software to conform to the de facto Verisign registry/registrar model and display both Registry and registrar output. By using this same model the Registry Whois service will be compatible with existing contemporary Whois client software.
D15.2.9 System security
Extensive technical and physical security provisions will be implemented to protect the system from system hacks, break-ins, data tampering, and other disruptions to operations.
Physical Security
The security and integrity of each Exodus Communications Data Center is maintained by video surveillance cameras, security breach alarms and 24-hour personnel. There are several cameras mounted inside and outside each facility (including within each Data Center). The video surveillance is monitored at the security guard station, at the Network Control Center and is also recorded on tape.
Exodus Communications Data Centers are equipped with "90-minute riot glass" at all locations. This glass is resistant to small-arms fire, as well as repeated blows with a sledgehammer. Exodus Data Centers utilize a key-card access system with mandatory pre-approved client lists and mandatory sign in/sign out procedures. Customers are issued key-cards upon each visit, after presenting photo identification. Customer names must be listed on a pre-approved client access list, which is submitted by each client prior to installation.
Inside the Data Center, each area is protected by key-card lock. Customers must pass through two sets of key-card access doors and possess a key to access individual customer space. The first door enables access to a holding area where personnel can be screened by Data Center Operations staff. In the event of a breach, NCC/Security personnel can disable the key-card entry system, denying access into the Data Center. NCC/Security staff monitors visitors at all times while in the Data Center. Exodus also uses motion-detection equipment to monitor areas after hours.
Technical Security
Security measures have been designed into the technical infrastructure for every device at every step. The security is designed to control access to appropriate systems. It is also designed to provide for authentication. In general, there is a front-end firewall allowing appropriate access for DNS and Whois lookups. It also allows appropriate traffic necessary for registrars’ operations. A second firewall separates the front end from the back end. This second firewall secures the traffic between the front and back end allowing only permitted connections to be established. Following is an analysis:
D15.2.10. Peak capacities
D15.2.10.1 Technical capability for handling a larger-than-projected demand for registration or load
From day one, the Registry database servers will be capable of handling up to 75 new registrations per second when operating at 50 percent capacity. This is based on the performance capabilities of the Oracle parallel server running on Sun Enterprise 6500 with 4 processors and using EMC Symmetrix for storage. By distributing the workload to 2 different database servers, the capability to handle new registrations is further enhanced. Since the Oracle database is the rate-limiting component of the setup, we can directly equate its performance (in terms of transactions per second) to the performance of the entire setup (in terms of new registrations per second). Even if the system operates at 10% capacity, the Registry is capable of registering 15 new domain names a second. This translates into 1.3 million new domain names a day, far exceeding even the most optimistic projections.
The read-only Oracle database is capable of handling up to 500 reads per second. This database will be used when a potential registrant checks for availability of a domain name using the registrar’s interface. Operating at 50 percent capacity, the system is capable of handling 21.6 million such requests a day.
D15.2.10.2 Effects of load on servers, databases, back-up systems, support systems, escrow systems, maintenance, personnel.
Given the tiered architecture of the system, it is possible to allocate additional resources focused on specific areas of growth.
DNS & Whois Servers: In case a surge in the load for DNS lookups slows down the nameservers, a quick RAM upgrade should be sufficient. The architecture allows for the addition of more servers that could operate in a load-balanced environment. In this way, a DNS request to a specific IP address associated with a published secondary nameserver may be load-balanced across a large number of actual servers.
SRS Servers: The performance of the SRS servers is limited by the Oracle database. An unexpected increase in load should have no effect on these servers. Any possible performance degradation can be quickly remedied by a RAM upgrade.
Database: Most of the load on the database will be to determine the availability of a domain name under the TLD. A separate database server is dedicated for these read-only transactions. The number of requests to write to the database, in the form of a new registration, modification to an existing registration, or deletion of a registration, should be far lower than the capability stated in the previous section. If it isn’t, the capabilities of the database can be easily upgraded by adding more CPUs and RAM.
Back-up and escrow system: In the Oracle database, the size of a new record associated with a new registration is very small (less than 0.5 kilobytes). A surge in registrations will not significantly increase the size of the database to be backed-up and escrowed.
Support systems: A surge in registration load does not imply a surge in the number of registrars. Since the Registry will be supporting only registrars, there should not be any significant effect of increased registrations on the support systems at the Registry.
Maintenance: A more-than-projected demand for registration should not significantly increase maintenance requirements. Exodus, as part of its Technical Maintenance Staff service, will perform all regular maintenance and system administration functions. They will handle any increase in maintenance requirements.
Personnel: A greater-than-projected demand for registration will not overly expand the personnel needs necessary for ongoing support, maintenance or monitoring. The infrastructure established at day one will support significant expansion.
D15.2.11 System reliability
Define, analyze, and quantify quality of service.
The primary functions of the Registry infrastructure are:
The first function depends on the performance of the 13 nameservers serving the TLD as well as the quality of their Internet connectivity. BIND automatically balances the load to the nameservers so that requests are evenly distributed to all 13 nameservers. Performance tests indicate that DNS servers should resolve a domain name lookup within 2ms. This does not include latency on the public Internet between the client and the nameserver. In order to minimize this latency, the proposed Registry will start with facilities in New York and Santa Clara, and expand to Tokyo and London in the near future.
The second and third functions take place exclusively between the registrars and the Registry using RRP. The performance of these functions is not as time-sensitive and depends almost exclusively on the performance of the Oracle databases. This has been discussed and quantified in section D15.2.10
In terms of availability, the Registry will easily achieve 99.99999% availability of at least one nameserver to resolve DNS requests. In the highly unlikely event that one Exodus facility goes down, nameservers at the other facility will continue to serve requests. The availability of at least one SRS server and one Oracle database is limited by the availability of the EMC Symmetrix storage, which is reported as 99.953%. This will also be the availability of the SRS system.
D15.2.12 System outage prevention
Both technical and facility security add to the level of protection against system outage. Security has been discussed at 15.2.9. The security measures are world-class and state-of-the-art with provisions to maintain them at that level.
D15.2.12.1 Procedures for problem detection
Under its Managed Monitoring service, Exodus continuously monitors the CPU utilization, file systems, swap space and memory utilization of servers running Solaris. Alarms can be defined to go off at critical levels of these stats and Exodus will follow a step-wise procedure to respond to the alarm. The service can also monitor crucial processes on the servers. For example, this service can be used to monitor the availability of the named process on all nameservers. As part of its SLA, Exodus will report all critical alarms within 15 minutes by telephone or pager.
