[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[Comment-Dnso] A big Problem with the ISP constituency
Dear Mr. Schneider,
In any event, I feel that all this is ultimately immaterial,
as you are
perfectly free to join DNSO's ISP constituency if you believe
not able to speak for Spain.
Frankly, I'm tired of
The point is that not EuroISPA nor ASIMELEC represent
countries, they just
represent their members.
problem still remains. The way the ISP constituency has been
>> most of us are excluded from the founding members and it is
up to you to
>> decide who joins and who does
>I would not dream of doing that.
This is not
what the documents that you have sent-in say. You are
>> Now, two very direct and public
>> Are the signatories of your draft
prepared to open the document for a
>> comment period or
>Of course. Please read the 1st sentence of the Intro's 2nd
>>> In the view of the undersigned, this document
will until its
>the ICANN Board remain the basis for
further discussion and revisions. <<
By the original closed group
of signatories? Who decides on changes?
>> Are they prepared to
accept as founding members all those who wish to be
(if they have a stake in the ISP business).
You are again contradicting
the official documents that you have sent in.
The document says that the
closed group of founding memebers will decide if
you accept new members or
not, plus, you will give yourselves three months
to do so, allowing
yourselves to keep organizations out for the first
like to see (officially, meaning in a new version of the draft)
things that you promise in your e-mail:
1) A way of joining the group of
2) An official way for comments to be sent in to the
founding members about
changes in the document.
3) A way in which founding
members discuss among them the differenet issues.
Then, when we see that
we have the minimum conditions for open process, we
can start discussing
issues such as how the draft might be excluding small
ISPs, which would be
unnaceptable to ICANN, as these companies would be
participation in the DNSO in any other way, and therefore
Unless we see a clear answer to all this very quickly (in a
application), we will be forced, as I already warned you, to write
democratic charter and bring it to Berlin for discussion.