At the protocol level, the availability of networked devices is monitored by pinging the devices every minute. If a device does not respond to a ping, it has a critical problem that needs urgent attention. Security breaches will be detected by the Intrusion Detection Service and Managed Firewall Service described in D15.2.9.
Availability and performance of services will be monitored by regularly generating a request to the relevant server and analyzing the response. For example, every minute a DNS request will be sent to each of the 13 nameservers. If the expected response is not received or no response is received at all from a nameserver, it is certain that the particular nameserver is malfunctioning and will be attended to immediately as per predetermined procedures. Similarly, the Whois service will also be monitored.
This is in addition to internal monitoring of security, system load, and equipment failure. Within the corporate offices of the Registry will be real-time monitoring capabilities of system load and security alarms. In the event of loads exceeding pre-defined levels or of equipment failure or of security alarms, immediate notification to relevant internal personnel as well as the 24 x 7 customer service personnel will ensue.
D15.2.12.2 Redundancy of all systems
Firstly, the Registry will have nameservers at Exodus data centers in New York and Santa Clara. If an entire facility goes down for any reason, the other facility will continue to provide full service so that uninterrupted service of DNS and Whois requests will be maintained. In addition, if the New York facility goes down, the duplicate set of fully redundant back-end equipment that is waiting in a dormant state at the second location can be activated remotely within 15 minutes. In this way, if the New York facility fails, SRS can be restored within 15 minutes.
The configuration and software of equipment at the Santa Clara facility will be kept in sync with those at the New York facility using the change management process, which will keep track of all changes to any equipment or software at the New York facility. Additionally, 2 dedicated T1 circuits between the EMC Symmetrix storages at the two sites provide for real-time, synchronized replication of data to the second site using Symmetrix Remote Data Facility (SRDF). The 2 T1s provide redundancy of this connection (see Figure 2). At each facility, two Cisco 2610 routers connect to the corporate office of the Registry over separate T1s. This provides a redundant link to the corporate office for remote monitoring and data transfers.
Secondly, every component at each facility is fully redundant. The architecture provides for no single point of failure. There are two 7206 routers, two Cisco 3526 switches (at each layer), two Cisco Pix firewalls (at each layer), two SRS servers, three Oracle servers (one configured as hot standby), more than two secondary nameservers and two primary nameservers (see Figure 1).
Exodus provides 2 separate links to the Internet. They are from 2 independent service providers. In the event one link fails, data is automatically routed to the other one.
D15.2.12.3 Backup power supply
Exodus provides in-line UPS power with backup generators.
D15.2.12.6 Availability of backup software, operating system, hardware
Exodus will be providing all the Sun servers in the technical infrastructure. They maintain a stock of spare servers and server components for quick replacement in the event of hardware failure. Hard drives loaded with the operating system and pre-configured software for all servers will be maintained to speed up the recovery process after a replacement of the server hardware.
The Registry operator will maintain spares of all Cisco equipment on-site. In the event of a failure, Exodus will replace the defective equipment immediately. As per service level agreements with Cisco and EMC, they will replace defective hardware within 2 hours.
Immediately after installation and initial configuration, a backup will be made of each platform and stored remotely. These will be used in the event of a catastrophe to restore the system to its initial configuration.
D15.2.12.7 System monitoring
System monitoring will be done internally as well as by Exodus and is described in D.15.2.12.1 as well as in the Exodus proposal (see Appendix F).
D15.2.12.8 Technical maintenance staff
For maintenance, Exodus makes available the following list of specialized engineers to perform a range of services (excerpts from the Exodus proposal; see Appendix F):
Network and System Administrator (NE/SA)
Database Administrator (DBA)
Security Administrator
D15.2.12.9 Server locations
Nameservers will be distributed between data centers at Exodus facilities in New York and Santa Clara. This list will be increased to Tokyo and London shortly afterwards.
D15.2.13 System recovery procedures
D15.2.13.1 Procedures for restoring the system to operation in the event of a system outage, both expected and unexpected
The technical infrastructure has redundancy built into every system to eliminate any single point of failure. Therefore, it is nearly impossible that any single hardware failure would disable the Registry. In the highly unlikely event that an entire Exodus data center fails, there is another data center with nameservers to continue serving DNS requests.
In the event of total system outage of the Santa Clara facility, DNS requests will be served by the New York facility. If the outage appears to be long-term, spare equipment at Exodus will be configured and deployed as secondary nameservers to handle DNS queries.
If the entire New York facility fails, dormant back-end equipment at Santa Clara will be activated within 15 minutes to handle SRS and Whois. If the failure is long-term, the zone file generation server and the phantom primary nameservers will also be activated to handle zone file generation and distribution.
If one of the two database servers fails, the hot spare database server will handle the load and keep the system operational.
The Registry will use a combination of Bind 8 and Bind 9 on secondary nameservers. This is to protect against possible bugs in one version. The SRS server software will be developed in-house, but will be extremely simple. Any bug in the software will be detected and fixed during beta testing. Any bug that may surface during production stage will be minor and fixed immediately. All other software used in the system is time-tested and rock-solid.
D15.2.13.2 Identify redundant/diverse systems for providing service in the event of an outage
Please see D15.2.12.2
D15.2.13.3 Describe the process for recovery from various types of failures
Recovery from failures will be predicated on the type of failure. Total location failure has been addressed above.
We will proceed through the architecture highlighting recovery processes for each component.
In the event of failure of a border router, Exodus will instantly detect this and automatically re-route all traffic to the functional router. In addition, Exodus will replace the defective router with a warm spare, maintained on-site by the Registry. Exodus will handle failure of any other Cisco equipment in a similar manner.
Exodus maintains a stock of spare Sun servers and server components for quick replacement in the event of hardware failure. If a server fails, Exodus will replace it within 15 minutes of detecting the failure. Hard drives loaded with the operating system and pre-configured software for all servers will be maintained on-site to speed up the recovery process after a replacement of the server hardware.
Any type of failure, especially of software, will warrant a security audit to ensure no unauthorized access is occurring. The audit will also determine if the failure was related to a security breach.
Each layer of Cisco firewalls, switches and load balancers are duplicated throughout the architecture. In the event that a single piece of equipment fails or an entire set of equipment fails, the second set will continue functioning and maintain all services. At that time, Exodus, EMC or Cisco will respond within SLAs to remedy the situation. For Exodus this is 15 minutes and for Cisco and EMC it is 2 hours.
D15.2.13.4 Training of technical staff who will perform these tasks
We will use Exodus for most of the recovery tasks.
D15.2.13.5 Availability and backup of software and operating systems needed to restore the system to operation
As mentioned in section D15.2.12.6, hard drives loaded with the operating system and pre-configured software for all servers will be maintained to speed up the recovery process after hard drive failure or server replacement.
D15.2.13.6 Availability of the hardware needed to restore and run the system
As detailed in section D15.2.12.6, Exodus maintains a stock of Sun servers that are available for immediately replacing a defective server. Cisco and EMC hardware can be replaced within 2 hours, as per SLA with them.
D15.2.13.7 Backup electrical power systems
Exodus maintains expensive backup power systems.
D15.2.13.8 Projected time for restoring the system
In the worst-case scenario, the entire New York facility could stop functioning. Within 15 minutes of detecting this, the Santa Clara facility could be brought on-line to serve registrars and Whois requests. The secondary nameservers at the Santa Clara facility will be operational at all times to serve DNS requests. In this way, DNS requests will continue to be served even if one of the two data centers completely stops functioning.
D15.2.13.9 Procedures for testing the process of restoring the system to operation in the event of an outage
In the event of a device failure or site failure there is a prescribed set of scripts that are run to ensure all functions are operational.
These scripts will test the various services (DNS, Whois and SRS) to verify operation. These tests run upon the interim configuration and are re-run when the solution has been implemented. It is run during the interim period to ensure services are maintained. They are run again upon problem resolution to verify that operations have resumed as prior to problem. A full set of satisfactory results will be used to compare test results.
Additionally, the Registry will maintain a separate small-scale but fully functioning test registrar setup. In the event of failure, this test facility will verify service delivery.
If the actual procedure is to be tested, the failure is simulated by purposely shutting down a device or service. This can be done by powering down the device or disconnecting a network connection. Once the failure is created, the monitoring services should detect it. The prescribed procedure to remedy the failure is then followed. Finally, after the procedure has been completed, the monitoring service should not detect the failure and the system should be restored. By following this method, every procedure will be tested and updated to make sure it works in the event of an actual failure.
D15.2.13.10 Documentation kept on system outages and on potential system problems that could result in outages
There will be three document trails of system outages and problems. One is through the Exodus Support Services. A second reporting trail is maintained by the relevant internal technology group: security, database, or network infrastructure. Customer Service provides the third set of documentation. This provides for a valuable cross-reference compilation.
The records should contain the equipment/software, type of difficulty, how/who reported and time/date of incident. The follow-up will contain detailed specifics of the incident, steps to resolution (along a prescribed resolution path or other), persons involved in resolution. All logs surrounding the time of incident will be appended to the incident record.
After any significant incident and periodically otherwise, a root cause analysis should be performed to determine if any aspect of the system warrants change. This could be software, architectural, security or a networking change.
D15.2.14 Technical and other support
Since the Registry is dealing only with registrars, little technical support will need to be provided. Nonetheless, a comprehensive support system will be implemented.
D15.2.14.1 Support for registrars
Comprehensive support will be available to registrars. The scope of the support will be: (i) installation of the SRS client, (ii) problems accessing and using the SRS server, and (iii) problems using the Registry.
D15.2.14.2 Support for Internet users
Internet users will be indirectly supported by the Registry through their respective registrars. Support requests will be diverted to registrars. It is assumed that any technical problem in the Registry that could affect Internet users (e.g. unavailability of nameservers) will be detected before it is necessary for Internet users to report it.
D15.2.14.3 Support for Registrants
Registrants will be supported by their respective registrars. The Registry will not be responsible for supporting them. However, the Registry expects to receive support calls and e-mails from registrants. Support e-mails from registrants will be re-directed to the respective registrar based on Whois information. This process will be automated. Any e-mail that does not contain the domain name will be responded with a standard reply instructing the registrant to approach the registrar for support.
D15.2.14.4 Technical help systems
A comprehensive and scalable help desk solution by Siebel will be implemented to provide web-based and e-mail support. It will also be used to manage and track support requests received over the telephone. Siebel is an industry leader in customer support services providing world-class services to a wide client base.
Each call to the help desk will automatically open a trouble ticket in the system visible to the help desk attendant for data entry. The established play book for each type of call is within the system, guiding the help desk attendant to the appropriate action. Exception rules will be established to handle those calls that fall outside the established procedures. Weekly the calls will be reviewed and categorized.
Siebel provides superior reporting capabilities. The review of each week’s calls will provide information valuable to several areas within the Registry. This information will shape the material used for training registrars. It will guide the software architects in their development with respect to services and usability. It will permit the business relationship personnel to more accurately set expectations from new registrars.
D15.2.14.5 Personnel accessibility
At lease one support engineer will be available at all times to support registrars.
D15.2.14.6 Web-based, telephone and other support
Web-based support will be provided using the Siebel help desk software. Registrars can log into the system over the web and open a new trouble ticket. Or, they can search the knowledge base for possible solutions.
Support over telephone will be handled though an interactive voice response (IVR) system. All incoming support requests will be entered into the help desk system. On-site support to registrars will be provided on request in special cases.
D15.2.14.7 Support services to be offered
This is described in section D15.2.14.1.
D15.2.14.8 Time availability of support
Support to registrars will be available 24 x 7.
D15.2.14.9 Language-availability of support.
Initially, support to registrars will be provided in English only. Based on demand, we will implement support in other languages. The help desk solution from Siebel supports 7 other European languages and Japanese.
D15.3 Subcontractors
A significant portion of the technical infrastructure, installation hosting, monitoring, administration and maintenance will be subcontracted to Exodus Communications as per their proposal attached in Appendix F. The scope of the work is:
By signing this Registry Operator's Proposal, the undersigned certifies (a) that he or she has authority to do so on behalf of the registry operator and, on his or her own behalf and on behalf of the registry operator, (b) that all information contained in this proposal, and all documents attached to this proposal, is true and accurate to the best of his/her/its knowledge and information. The undersigned and the registry operator understand that any material misstatement or misrepresentation will reflect negatively on any application of which this proposal is a part and may cause cancellation of any delegation of a top-level domain based on such an application.
______________________________________________
Signature
______________________________________________
Name (please print)
______________________________________________
Title
______________________________________________
Name of Applicant Entity
______________________________________________
Date
Appendices
Appendix A: Sarnoff Technology Venture Companies
AgileVision – Developing a broad line of products for the emerging digital television (DTV) broadcast industry.
Delsys Pharmaceutical Corporation – Uses electrostatic dry powder handling technology to improve the quality, safety, and speed of pharmaceutical tablet manufacturing and other forms of drug delivery.
DIVA – Provides cable TV operators with a complete two-way interactive video-on-demand solution so they can offer their customers instant access to over a thousand movies or other special programming.
E-Vue, Inc. – An MPEG-4 multimedia technology service company that is developing streaming multimedia products for the Internet.
Hitek – Provides manufacturing, engineering, and management support to Sarnoff.
LifeClips, Inc. – Creating products and services that will revolutionize the way people make and view home videos.
Locus Discovery, Inc – Uses proprietary algorithms for drug discovery.
NxtWave Communications – Produces all-digital modulator and demodulator ICs for cable, satellite, broadcast and xDSL systems.
Orchid Biosciences – A leader in the development and commercialization of technologies, products and services designed to measure and use information related to genetic diversity.
PowerZyme – Developing a new proprietary battery technology.
Princeton Lightwave – Designs and manufactures high-performance optical components for advanced network applications.
Pyramid Vision Technologies (PVT) – The world’s highest performance computer vision systems for video production stabilization.
RIVIT – Specializes in radio frequency-based identification (RFID) products & services.
Sarcon Microsystems, Inc. – This company is developing uncooled microcantilever infrared and chemical sensing assemblies for laboratory instruments, industrial monitoring, and commercial security applications.
SARIF, Inc. – Manufactures advanced polysilicon active matrix LCDs for use in projection displays and head-mounted systems.
Secure Products – Develops anti-counterfeiting and anti-diversion systems through unique marking and recognition technology and is the only company with a phosphor-tag security system in US currency.
Sensar, Inc. – Introduced an iris recognition biometric system for financial services applications.
Songbird Hearing Inc. – Developing the world’s first disposable hearing aid.
VideoBrush™ Corporation – VideoBrush and its technology (PC-based software that creates high-resolution or panoramic images from video and digital photographic input) were recently acquired by PictureWorks Technology, Inc.
Wavexpress – Provides technology and services to digital TV broadcasters for the secure ad-supported or pay-for-use distribution of digital information.
Appendix B: Fortune Magazine Cover and Business Week Article on Sarnoff and SRI International
Appendix C: Resumes of Key Sarnoff and AtomicTangerine Managers
Dr. James E. Carnes, President and CEO of Sarnoff Corporation
Dr. James E. Carnes is President and CEO of the Sarnoff Corporation, a subsidiary of SRI International. Sarnoff conducts industry- and government-supported electronics, information and biomedical research and development in areas such as digital HDTV, solid state lasers, integrated circuits, flat panel displays, computer vision, drug discovery tools and drug delivery systems.
Dr. Carnes, who has had 31 years combined service with Sarnoff and its RCA predecessor, became Sarnoff's President in 1990. A recognized authority in the field of charge-coupled devices, he has played a major role in the development of High Definition Television (HDTV) in the U.S. since 1987. He joined RCA Laboratories in 1969 as a Member of the Technical Staff and worked in the area of MOS device structures, particularly CCD technology and applications.
In 1977 he transferred to RCA's Consumer Electronics Division in Indianapolis, where he held a variety of management positions in integrated circuit design and development and TV advanced development. In 1982 he was appointed Division Vice President, Engineering, at the Consumer Electronics Division. He returned to Princeton in 1987 as Vice President, Consumer Electronics and Information Sciences Research when Sarnoff became a subsidiary of SRI International, which is headquartered in Menlo Park, California.
Dr. Carnes has been issued nine U.S. patents and is the author of more than 100 papers and presentations. In 1981 he was a recipient of the David Sarnoff Award for Outstanding Technical Achievement "for the development and implementation of a CCD comb filter integrated circuit in color television receivers."
He received a B.S. degree in Engineering Science from The Pennsylvania State University in 1961. In 1970, he earned a Ph.D. degree in Electrical Engineering from Princeton University. Dr. Carnes is a Fellow of the IEEE and a member of the National Academy of Engineering. He sits on the Board of Directors of the following companies (* indicates a Sarnoff spin-off company):
Sarnoff Corporation (formerly David Sarnoff Research Center), 1990–
SRI International, 1998–
*Sensar, Inc., Chairman, 1992–
*Sarnoff Real Time Corporation, 1993–98
*Sarif, Inc., 1994–
*Delsys Pharmaceutical Corporation, 1994-97
*Orchid Biocomputer, Inc., 1995–99
*NxtWave Communications, Inc., 1996–99
* NOVA Corporation (NYSE: NIS), Atlanta, GA, 1997-98
Dr. Norman D. Winarsky, Managing Partner, Sarnoff Corporation
Norman D. Winarsky is Corporate Vice President of Sarnoff Corporation, responsible for Internet and Multimedia Technologies. Business units within Sarnoff reporting to Dr. Winarsky include the National Information Display Laboratory (NIDL), Vision Technologies, and Computational Science. He is a founder of the National Information Display Laboratory - a center of excellence for the government in information processing and display technologies. He is a recipient of Sarnoff's highest honor, the David Sarnoff Award for Outstanding Technical Achievement.
Dr. Winarsky received the BS, MS, and Ph.D. degrees in Mathematics from the University of Chicago in 1969, 1970, and 1974, respectively, graduating Summa Cum Laude and Phi Beta Kappa. Dr. Winarsky has written over 50 papers and given hundreds of invited talks, lectures, and presentations throughout the world. His primary responsibility is to advance and execute the Sarnoff Internet Strategy.
In the last four years he was also founder of five of Sarnoff’s sixteen spinoffs. These include: SENSAR, Sarnoff’s first spin-off, serving the e-commerce community with iris recognition systems; VideoBrush, providing consumer software that stitches video into still images in real-time (now acquired by PictureWorks); Pyramid Vision Technologies, providing the US government with real-time systems for mosaicking and enhancing video; GreatHomeVideo.com, creating a web community of home video users and WaveXpress, providing television broadcasters the capability to use their digital channels for datacasting. He served as President and CEO of Sensar, Pyramid Vision Technologies, and VideoBrush during their incubation phases. Dr. Winarsky is Chairman of the Board of Pyramid Vision Technologies, and Member of the Boards of GreatHomeVideo.com and WaveXpress.
Glenn A. Reitmeier, General Partner, Sarnoff Corporation
Glenn Reitmeier is Vice President of Internet Technology Strategy and Development at Sarnoff Corporation. His current responsibility is to leverage Sarnoff’s broad technology base to drive new developments in digital media, networking and consumer products and services that will help create the next wave of Internet and digital convergence growth.
His career has pioneered the development of digital television, digital media and digital convergence. He has created and led world-leading developments in Digital Cinema, object coding and wavelet image compression in MPEG-4, MPEG-2 compressed bitstream processing and integrated circuits for digital television receivers. His efforts have contributed to the formation of six new startup companies and resulted in three technical Emmy awards.
Mr. Reitmeier was one of the leading contributors to establishing the ATSC Digital Television standard that was approved by the FCC in 1996. In the Digital HDTV Grand Alliance, he performed in both technical and strategic capacities, and was the leader of Grand Alliance computer interoperability efforts. During the competitive phase of the HDTV process, he led Sarnoff’s team in the development of the Advanced Digital HDTV system, which pioneered the use of layered system architecture, packetized data transport and MPEG compression and multiple formats. These key technical approaches later became the basis for both the Grand Alliance HDTV system and the Hughes/DirecTV Digital Satellite System (DSS). They are also the key innovations that enable data broadcasting and allow digital television to become a powerful new medium.
In addition, he was responsible for creating and leading other Sarnoff programs which combine digital video and computing technologies to create new capabilities for both advanced computer systems and new consumer electronics. He created and led a Sarnoff-Sun-Texas Instruments team in a DARPA funded project to develop a High-Resolution Video Workstation - a real-time video-processing multimedia workstation. He led projects related to improving the performance of consumer television receivers, including signal processing and user interface aspects that have impacted product design. He also led projects related to developing new technologies for consumer information services, including computer and network architectures, Digital Signal Processing modems and natural language software.
Earlier in his career, Mr. Reitmeier was a contributor to the establishment of the world’s first digital television standards (the ITU 601 sampling standard and the D1 tape standard) that are now in widespread use in the broadcast industry. He holds over 40 patents in digital television technology. He received the B.E.E. degree summa cum laude in 1977. He subsequently attended the University of Pennsylvania, and received the M.S.E. degree in Systems Engineering in 1979.
Shailendra K. Suman, Executive Director, Sarnoff; General Partner, nVention
Shailendra K. Suman is Executive Director of Sarnoff Corporation and General Partner of nVention. He is responsible for the business and strategy development, market analysis and strategic alliances for nVention and its ventures.
Mr. Suman received his BS in Mechanical Engineering from B.I.T. Sindri, India, an MS in Control Systems from University of Alabama, and an MBA in Finance and Strategy from University of Minnesota in 1986, 1989, and 1995 respectively. He completed all the coursework towards a Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering at Columbia University, NY in 1989.
Prior to joining Sarnoff, Mr. Suman was Managing Director for PSEG Distributed Generation business unit, where he started and led the business unit in the emerging energy technology market, formed several overseas joint ventures, and developed a sales and marketing strategy to launch e-commerce in the energy industry.
Before coming to PSEG, Mr. Suman held several management positions at Northern States Power Company in Minneapolis. He led the development of the corporate technology strategy plan and was appointed Chairman of the NSP’s Technology Advisory Board. He also managed the development of three new businesses from concept to launch over three years.
Mr. Suman is a member of the Conference Board’s International Council of Innovation & Technology Management and the Institute of Electronics and Electrical Engineers.
Anne VanLent,. President, Ventures and Licensing, Sarnoff Corporation
Anne M. VanLent currently serves as Vice President, Ventures and Licensing at the Sarnoff Corporation, Princeton, New Jersey. Her responsibilities include identifying technologies that can serve as the foundation of new commercial businesses, and helping to assemble the technical, managerial, and financial resources to create those businesses. She also manages and oversees all of the patent and licensing activities of Sarnoff. Sarnoff Corporation specializes in developing world-leading technologies, then moving them rapidly into the marketplace.
Ms. VanLent has extensive experience in founding and building technology-based companies. In addition, she is experienced with emerging growth companies and has a broad background in science, finance, and business development.
Before joining the Sarnoff Corporation in July of 1997, Ms. VanLent was the founder and President of AMV Associates, which provided senior level finance, business development, and operations consulting services to emerging growth life science companies. Prior to that experience she helped found Trophix Pharmaceuticals Inc., a venture-backed neuroscience company, now a part of Allelix Pharmaceuticals, Inc. She also spent eight years as Senior Vice President and CFO of The Liposome Company, Inc. of Princeton, New Jersey.
Her undergraduate degree in physics, conferred with honors and great distinction, was received from Mount Holyoke College. She conducted graduate studies at the Universite de Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France.
Anne currently serves as a director of Penwest Pharmaceuticals Co. (NASDAQ:PPCO), and i-STAT Corporation. (NASDAQ: STAT), Orchid BioSciences, Inc. (NASDAQ: ORCH), and several private emerging growth technology companies.
Nova Spivack, Founder, Lucid Ventures; Entrepreneur in Residence, nVention
Nova Spivack is Founder, President and CEO of Lucid Ventures Inc. and Co-Founder and CEO of Lucid Associates, LLC. He founded Lucid Ventures to develop, fund and incubate proprietary concepts for new Internet ventures. Lucid Associates LLC is a strategic venture development firm that provides high-level business planning, M&A strategic planning, product and technology innovation, industry connections, and venture capital assistance to selected Internet ventures. Mr Spivack has been an Internet venture strategy advisor to Sarnoff Corporation for the past year and a prime mover in their decision to create nVention.
Mr Spivack was a Co-Founder, Executive Vice President , and Director of EarthWeb Inc., an industry-leading Internet venture, since 1994. He co-led the company from startup through an historic IPO (the first business-to-business IPO and one of the all-time best first day gainers) and a secondary public offering. He served as executive vice-president for product development and strategy and was responsible for all research and development, products and services strategy, and business development and marketing for a variety of Internet content services, software products and consulting services. He represented EarthWeb to worldwide press and at key industry events. He gave frequent presentations and keynotes at conferences including Internet World, W3C, Java One, PC Forum, Software Development, International Software Partnering Conference, Seybold Publishing, Practicing Law Institute, WebDeveloper, and many others.
In 1997, Mr Spivack was the Founder of the Java Developer’s Alliance, New York, NY, and he has served as a Board Member and Executive Director since. He conceived of and built the official worldwide organization of Java Users Groups ("JUGs"), which currently includes more than 100 JUGs around the world.
Mr. Spivack was the principle strategic planner responsible for product development, marketing strategy and content planning for sites including: www.gamelan.com, www.developer.com, www.developerdirect.com, www.itknowledge.com, www.chatplanet.com, www.datamation.com, www.htmlgoodies.com, www.intranetjournal.com, www.jars.com, www.javagoodies.com, and www.javascripts.com. He LAO consulted on the development of sites such as www.metmuseum.org, www.bmgmusicclub.com, www.nyse.com, www.reuters.com, and many others.
He authored The Official Gamelan Java Directory book and is co-author/contributor to other books including Intranets Unleashed, PLI First Annual Symposium on Internet Law, and Traveler’s Tales Nepal. He is the principal author of EarthWeb Inc’s S1 IPO Prospectus.
Mr. Spivack is currently developing several new proprietary patents in the areas of GPS technology, Internet television, Wireless consumer electronics, Internet radio, artificial intelligence and augmented reality. He is the principle inventor of multiple fundamental patents related to simulcasting Internet content with television broadcasts for use in entertainment, education, sports, news and information services. These patents were sold to ACTV, Inc., the leading public company in the interactive television industry (IATV on NASDAQ), and are now the foundation of their business.
He has had numerous speaking engagements and panel chairmanships at Internet World, JavaOne, Practicing Law Institute, WebDeveloper, Online Publishing for Magazines, Venture Market East, Seybold, and many others. Topics have included Internet Marketing and Strategy, Frontiers of Java Technology, Frontiers of Web Content, XML Technology, Internet Site Development, Legal Implications of Internet Technologies, Online Publishing Strategies, Online Commerce Strategies, and others.
He has been profiled and/or quoted in Business Week, CNN, CNBC, CBS Evening News, CNN-FN, The New York Times, Washington Post, WIRED Magazine, Chronicle of Philanthropy, Communications Week, Interactive Week, Internet World, Reuters, Newsweek, Red Herring, Silicon Alley Reporter, Interactive Age, Web Week, Java Developer’s Journal, and others.
Mr Spivack is among the top-rated featured "Internet Business Experts" on Expert-central.com, part of the About.com network.
Mr Spivack is a graduate of Oberlin College and International Space University.
Dr. William J. Burke, Vice President, Intellectual Property and Licensing, Sarnoff
William J. Burke is Vice President for Intellectual Property and Licensing for the Sarnoff Corporation.
Dr. Burke joined RCA Laboratories in 1967 as a Member of the Technical Staff. He transferred to RCA Patent Operations in 1978 and was named a Managing Patent Attorney in 1983. In 1987 when the David Sarnoff Research Center was transferred to SRI International by General Electric, he was named Director of Law and Patent Operations as well as Assistant Secretary for the new company. In 1995 he was named Acting General Counsel. In 1997 Dr. Burke was named Vice President, Intellectual Property and Licensing.
His undergraduate degree in Physics is from Boston College and his PhD degree is from Tufts University. Dr. Burke was a National Science Foundation Postdoctoral Fellow at University of Illinois, Urbana. He received his JD from New York Law School.
Dr. Burke is a member of the American Bar Association, American and New Jersey Intellectual Property Law Associations, the American Corporate Counsel Association, and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.
Dr. Burke has participated in the formation of eighteen Sarnoff Technology Ventures and has served as an officer of many of these Ventures. Dr. Burke was also a participant in the Grand Alliance digital HDTV standard setting process in 1996.
Dr. Burke has nine U.S. issued patents and over thirty technical publications.
Dr. Burke has been admitted to the New York Bar, New Jersey Bar, Court of Appeals of the Federal Circuit and Court of Federal Claims and is registered to practice before the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Dr. Rafael Alonso, Head, Computing Systems Research Group, Information Sciences Laboratory, Sarnoff Corporation
Rafael Alonso obtained a Ph.D. in Computer Science from U.C. Berkeley in 1986 where he held an IBM Fellowship. He was a faculty member at Princeton University from 1984 to 1992 where he graduated three doctoral students, obtained several government and industrial grants, and developed two new courses. In 1991 he co-founded the Matsushita Information Technology Laboratory to develop leading edge information and video systems for Panasonic. Dr. Alonso obtained two U.S. patents for his work, and his research team contributed software to a number of products, as well as developed a non-linear editing system prototype shown at the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) Conference. Dr. Alonso is presently Head of Computing Systems Research at Sarnoff Corporation where he oversees research projects in a number of areas including Web-based collaboration tools, online learning, video databases, and development of MPEG encoding algorithms. He is also currently coordinating two product development efforts. Dr. Alonso's current research interests include organizational memory, multimedia database systems, video servers, mobile information systems, and heterogeneous database systems. Dr. Alonso has published over 40 refereed papers, been a member of more than 20 Program Committees, and is currently on the editorial board of several technical journals
Specialized Professional Competence
Database Management Systems: video databases, video server architectures, multimedia indexing, heterogeneous DBMSs, data caching and replication, query optimization, transaction models
Distributed Systems: computer-supported collaborative work (CSCW), file server architectures, load balancing and process migration strategies
Mobile Computing: energy-efficient query compilation, broadcast-based information systems, pen-oriented DBMS interfaces, wireless video.
Representative Research Assignments at Sarnoff Corporation
• Design of a Web-based CSCW system for Distance Learning.
• Design of a hierarchical video database architecture serving video mosaics and video streams to several hundred users. Emphasis on multimedia database indexing and interface design.
• Design of a data repository for disease treatment management. The system performs data integration on multi-source information and carries out several levels of data scrubbing.
• Design of a cable head-end based system providing Internet access from home via a conventional television set and a set-top box.
Dr. James R. Bergen, Head, Information Technologies Initiatives, Sarnoff Corporation
James R. Bergen is an expert in the technologies of image processing, computer vision, visual psychophysics, and visual perception, with special competence in motion and visual texture (from perceptual and algorithmic standpoints), adaptive video signal processing, computer vision, and image analysis systems. A three-time recipient of the David Sarnoff Technical Achievement Award (1983, 1987, 1991), Dr. Bergen has authored or co-authored forty (40) technical publications and book chapters. He holds a BA in Mathematics and Psychology (1975) from the University of California at Berkeley and a PhD in Biophysics and Theoretical Biology (1981) from the University of Chicago. Dr. Bergen was a postdoctoral member of the technical staff at Bell Laboratories in Murray Hill, NJ.
Specialized Professional Competence
Motion and visual texture, from perceptual and algorithmic standpoints
Adaptive video signal processing
Computer Vision
IMAGE Analysis Systems
Representative Research Assignments at Sarnoff Corporation
Theoretical and experimental studies of biological and artificial visual systems
Development of biologically motivated algorithms for image processing
Development of motion analysis algorithms for interpolation and image coding
Design of image analysis software tools
Intellectual property analysis and licensing
Jonathan Fornaci - President and Chief Executive Officer
Jonathan leads the AtomicTangerine executive team and serves as a board member. He has a proven record of visionary leadership gained through years spent in senior-level positions with companies including Luna, IBIS Consulting, GE Capital and Trans Ocean. As chief executive officer of IBIS Consulting, Mr. Fornaci more than doubled revenue and employees in less than 12 months and successfully orchestrated a US $300 million merger with Proxicom. As chief operating officer of Luna, he brought to market the first e-relationship software for Fortune 1000 and Digital 1000 companies.
Mr. Fornaci previously served as chief information and technology officer of a GE Capital services company and as part of the GE Capital corporate staff. During his two years with GE Capital, he directed the company's worldwide systems operations, including development of the company's extranet, Intranet, enterprise applications and WAN. He also facilitated a worldwide reengineering effort for the accounting, operations and sales/marketing departments, and oversaw a major company merger. Mr. Fornaci began his career with four years at Andersen Consulting.
A sought-after speaker, Mr. Fornaci has presented at the IT Metrics Summit (sponsored by the World Research Group), International HR (sponsored by the National Foreign Trade Council), Software 500 Executive Forum, Morgan Stanley Dean Witter Investment Conference, 16th Annual Software Forum, IDG Global Summit Forum, Corporate Intranet, HR Internet '97, Zonerthon Internet Conference, SIMS, Intranet '98 and Global Supply Chain Forum.
He has had articles published in CIO Magazine, Computerworld, Visigenic Profile, TechMall, Software Magazine, The Journal of Commerce, Websheet, Client Server Magazine, Network Computing and Infoworld.
Mr. Fornaci holds a bachelor's degree in physics from the University of California, Berkeley. He also worked as a market maker and holds a number of government security licenses (Series 3, 7 and 63).
Dr. Yadunath Zambre, Ph.D., Chief Technology Officer, AtomicTangerine
Yadunath Zambre is chief technology officer of AtomicTangerine. He specializes in speech recognition and computer networking technologies and is currently working with the Nuance speech recognition system. He periodically teaches graduate classes on digital multimedia technology at Stanford University, where his students have done projects ranging from Java-based Internet shopping applications to voice control for networked virtual environments. Dr. Zambre has also been an invited speaker on Internet technology and its applications at international scientific conferences and at artists’ guild workshops in Hollywood.
Dr. Zambre has applied and integrated new and old technologies in a wide variety of settings. He has experience programming Sun, VAX, Xerox, IBM, and PC systems with C/C++, Java, Fortran, and assembler.
Major accomplishments have included:
Before joining AtomicTangerine and, previously, SRI International, Dr. Zambre cofounded a company that wrote software for diagnosing and analyzing errors in particle accelerators. The software was sold to international and U.S. laboratories and, on average, has reduced accelerator downtime by a factor of five. In many cases, the resulting cost reduction per incident exceeds US $200,000.
Dr. Zambre holds a B.S. (cum laude) and M.S. (awarded simultaneously with the B.S.) in engineering from Yale University, and a Ph.D. in applied physics from Stanford University.
Sterling F. Stoudenmire IV, Vice President, Digital Enterprises, AtomicTangerine
Sterling Stoudenmire is the vice president of AtomicTangerine’s Digital Enterprises practice, headquartered in Menlo Park, California. He has more than 11 years of experience in strategy and information technology consulting, and has worked with numerous dot-com clients in the formation, capitalization and emergent stages. Sterling offers clients a unique combination of business acumen across a variety of industries as well as expertise in emerging technologies. He frequently serves as overall architect for new business opportunities.
Mr. Stoudenmire’s representative experience includes:
Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Stoudenmire served as director, e-business strategy, for Arthur Andersen. He is a frequent public speaker on e-business, information rules, and "innovation through information technology" for organizational change and competitive advantage. Past audiences include the World Economic Forum, AA’s E-Business Video Series, and the Florida Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
Mr. Stoudenmire holds a B.S. in finance from Florida State University.
Dr. Norm Nielsen, Technology Director, AtomicTangerine
Norm Nielsen is a technology director in AtomicTangerine’s Menlo Park office and leader of its Emerging Technologies Center of Excellence. He has worked extensively with major corporations on four continents to assess and deploy cutting-edge information technology to achieve strategic business objectives and improve profitability. Dr. Nielsen specializes in computer systems design and architecture evaluation, information security and risk assessments, intrusion detection systems, information technology assessment and strategy, speech recognition system design and development.
Dr. Nielsen has led numerous projects that assisted companies in using information technology to strategic advantage. Representative experience includes:
Before joining AtomicTangerine and, previously, SRI International, Dr. Nielsen served as a faculty member at Stanford University. He is listed in Who’s Who in America and Who’s Who in Science and Engineering and is a member of Phi Beta Kappa and other national honor societies. In addition to serving as treasurer of AAAI, he is a member of AAAS, the ACM, the Computer Society of the IEEE, and INFORMS. Dr. Nielsen has authored more than 75 articles and papers on information technology topics, and has written two books relating to the practical application of artificial intelligence technology.
Dr. Nielsen holds a B.A. in mathematics (summa cum laude) from Pomona College, an MBA in management science and a Ph.D. in operations and systems analysis from Stanford University.
Sanjay Deo, Director of Technology, Digital Enterprises
Sanjay Deo is director of technology for the Digital Enterprises market unit in AtomicTangerine’s Menlo Park, California, office. He has more than 10 years of experience in software development—custom as well as product—and has provided management consulting services to startups, spin-offs, and brick-and-mortar clients in the information services, telecommunications, entertainment, health care and high-tech industry sectors.
Mr. Deo’s specific expertise lies in building B2B digital marketplaces and Internet security. He is also experienced in IT strategy, technology assessment, systems design and integration, and process innovation.
Representative experience includes:
Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Deo was director of the Advanced Technology Group in Arthur Andersen’s Business Consulting practice. In previous work, he was with CyberGuard Corporation, where he focused on design and implementation of high-assurance operating systems, and architected three firewalls for three operating systems.
Mr. Deo holds a B.E. in computer engineering from the University of Bombay and an M.S. in computer science from Texas A&M, College Station, Texas.
Donald Holden, CISSP, Business Leader, Information Security
Don Holden is a business leader who specializes in information security. He has more than 20 years of experience in information systems, security, encryption, business continuity and disaster recovery planning.
Mr. Holden has written numerous white papers and given presentations on information security management and technology issues such as intrusion detection, firewalls, biometric authentication and digital watermarking. He is currently the chairman of the IEEE Computer Society working group on recommended best practices for Internet security. He is also participating in the development of security standards for the financial industry.
Mr. Holden’s major achievements have included the following:
Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Holden was a senior consultant for SRI Consulting, where he was a project leader for an Internet startup assignment to plan a revolutionary secure electronic commerce portal-based business. Mr. Holden previously served as program manager for Compaq’s Security Program Office, where he led the Compaq Security Forum that coordinated the decentralized security engineering, marketing and consulting initiatives across Compaq, Digital, Tandem and Atalla divisions. He represented Compaq in the BioAPI Consortium and the International Information Integrity Institute (I-4). Don also was the director of operations research at a major Boston bank, where he developed business models and implemented an internal decision support system. He has also had assignments as an auditor with the U.S. Air Force Audit Agency and as a disaster preparedness officer with Federal Emergency Management Agency.
Mr. Holden holds an M.B.A. from Wharton and a B.S. in business and accounting from Georgetown University. He is a Certified Information System Security Professional and a member of the IEEE Computer Society, the Computer Security Institute, and the Information Systems Security Association.
Stephen Whitlock, Technology Leader, AtomicTangerine
Stephen Whitlock is a technology leader in AtomicTangerine’s Seattle/Tacoma office. He specializes in the cryptography, Unix and network security. Stephen is an internationally recognized expert in the field of information security. His background includes the development of tools for testing system security as well as publications and presentations on cryptography, Unix and network security. For many years, he functioned as an internal corporate consultant on cryptographic and security issues.
Representative experience includes:
Before joining AtomicTangerine, Mr. Whitlock was an advanced computing technologist in the mathematics and computing technology division of Boeing’s Phantom Works.
He has been an active participant in the security activities of the Electronic Messaging Association, Internet Engineering Task Force, Key Recovery Alliance, Object Management Group and the Open Group. He is currently the chair of the Open Group’s Security and Electronic Commerce Program Group and as such has been involved in the development of several standards, including the Architecture for a Public Key Infrastructure, Common Data Security Architecture and Advanced Authorization API.
Mr. Whitlockholds a B.S. in electronic engineering technology from the Weber State University and an M.S. in software engineering from Seattle University
Laura A. Bilodeau, Business Leader, AtomicTangerine
Laura Bilodeau specializes in market strategy, business modeling, and financial analysis for entrepreneurial ventures as well as Fortune 500 companies. In particular, she focuses on the use of quantitative techniques and market assessment to validate the business plans for new e-commerce ventures.
Ms. Bilodeau’s accomplishments include the following:
Before joining AtomicTangerine, Ms. Bilodeau was a consultant in the telecommunications practice at A.T. Kearney. Previously she worked at D.E. Shaw & Company, a proprietary trading firm in New York, where she was responsible for conducting financial analysis and due diligence for potential new ventures.
Ms. Bilodeau holds a B.A. in astrophysics from Princeton University and an MBA from the Wharton School of Business.
Appendix D: Letter of Reference in Support of TLD Application
Subject: Compaq support
Date: Mon, 25 Sep 2000 17:35:42 -0400
From: "McKie, Ted" <Ted.McKie@compaq.com>
To: "'Shailendra Suman'" <ssuman@sarnoff.com>
CC: "Zia, Sultan" <Sultan.Zia@compaq.com>,"Mahoney, Steve"
<Steve.Mahoney@compaq.com>,"Desai, Mitesh" <Mitesh.Desai@compaq.com>
Mr. Suman,
This letter is an expression of interest on behalf of Compaq Computer Corporation to work with Sarnoff should Sarnoff be selected for award of a new TLD contract under the referenced Application Process with ICANN.
Compaq will be pleased to work with Sarnoff in a variety of capacities which include being part of the consortium that would serve to further the adoption of the new TLD, help create open standards, develop applications, and/or some other arrangement as appropriate and mutually agreeable to both Sarnoff and Compaq under reasonable terms and conditions to be negotiated.
Specifically, Compaq is interested in working in the field of enabling our hand-held devices to work seamlessly with DNS and the purpose of the new TLD and extending enterprise and service provider infrastructures to support this new functionality.
Compaq hereby grants Sarnoff its permission to use Compaq's name, logo,
And a copy of this letter in Sarnoff's proposal for a TLD being submitted to ICANN in response to the above referenced Application Process. Compaq also grants Sarnoff its permission to use its name in connection with marketing to ICANN under the referenced process.
Sincerely yours,
Ted McKie
Director of Business Development
Compaq Computer Corporation
Appendix E: Letters of Interest from Cap Gemini Ernst & Young US, LLC, Ernst & Young LLP and Ruder Finn
Appendix F: Subcontractor Proposal from Exodus Communications